J.A. Happ, the stopgap sub for injured right-hander A.J. Burnett, saw his Pirates debut spoiled by another J.A. — Jake Arrieta.

The Chicago Cubs starter tossed seven scoreless innings, allowing just two hits, and the Cubs cruised to a 5-0 shutout victory Tuesday night at PNC Park.

“He’s been dominant the whole season,” Francisco Cervelli said of Arrieta (12-6), who let just one runner reach scoring position. “In my opinion, No. 1 or 2 nastiest guys in the National League.”

The Pirates (61-44) were out-hit, 14-4. Their lead over the Cubs (58-47) in the wild-card race was trimmed to three games, though they stayed five games back of the first-place St. Louis Cardinals in the National League Central Division.

Advertise with us

This de facto series opener — played after a rainout Monday night — marked the first time since August 1977, that both teams in a Pirates-Cubs game were at least 10 games over .500, according to Elias Sports Bureau.

Arrieta lowered his ERA to 2.50 and turned in his ninth consecutive quality start. He painted corners with his heavy cutter, and also singled off Arquimedes Caminero’s 99 mph fastball in the seventh.

Happ, a left-hander acquired at the trade deadline Friday for minor league right-hander Adrian Sampson, might have wished for a better first day on the job. Happ threw 99 pitches over 4⅓ innings as the Cubs pelted him for eight hits, two walks and four runs.

Click the image above to explore our 2015 season tracker and check out how the Pirates have fared so far, game by game. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Afterward, Happ admitted he was “anxious,” but he made no excuses.

“I obviously would have liked it to have gone a lot differently,” he said, “but I just didn't execute a few key times, and they made me pay for it.”

Advertise with us

Cubs cleanup hitter Anthony Rizzo had three singles and a double for his fourth career four-hit game. Starling Marte singled and doubled, collecting half the Pirates hits.

Happ got just five hitters into the game before boo birds descended on the North Shore. The Cubs loaded the bases in the first, and Happ forced home the game’s first run by walking Jorge Soler on a 3-1 fastball.

“The only damage was one run,” Cervelli said. “But he threw a lot of pitches.”

Happ’s pitch count quickly became an issue. He went to a three-ball count on six batters, and left plenty of offerings up and over the plate.

“This is the big leagues,” Cervelli said. “You make mistakes, and you pay.”

Advertise with us

Happ said he needed to be “more economical” with his pitching, but he did note — as did Los Angeles Dodgers All-Star starters Clayton Kershaw and Zack Greinke recently — that the Cubs work counts more aggressively than most teams.

“They’re a dangerous bunch,” he said. “They have a lot of power, a lot of speed. They laid off some good pitches — I expected them to swing at some of them, to be honest — and that makes it tougher to come back and execute your next pitch."

Center fielder Andrew McCutchen saved Happ from further damage in the second. McCutchen slid to stop Chris Denorfia’s two-out double and fed Jung Ho Kang for a perfect relay to cut down Addison Russell, who tried scoring from first, at the plate.

The Cubs pushed across two more runs with two outs in the third on Starlin Castro’s RBI double and David Ross’ run-scoring single. They added single runs in the fifth and the sixth.

Right-hander Jared Hughes allowed three hits, a walk and a run in 1⅓ innings. Caminero cleaned up Hughes’ mess in the sixth and went 2⅓ scoreless innings — his longest relief outing this season. He allowed three hits, walked one and struck out six.

The Pirates finally pieced together a rally against Arrieta in the seventh. After Marte’s leadoff single, McCutchen walked to give the Pirates their first runner in scoring position against Arrieta. He easily worked out of the jam by getting a line drive, a strikeout and a weak grounder.

Advertise with us

“We couldn’t get the barrel to [Arrieta], outside of Marte and McCutchen,” Hurdle said. “… We couldn't find a way to connect any dots off of him.”

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.