NASHVILLE, Tenn. — In a thin reliever market, the Pirates hold one of the best available.
The Pirates don’t need to trade closer Mark Melancon, who led all of baseball with 51 saves in 2015. But Melancon is one of the few impact relievers who remains on the market. The San Diego Padres already traded Craig Kimbrel to the Boston Red Sox. The Detroit Tigers already have traded for Francisco Rodriguez. Darren O’Day, the top free-agent reliever, has agreed to terms to return to the Baltimore Orioles. The New York Yankees could trade closer Andrew Miller, but that is far from certain.
“Any time the market gets smaller and you still have a guy, there tends to be interest from those teams that have just recently lost out,” Pirates general manager Neal Huntington said on Day 1 of the winter meetings at the Gaylord Opryland Resort and Convention Center here.
“We like Mark. We’re not looking to move Mark. But if it’s the right situation, and it makes sense for us, as we will with just about any player, it’s something we’d go forward with.”
Though several media reports indicated the Cincinnati Reds were nearing an agreement to trade Aroldis Chapman to the Los Angeles Dodgers, a Yahoo sports report Monday night detailing Chapman's alleged involvement in a domestic incident with his girlfriend has thrown any deal in doubt. Major League Baseball will investigate the incident, Yahoo reported.
Why trade Melancon, a two-time All-Star with the Pirates who helped them go 84-1 in 2015 when leading after eight innings? He will be a free agent after next season and could make as much as $10 million in his final year of arbitration, which might commit 10 percent of the Pirates’ payroll to a 70-inning pitcher. They might want to re-allocate that money toward the rotation.
Read More
With or without Melancon, the Pirates return most of their position players on a team that won 98 games in 2015 and have a window to contend in the next year or two with Andrew McCutchen, Neil Walker, Francisco Cervelli and Francisco Liriano. For now, the Pirates have a strong back-end tandem of Melancon and Tony Watson, something more teams are trying for as starting pitching becomes more and more expensive.
“We’ve been well aware we were fortunate to have a tandem at the back end where if we were supposed to win a game, we did,” Huntington said. “… One of the main reasons we may end up holding Mark is those two guys have been about as good as you can be over the last handful of years.”
Of course, by being the last team holding a trade chip, the Pirates could see Melancon’s value decrease if there are fewer potential suitors.
Though the Pirates could move Melancon, they continue to search for starting help and a left-handed reliever. Wei-Yin Chen, Mike Leake, Scott Kazmir, Justin Masterson, Doug Fister, Yovani Gallardo and Ian Kennedy remain on the starting-pitching market, with several teams possibly in a position to deal starters.
“Pitching is a game of attrition, and you never have enough of it,” Huntington said. “Every team is looking to add starting pitching, except maybe one.”
Though the Pirates pick 26th in the 2016 draft and won the 38th overall pick in the competitive-balance lottery, Huntington cautioned against signing players attached to draft picks after declining qualifying offers — such as Chen, Gallardo and Kennedy. He said the Pirates had the financial means to sign a pitcher.
“We will utilize whatever flexibility we have, and there’s no bar set on what we can or can’t do in terms of a max,” Huntington said.
The Pirates have interest in Masterson, according to a source, who joins Fister, Kyle Kendrick and Henderson Alvarez in the category of reclamation projects or injured pitchers with upside. The Pirates have had success with such pitchers, Huntington said, making the club attractive to agents and players who want to rebuild their value.
“I know if I were a pitcher, I’d be paying us to come pitch here,” Huntington joked. “The return on investment is significant. Unfortunately, it doesn't work that way. We haven’t found that player yet, but we'll keep looking.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.