Welcome to Day 3 of baseball’s winter meetings and Day 45 (estimated) of the Andrew McCutchen saga.

On Tuesday night, Chelsea Janes of the Washington Post reported that the Nationals, after offering top outfield prospect Victor Robles to the White Sox as part of their rejected package for Chris Sale, weren’t interested in doing the same for anyone, McCutchen included.

That makes sense. Robles is a top-10 overall prospect and rising, and Sale had more value than McCutchen. No shame there; as a 27-year-old, Cy Young-caliber starter signed to a reasonable deal through 2019, Sale had more value than just about anyone.

So, logic dictates, the McCutchen discussions would center around young starters like Lucas Giolito, Reynaldo Lopez and Joe Ross. Giolito leads the way there; MLB.com had him as the third overall prospect at last season’s midpoint.

Advertise with us

If that’s your lead return, you’ve done well for yourself. Except, from MASN late Wednesday morning, there was this:

The latest is the Nationals apparently balked at an offering that included Robles and right-hander Lucas Giolito, a source with knowledge of the discussions confirmed.

The Pirates are looking for at least three players in return for the All-Star outfielder, and that package could include a mix of prospects and a player with major league experience. The Dodgers have also inquired about McCutchen.

So, not only do the the Nationals not want to offer Robles to anybody for anything, but the Pirates are looking for a a return that includes not just him, but the best right-handed starter prospect in baseball.

It’s possible that neither are true. And it shows just how much stuff flies around during times like these. We’re not going to know the outcome until the outcome. So it goes.

Roethlisberger: McCutchen 'great for the city and the team'