It was just three weeks ago Sunday that Pirates general manager Neal Huntington was asked during his weekly meeting with reporters to justify keeping Jung Ho Kang on the major league roster after the infielder got off to a slow start in limited April playing time. Since then, Kang has been one of the team’s best players. With a handful of starts under his belt of late, his OPS is up to a robust .898, and he’s been a steady hand in the field to boot.
Now, it’s Josh Harrison and Jordy Mercer — Kang’s chief competition for playing time — who are drawing the ire of the masses. Both are struggling mightily to get on base. And Harrison’s defense has been especially brutal. He has five errors already in 2015 after committing just three all of last season.
Predictably, the new solution being put forward by many of the same folks who were bleating for Kang to be sent to the minors is for him to replace Mercer or Harrison in the everyday lineup.
I’ve met first graders less fickle.
The club invested in Harrison over the long term with an offseason contract extension for a reason. He’s due to collect a little more than $26 million over the next four seasons after an All-Star campaign in 2014 in which he finished in the top 10 of MVP voting and showed remarkable positional versatility. Mercer, meanwhile, has a track record of being a slow starter who morphs into one of the best shortstops in the National League for the bulk of the summer.
That should buy them more than a month’s worth of goodwill, especially when when their prospective replacement is a guy who’s still largely an enigma after coming to the big leagues from South Korea over the offseason. And if it doesn’t, consider these peripheral statistics.
Mercer’s line drive percentage is actually up about 5 percent from last year, which means that he’s making better contact while walking at a similar rate and striking out less often. And his .225 batting average on balls in play (BABIP) is well below his career norm of .292 and the general big league baseline of .300 for this stat that removes strikouts and home runs from the equation. All of these numbers combined suggest he’s a candidate for some legitimate progression.
Harrison’s line drive numbers, on the other hand, are down. So he’s not hitting the ball with the same authority he did last season, when he hit 38 doubles. He’s also striking out more, walking less and hitting a lot more easily fielded ground balls. Those are legitimate problems that will require some adjustments and make his case a more perilous one than Mercer’s.
But his regression in those areas has been amplified by a ghastly .191 BABIP that screams bad luck. A number that low — it’s the seventh-worst in baseball among qualified hitters, according to Fangraphs — suggests that even the good contact he is making is often going for naught at a rate unsustainable over 162 games. His 2014 clip was .353. So while his peripherals indicate he’s nowhere close to being in last year’s form, they do offer hope he’s probably not quite as bad as he looks, either.
That said, getting Kang’s bat in there while he’s hot is a good idea. The Pirates did that often this past week, as he started four of the six games against the Reds and Cardinals. It paid off to a large degree, especially with his home run in Sunday’s win against St. Louis.
However, manager Clint Hurdle wisely alternated between sitting Mercer and Harrison to get Kang in the lineup. This kept his teammates mostly involved and gave them ample playing time to make necessary adjustments.
That’s how it should be for at least another month or so, too. If in the middle of June one or both players still aren’t progressing, perhaps a more permanent change will be in order. At that point, you’d expect them to have between 200 and 250 at bats, a sample size large enough to begin drawing some more meaningful conclusions.
Until that point, though, calls for Kang to be an everyday player at Mercer and Harrison’s expense smack of impatience and the same capricious logic that would have had Kang at Triple-A Indianapolis not so long ago.
If the Pirates are going to be at their best, they need his teammates to work through this. That took playing time for Kang. No one should expect it to be any different for Mercer and Harrison.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.