Gregory Polanco needed more information before he committed to forgoing at least one and possibly as many as three years of free agency, three years in which the market would help to determine his salary and he could choose where he played.

A year and a half in Pittsburgh provided enough.

“I waited for the right time,” Polanco said. “Now that I know the city. … I like to play here. I love to be here.”

Contracts like the one Polanco signed this week, a five-year extension with $35 million guaranteed that could be worth $60 million with option years and incentives, benefit teams because they provide cost certainty through arbitration years and lock in free-agent years, likely at salaries below market value.

Advertise with us

SportsNow: Pirates quick out of the gates

They also aid the player, in ways that go beyond the tens of millions of guaranteed dollars. The player must decide two things: Is this the right balance of guaranteed money against future earning potential, and is this a place I want to be for the next several years?

Polanco isn’t the only Pirate who has had to ask those questions in recent years.

“I could see it just in the culture of how the clubhouse is, guys around the clubhouse,” said infielder Josh Harrison, who last April signed a four-year extension which includes two club options. “I’m not saying — I wasn’t here in the big leagues in 2008, 2009, 2010 — but … I don’t think it really takes anybody to be a genius to understand the difference in the clubhouse from those years. They were going through a trying time. Now, we’ve got a good core group.”

In 2012, Andrew McCutchen signed a six-year extension, with a club option for 2018. Starling Marte received a six-year extension in 2014, with club options for 2020 and 2021. Of McCutchen, Marte, Harrison and Polanco, only Harrison was eligible for salary arbitration.

“I’m very excited to be here, to stay here for a long time,” Polanco said this week.

Advertise with us

A guaranteed salary rather than one subject to the comparison-based arbitration system can help players relax. They don’t need to press trying to rack up statistics or worry about injury.

“I told [Polanco], just like when it happened to me, it’s good to get it out of the way,” McCutchen said. “Now you can go and you can really relax and just play the game. I honestly think that’s kind of helped him. He’s going to be able to just go out and not worry. He’s financially set, and I’m looking forward to him being able to be the player that we know he can be.”

After signing his extension, McCutchen put forth what might be his best season to date and finished third in the MVP voting in 2012. He won the award the following year and has finished in the top five for four years in a row.

Extensions for players without much service time offer insurance — from injury and poor performance — as well as security.

“That question [could a player have waited and gotten more money] gets asked, I get it,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “What happens when the player gets hurt? Does that same person that asked the question care? That the career gets shortened by five years, that he never even gets close to his potential? That something completely out of his hands gets taken away from him?

Advertise with us

“My perspective is, it’s a really good thing. For the player, for the organization, I know our union has its own thoughts. I don’t think you have to maximize everything in life when there’s that kind of risk involved.”

The Major League Baseball Players Association helps to inform the player and his representatives what they could stand to earn, given what other players of similar age, service time and performance make.

“Any time that situation arises, you just want anybody going through that to understand that ultimately the decision is yours,” Harrison said. “Don’t get caught up into what other people say or what people may think. At the end of the day, you’ve got to do what’s comfortable for you and what you think is best for you and your family.

“No matter what, people are going to say, ‘He should have waited.’ People probably said that about Cutch. Does he seem affected?”

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.