Jarrod Dyson had a .651 on-base plus slugging percentage in 290 plate appearances for the Kansas City Royals in 2014. He had four hits in 33 at-bats in September. Yet there was Dyson, scoring the tying run in the bottom of the ninth in the American League wild-card game.
The Royals won that game in 12 innings. They reached the World Series and lost in Game 7 with the tying run on third. Dyson was an important reason they got to keep playing, and an example of how the elimination aspect of the wild-card game changes not only how teams play the game but also how they construct their roster.
The Pirates will play in their third consecutive wild-card game Wednesday night, against the Chicago Cubs at PNC Park. They’ve had two shots at setting a roster to cover every contingency and two games to make decisions against the backdrop of heading home for the rest of October.
Hurdle has seen his share of elimination games, starting as a player, when he went 5 for 12 in the 1980 World Series that his Royals lost to the Philadelphia Phillies. He managed the Colorado Rockies during their 2007 postseason run, which included a tiebreaking Game 163. His Rockies won that game in the 13th inning, a Jamey Carroll sacrifice fly providing the winning run. Carroll, like Dyson, entered as a pinch-runner.
“You have to make sure the players are aware of the urgency that could come with an elimination game, because things are done a little differently,” Hurdle said.
Roster construction
Read More
The Pirates and Cubs must set a 25-man roster by Wednesday morning, but the winner can set another, different roster for the NLDS.
“You try to think of any possible situation and try to find a player that can help you win a game in that situation,” general manager Neal Huntington said. “You don’t need four starting pitchers on your [wild-card] roster, yet you want some length, somebody that can come in in case a pitcher comes up short before the game or takes a ball off the knee in the second inning and can’t continue.”
The Pirates put Gerrit Cole, the starter this year, on the 2013 wild-card roster in case something happened to Francisco Liriano. Last year, after Cole pitched the final game of the season, Vance Worley and Jeff Locke were on the roster to back up Edinson Volquez.
The Pirates carried three catchers the previous two years, something most teams don’t do in the regular season, but two previous wild-card games displayed the benefits. Oakland Athletics catcher Geovany Soto hurt his thumb last year, requiring Derek Norris to replace him; what if something happened to Norris? And Texas Rangers manager Ron Washington moved Mike Napoli behind the plate in 2012 — causing the Rangers to lose the DH in the process — when he removed Soto, then playing for the Rangers, for a pinch-hitter.
Pirates blog: How to get Jake Arrieta
“If I have to send Sean Rodriguez behind home plate in that game I might as well just walk out of the building,” Hurdle said.
Keeping three starters off the roster frees teams to add more fringe bench players — left-handed hitters for late-inning matchups, defensive replacements or pinch-runners. The Royals stole seven bases in the 2014 wild-card game, two of them from pinch-running burners Dyson and Terrance Gore. Dyson stole third in the ninth, allowing him to score on a sacrifice fly. The Baltimore Orioles used Lew Ford and Robert Andino as pinch-runners against the Rangers in 2012. Both scored.
The Pirates put three left-handed relievers (in addition to Locke) on their 2014 wild-card roster, two in 2013. Against a Cubs roster featuring left-handed hitters Anthony Rizzo, Kyle Schwarber, Miguel Montero and Chris Coghlan, the Pirates might consider Bobby LaFromboise in addition to Tony Watson and Antonio Bastardo.
On the mound
That urgency Hurdle mentioned? “More often than not it affects the guy on the mound,” he said. “It’s not the same template as having starters [get] the opportunity to work through things. You’re not about building confidence now.”
The 12 starters in the first six wild-card games averaged almost six innings per start, skewed slightly by Madison Bumgarner’s complete game against the Pirates last year. Four of the starters completed five innings or fewer. If things go sideways, Hurdle will have a quick hook.
“You’re out to get results and get the matchups you need, so the game might be at a little quicker speed than the 162 you play,” Hurdle said. “Which is necessary at times, but you also have to give them a heads-up so it’s not blindsiding.”
Forty-seven relievers appeared in the first six wild-card games, almost eight per game. Of those, 22 pitched less than one inning.
In the field
Not much changes here.
“It’s amazing how those percentages don’t lie,” said Pirates first-base coach Nick Leyva, who coordinates infield positioning. “The black and white’s there. We’re just going with the percentages.”
The Pirates will adjust their defense as the game progresses if the pitcher isn’t locating his pitches well or if opposing hitters indicate a change in approach, but, for the most part, they trust the batted-ball percentages that have influenced their positioning all season.
“Schwarber, he knows that we’re going to put a shift on them,” Leyva said. “Is there going to be a time where he says, maybe I’ll take a shot to left field or I’ll take a bunt? I hope so, because we’ve done our job. We’ve committed him to change his style of hitting, and a lot of times that’s what it’s all about, too.”
What about bringing the infield in to cut off a run? Depends on the opposing pitcher, the batter’s tendencies and the situation.
“I’m sure that you’ll want to cut off a run early in a game if you’re facing [Zack] Greinke or [Jake] Arrieta, because they don’t give up much,” Leyva said. “So you got to be realistic.”
Arrieta will start Wednesday night for the Cubs.
On the bases
The Pirates will review video of the Cubs’ running-game program today, with an emphasis on limiting mistakes and ensuring clear communication.
“There are things that we can do on the bases that are conducive to putting more pressure on the Cubs,” third-base coach Rick Sofield said. “And we’re going to have to trust them. Hopefully, the window of opportunity to do those things opens up and, once it does, then we’re going to have to be who we are. I don’t think we can shy away from it.”
The Pirates have four players with usable speed — Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco, Andrew McCutchen and Josh Harrison — and a secret weapon in Pedro Alvarez, the best fundamental baserunner on the team. Exploiting that requires trusting the game plan.
“It may be a heavyweight boxing match at first, things are slow,” Sofield said. “But, at some point, there’ll be a spot that it opens up, and then we’ll have to be who we are.”
They’re not the Royals, who stole seven bases by testing Jon Lester’s reluctance to throw the ball to first.
“There is the good old-fashioned hardball way,” Sofield said, “and there’s times when guys have to hit doubles.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.