Thursday’s Major League Baseball amateur draft will make dreams come true for thousands of players, infuse farm systems with talent — and produce one last data point.

The draft, which begins at 7 p.m. on MLB Network, will provide the fifth and final referendum on the slotting system and bonus pools that have governed spending for the past four years. The current collective bargaining agreement, which introduced these rules, expires after this season. Negotiations between MLB and the Major League Baseball Players Association will likely at least address, if not alter, the draft process, which brought with it some unintended consequences.

The Pirates have the 22nd overall selection after finishing with the second-best record in baseball last season. They also own the 41st selection, a so-called competitive balance pick, available via a lottery to teams in the 10 smallest markets or teams with the 10 smallest revenue pools. Their signing bonus pool, according to MLB.com, is $7,007,900.

How do we arrive at that figure? What is its purpose? And what effects has the system had?

Advertise with us

“You draft for talent and you negotiate aggressively, is essentially what the new system has put in place for those teams that aren’t in the top 10 picks or even the top five picks or don’t have a bunch of compensation picks,” Pirates general manager Neal Huntington said. “You’re really hamstrung by the new system.”

MLB assigns a monetary value to every pick in the top 10 rounds of the 40-round draft. This year, that value ranges from $9,015,000 for the first overall pick, owned by the Philadelphia Phillies, to $1,878,000 for the St. Louis Cardinals with the last pick of the first round, to $156,600 for the Cardinals’ 10th-round pick. The sum of the values for a team’s picks in the first 10 rounds equals its bonus pool. Spend more than that pool, and pay a tax on the overage; spend too much more and forfeit a future first-round pick.

The idea was partially to remove a player’s “signability,” how easy a player would be to sign or how much money he was demanding, from the equation and let teams pick the best player on their board. Pirates fans who remember Daniel Moskos going ahead of Matt Wieters can sympathize. To some extent, it has succeeded.

“It seems like more and more teams are taking the player they want to take, that they think is important, and fewer and fewer guys are sliding because of perceived signability,” Huntington said.

Many thought lower signing bonuses would send more high school players to college rather than pro ball. But if that were the case, this year’s college crop – the high school class of 2013 – should be stacked, and it’s not, at least pitching-wise.

Advertise with us

“The truth of the matter is, from our perspective, the college arms that you can project as quality starting pitchers probably is not what it once was,” Huntington said.

But the bonus pools also reduced leverage for amateur players who aren’t yet part of the union and cannot choose their employer, tied separate draft picks together, limited small-market teams’ access to talent and contributed to clubs fielding non-competitive teams.

The Pirates dealt with this first-hand in 2012, the first draft under the new system, when they drafted Stanford righty Mark Appel eighth overall. The most the Pirates could offer Appel without forfeiting a future draft pick was $3.8 million, and he said no thanks and went back to school.

The Houston Astros took Brady Aiken, a high school lefty, first overall in 2014 and agreed to terms on a $6.5 million bonus, about $1.4 million less than the $7,922,100 slot value. Some of that saved money was to be diverted to Jacob Nix, a high school righty taken in the fifth round, to sign him away from his UCLA commitment. The Astros found something they didn’t like about Aiken’s ulnar collateral ligament, the tissue that is repaired by Tommy John surgery, during Aiken’s physical, and as a result reduced their offer to $3,168,840 – 40 percent of the slot value, the minimum offer required for the Astros to receive a compensation pick in the following year’s draft if they didn’t sign Aiken.

Aiken didn’t sign. (He eventually had Tommy John surgery last March; the Cleveland Indians drafted him 17th overall in 2015 and gave him a $2,513,280 bonus.) Under the bonus pool rules, not signing Aiken meant the $7,922,100 assigned to his slot vanished and the Astros had no money for the $1.5 million bonus they and Nix agreed upon. He didn’t sign, either.

Advertise with us

The Astros lost more than 100 games in 2011, ’12 and ’13, and they picked first in the draft in each of the following years. They are hardly the only team to see the benefit of losing games to draft higher, thus receiving access to better players and larger bonus pools with which to sign them. The Atlanta Braves, Philadelphia Phillies (deceiving current record aside), Cincinnati Reds and San Diego Padres are well on their way to high picks in next year’s draft.

What could change in the next CBA? MLBPA executive director Tony Clark addressed in February the concept of a lottery, telling the Associated Press, “It will be beneficial to look at that.” Such a system could reduce the incentive for teams to tank. Alleviating the connection between separate draft picks, like Aiken and Nix, could prevent collateral damage, as could increasing the minimum bonus offer required to receive a compensation pick. Altering the penalties — no team has spent enough to forfeit a draft pick, as teams realize the value of first-round selections — could stock more farm systems with better talent.

Huntington has a conduit to the commissioner’s office: Pirates chairman Bob Nutting is on MLB’s executive council.

“We’ve had a ton of conversations about things that we think could improve from a global perspective, that benefit the industry, not just the Pirates,” Huntington said. “We’ve generally tried to take a bigger-picture approach, here are some things that seem to be a little bit out of line in the industry right now, that could be adjusted, that should be adjusted, for the benefit of whichever party it benefits.”

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.