The Chicago Cubs’ Jake Arrieta is the best pitcher in the known universe right now, which means you have to give the Pirates less than a 50-50 chance of beating him in the National League wild-card game should their pursuit of the St. Louis Cardinals in the NL Central come up short.
As this space noted not so long ago, anything can happen in one baseball game. In fact, Arrieta’s start at PNC Park last week went sideways when he goofed a throw to first base, allowing the Pirates to score the tying run in the eighth inning and force him from the game with a no decision in what became a 12-inning loss for the home team.
That said, Arrieta’s microscopic 1.88 ERA this season suggests the Pirates’ odds will probably be hanging on flukes like that — more than anyone is comfortable with after a season in which the Pirates have been the second-best team in baseball.
And even if they’re fortunate enough to survive such an encounter, they’ll then have to get through the world-leading Cardinals in the postseason’s divisional round while lesser teams face off elsewhere to advance to the league championship series.
Bottomline: Circumstances are going to make it extremely difficult for these Pirates to reach a new high water mark in postseason play this season.
No one should for a second, however, mistake failure to advance to the NLCS for the first time since 1992 for failure on the part of the team or organization to grow. The Pirates have done that and then some this season, and they’ve done it in some dramatic ways that should not be discounted, regardless of how the postseason turns out.
Look at Jung Ho Kang, a Korean enigma who became part of the foundation of the club before suffering a devastating injury during the last homestand. His success was a huge step forward for general manager Neal Huntington’s efforts to capitalize on the international market.
Look at J.A. Happ, pretty much the definition of a soup can during his time in Seattle who has contributed almost two wins above replacement in just two short months since being dealt here at the trading deadline in late July. His immediate turnaround in the heat of a pennant race has shown this coaching staff, led by pitching coach Ray Searage, has mastered the art of the reclamation project to the point that it’s reasonable to question why the Pirates should ever pay a premium price for a starting pitcher as long as these guys are in Pittsburgh.
Look at Francisco Cervelli, the catcher who’s improbably made the city forget about Russell Martin. By identifying his pitch framing skills paired with his legitimate pop at the plate, Huntington and Co. have secured not just the club’s present at the position, but its future — he’ll be under contractual control through at least next season.
Look at Gregory Polanco. His season hasn’t been the breakout many hoped it might be, but the young outfielder has progressed, especially in the second half, during which he’s posted a substantial OPS better than .750.
All this, combined with the continued excellence of guys such as Andrew McCutchen, Gerrit Cole, Francisco Liriano, Starling Marte and Neil Walker, has been good for 93 wins so far with a handful more still on the table. It also reflects well on the club’s ability to keep this winning going for at least a few more seasons, with most of these guys locked up for years to come.
That’s really all you can ask of a franchise in a sport where the postseason can be such a fickle beast — one that this year will force them to beat the best and third-best teams by record just to get to the semifinal series.
Of course, this is a town with a sports culture built on championship tradition, and if this group wants to be immortalized, it’s going to have to overcome those borderline unfair obstacles. Falling short of an NL or World Series title would rightly be a disappointment for many.
But that disappointment shouldn’t define what’s been a stellar six-month campaign, one in which the Pirates have proven they’re definitely better off than they were at this time a year ago.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or via Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.