Evaluating the first half of the Pirates’ season requires some digging. Their record (44-42 entering the weekend series vs. Chicago) and run differential (minus-2; 398 scored, 400 allowed) suggest mediocrity. But at times they played like one of the best teams in the league, and at times they played like the worst.

After subpar marks in June, the Pirates turned in some of their best work as the All-Star break approached. They took a seven-game winning streak into their series finale against the St. Louis Cardinals Thursday. Six of those victories occurred after the Pirates had fallen behind. The bullpen began resembling bullpens of Pirates teams past. The Pirates pulled within shouting distance of the Chicago Cubs and moved to three games out of a wild-card spot.

“We’ve got a lot of talent, we’ve got a lot of swagger going now,” Jon Niese said. “It feels good to win. Just as you can say losing’s contagious, so is winning. It’s a lot of fun right now. Hopefully we can keep it rolling.”

So out comes the red pen as we grade the Pirates’ first half. Grades are based on the Pirates’ performance in relation to other teams in Major League Baseball and the National League. Statistics are through Thursday’s games.

Advertise with us

Offense

The Pirates have scored 4.63 runs per game, which ranks sixth in the NL. Their .264 batting average ranks fourth in the league, as does their offensive Wins Above Replacement (13.4). They fulfilled a spring training goal by posting a .336 on-base percentage, good for second in the league.

Their OPS+ (on-base plus slugging percentage, adjusted for league and park effects) is 100, meaning exactly league average. They are scoring their runs without the benefit of much power: They have hit 80 homers, 12th in the league, and their .411 slugging percentage is in the middle of the pack at seventh.

They are also producing without the usual contributions from Andrew McCutchen, their former MVP and five-time All-Star who has struggled this season. McCutchen is hitting .238/.312/.401 and striking out 24.8 percent of the time, almost 7 percent more than his career rate.

His fellow outfielders have picked him up. Starling Marte is hitting .318 with 25 steals and excellent defense. Gregory Polanco has 12 homers and a team-high 38 walks to go with his .291 average. Throw in solid production from John Jaso and David Freese, and bench contributions from Matt Joyce and Sean Rodriguez, and the offense has weathered McCutchen’s drop-off well.

Advertise with us

Grade: B

Defense

We evaluate defense with the understanding that partial-season advanced defensive metrics are not the surest indicator of a player or team’s true skill. Such variance is how Jordy Mercer, a good defensive shortstop, can grade out with minus-seven Defensive Runs Saved, according to Baseball Info Solutions. That’s the worst rate on the team.

The Pirates as a team have 14 DRS, 10th- most in MLB. According to Fangraphs’ calculation of Ultimate Zone Rating, the Pirates have allowed five runs more than the average team, 16th in MLB.

When the opponent puts the ball in play, the Pirates turn it into an out 68.9 percent of the time, tied for 11th in baseball.

Advertise with us

Marte leads the team with nine DRS. Polanco has saved five runs above average and Jaso, the converted catcher playing first base, grades out exactly average. Mercer’s number is probably an aberration, but McCutchen is six runs below average, according to Baseball Info Solutions.

Grade: C+

Starting pitching

Now for the problem children. Francisco Liriano and Jeff Locke have ERAs north of 5.00, with Niese coming in at 4.87. The rotation allows a .269 batting average against, second-worst in the league, and their 8.8 percent walk rate is 12th. Liriano led all of baseball in walks.

“We haven’t thrown the ball the way we’re capable of throwing it,” Locke said. “I guess that’s what we can look for on the bright side because we do have another half of baseball coming up.”

Advertise with us

Short outings have overburdened the bullpen. The Pirates starters have pitched 4731⁄3 innings, more than only four out of 15 NL teams. They have a 4.75 ERA (11th in the NL) as a unit and have allowed 1.33 homers per nine innings, better than only the Cincinnati Reds in the NL.

“Do I want to be sitting here with a 5.00 ERA and not throwing the ball that well? No, not at all,” Locke said. “But I know that when we start throwing the ball, it’s extremely contagious when guys start putting together good starts. We’ve just got to roll a few good ones together.”

Grade: D

Relief pitching

The relievers hit the books hard in the past two weeks. In June their ERA was 4.25. In July? An NL-best 0.64, two runs allowed in 28 innings through seven games. The bullpen had allowed one run in its previous 451⁄3 innings of work through Thursday.

Advertise with us

“I would say that the numbers say we’ve been putting the bullpen all together,” Arquimedes Caminero said. “We’ve been doing our best and the results are going to come out.”

Mark Melancon has been his typical spectacular self. In 38 games he pitched to a 1.27 ERA and 26 saves. Tony Watson overcame early issues to reduce his ERA to 2.92 and his opponent batting average to .186. Caminero completely reversed his season trajectory, and the relief unit dragged its ERA down to 3.74, fifth in the NL.

“The bullpen’s been incredible of late,” Locke said Wednesday. “I had no idea they’d been as sharp as they’d been until they said it on TV tonight. It’s tremendous. That’s tremendous, to hand the ball over to those guys.”

But the bullpen’s 18.8 percent strikeout rate still ranks last in the NL, and their 0.6 WAR ranks 13th. The rotation’s short starts meant too much exposure for middle relievers Kyle Lobstein, Rob Scahill and Cory Luebke.

Grade: C+

Advertise with us

Coaching staff

If you are what your record says you are, then the Pirates are in the range of a C: Their .512 winning percentage is tied for 17th in MLB.

Hitting coaches Jeff Branson and Jeff Livesey deserve credit for successfully implementing an approach that prioritizes reaching base and scoring runs without homers.

Manager Clint Hurdle did his level best navigating a tired bullpen and a seemingly perpetually banged-up roster in June. Hurdle angers fans with minutiae – substituting Sean Rodriguez for John Jaso on defense, bringing in this reliever rather than that one – but on balance does well with the roster he has. With three catchers and two starters on the disabled list, the team has weathered the storm.

Determining how much to mark down pitching coach Ray Searage and bullpen coach Euclides Rojas is tough – they’re not the ones pitching – but the staff has taken a step back. That was inevitable, as repeating last year’s exceptional run prevention was unlikely. But despite recent improvement, the body of work from the first half has been below league average (4.35 ERA as a staff; league average is 4.16).

Advertise with us

Grade: C+

Front office

Pirates brass aced some courses and struggled with others. They nailed the acquisition of Jaso, seeing a viable first baseman in a former catcher and designated hitter and an unconventional yet effective leadoff hitter. For $3 million, David Freese is hitting .296/.374/.473 with nine homers, playing good defense at two positions and providing a positive effect in the clubhouse. Bringing back Rodriguez and signing Joyce improved the bench.

The Pirates also completed two in-season contract extensions. Francisco Cervelli will be a Pirate for three more years and the club created cost certainty with Polanco during his breakout year.

Their pitching choices haven’t worked as well. In replacing A.J. Burnett, J.A. Happ, Antonio Bastardo, Joe Blanton and Joakim Soria with Niese, Juan Nicasio, Ryan Vogelsong and Luebke, the staff has regressed (though Neftali Feliz has been great).

Advertise with us

Nicasio has looked better out of the bullpen, where he doesn’t have to worry about turning over the lineup and Hurdle can minimize his exposure to lefties. Perhaps the Pirates should have put him there out of spring, but what would that have said to Pirates players, present and future, if the team ignored such dominant spring play?

Four pitching prospects have made their major league debuts and pitched well, speaking to the work done in the farm system and organizational depth.

Grade: C+

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.