Pirates starter Jeff Locke hit the first Indians batter he faced Saturday but that was about the only mistake he made as he turned in one of the best performances by any starter on the team this season.

And the thing is, he had to be as near perfect as he was to give the Pirates a chance to win because Indians rookie Cody Anderson was pretty dominant as well.

Locke (5-4) pitched eight innings and gave up only two hits and led the Pirates to a 1-0 win over the Indians before a crowd of 37,298 at PNC Park.

Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said this was a classic example of a low-scoring game that was still incredibly exciting to watch because both pitchers were so good and so hard on the opposing lineups.

Advertise with us

He said this wasn’t a case of good hitters just missing hittable pitchers, either, it was an example of two pitches making great pitches and throwing the ball with great efficiency.

“The two guys that went out there and took the mound were really, really good,” Hurdle said. “You might have seen two of the best change ups you are going to see all year. They both attacked the zone and I can’t speak enough about Locke’s effort today, it was fantastic.”

Locke was so good that even though Hurdle relieved him with Mark Melancon, one of the best closers in baseball, for the ninth inning, he wasn’t sure it was the right decision.

He said that Locke probably earned the chance to get the complete game but his comfort zone in a 1-0 game was to go to Melancon, who has been almost automatic in save situations.

“I wrestled with that decision,” Hurdle said. “And I am still not sure I made the right decision sitting here right now, quite frankly. I hate to get in the way of players when they are performing like that and so I don’t know if tomorrow or a week from now I’ll be able to say it was the right decision.

Advertise with us

“I just know that we won the game and I wanted to get the ball into [Melancon’s] hand, a guy who had been in that position before.”

Locke’s line was impressive as he went 8 shutout innings and gave up only two hits, struck out six and didn’t walk any but it doesn’t tell nearly the whole story of just how dominant he was.

A look deeper into Locke’s performance reveals no Indians runner reached second base and he retired the final 19 batters he faced as he finished with six consecutive perfect innings before giving way to closer Mark Melancon in the 9th.

The Indians did get two runners on against Melancon but he pitched his way out of the jam and earned his National League-leading 26th save of the season.

Locke said the key was simple, well, more accurately the key was to keep it simple and throw strikes which is what he tried to do all day.

Advertise with us

“I was really just trying to throw strike one because they are a very aggressive team,” said Locke, who faced 25 hitters and only twice even got to a three-ball count. “It plays to our defense’s favor with ground balls and flyouts early in the count it allowed me to get back up on the mound and keep attacking the zone against those guys.

“When you get into a good rhythm, you just want to try and stay in that rhythm and keep working within your game plan.”

Anderson (1-1) got the loss but probably deserved a better fate as he was almost as good as Locke, but not quite, and that was the slight difference between the two performances was also the difference in the game.

The Pirates were scoreless through five innings but did manage to finally get to Anderson for a run when Josh Harrison doubled with one out in the bottom of 6th and then he scored on an RBI single by Neil Walker.

But that was all the damage they could do to Anderson, who went all eight innings and gave up six hits and one run, but given how dominant Locke was, it was all the offense the Pirates would need to win the game.

Advertise with us

Locke said watching Anderson make quick work of the Pirates lineup was tough because he obviously wants his teammates to have success but in a strange way it helped him stay fresh and focused because there wasn’t much time between innings.

“Anderson threw so such a good game and was so efficient, it enabled me to get back up there on the mound quickly and get back to work,” Locke said. “That helps a lot, you want to try and get all the runs you can but when that guy is out there setting us down like he was, it really does give you the opportunity to get out there and try to attack those guys.”

Walker said that the Pirates approach to Anderson was to try and be aggressive because he was coming right at them but he was very good at mixing his pitches up and putting the Pirates hitters in tough counts all day long.

“He pounded the strike zone with fastballs, sliders and change ups,” Walker said. “We figured out early on he wasn’t going to nibble, he was going to make us beat him and unfortunately we didn’t score more than one run or get his pitch count up for that matter.

“But when you are going up there and he is coming right at you and it is strike one, strike two, sometimes it is just hard to get those hits to fall, he deserves a lot of credit.”

Advertise with us

Despite the win, the Pirates (46-34) remained six games behind the National League Central-leading Cardinals (52-28) as they used a late sacrifice fly to lift them to a 2-1 win over San Diego.

The Pirates will face the Indians (38-42) Sunday at PNC in the rubber match of the three-game series.

Gerrit Cole (11-3) takes the mound for the Pirates against Indians starter Danny Salazar (7-3) and Cole will attempt to become the first pitcher in the Majors to reach 12 wins this season.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1720 and Twitter @paulzeise