BRADENTON, Fla. — Andrew McCutchen is a quiet man, generally reserved and even-keeled. Even when displaying some of the swagger that comes with being among the best players in the game, he does so humbly, without airs.
But he also has an MVP award and two top-three finishes. He made four consecutive All-Star teams. He appeared on the cover of a video game, presented at the American Music Awards and proposed on “Ellen.” He is not just a good player anymore.
“When he does speak,” manager Clint Hurdle said, “men listen.”
Two weeks ago, McCutchen lent his thoughts to The Players’ Tribune, a media platform started by former New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter to allow athletes to tell their stories, first-person and unfiltered. McCutchen discussed the Jackie Robinson West Little League team, which was stripped of its U.S. title because it used ineligible players, and the difficulties children from low-income families face in playing baseball at a high level because of the cost and time commitment of travel teams. He also compared the opportunities talented young players in the U.S. have to those in Latin America.
“When I was a kid, I looked at baseball players growing up in Latin America with a lot of envy,” McCutchen wrote. “If you’re a talented kid in the Dominican Republic or Puerto Rico, a team can come along and say, ‘We’re going to sign you for $50,000 and take you into our organization and develop you, feed you, take care of your travel.’ To me, as a 14-year-old kid whose family was struggling, that would have meant everything to me. I would have taken that deal in a second.”
A week and a half later, the Boston Red Sox signed 19-year-old Cuban Yoan Moncada with a bonus worth $31.5 million, which will actually cost them about $63 million because of the 100 percent tax on the portion that exceeds their international bonus pool. That got the attention of Tampa Bay Rays pitcher Drew Smyly, who tweeted, “It’s not right that a Cuban 19yr old gets paid 30m and the best 19yr old in the entire USA gets prob 1/6th of that. Everyone should have to go through same process.”
“It just happened that Jackie Robinson West came out and I felt that it needed to be talked about and shared,” McCutchen said this week. “But the whole other thing was, just having that opportunity, it really isn’t equal. … Not to have anything against any type of Latin players. I was just saying that opportunity is different, and how do you address it? Will it ever be changed?”
Jeter had previously asked McCutchen if he would serve as a senior editor to The Players’ Tribune and McCutchen accepted. The article was a combination of McCutchen’s writing and interviews with a staffer to help with the presentation of the finished product, he said, but the words and thoughts are his own.
“It’s more of those times when you’re watching something and you have something on your mind and you say something like, ‘Man, I wish they would do it like this or I wish this would happen,’ ” he said. “You’re able to actually go and talk about those things.”
The difference in opportunity McCutchen and Smyly referred to stems from the recent creation of signing bonus pools and penalties for exceeding them. Gerrit Cole’s $8 million bonus is still the highest in the history of the draft, and the $6.7 million bonus Chicago Cubs prospect Kris Bryant got in 2013 is the highest since the most recent collective bargaining agreement capped draft spending. Similar rules restrict international spending, but unlike the draft, where overspending can cost teams future picks, penalties for exceeding the international pool are not as punitive. The Red Sox cannot sign an international player for more than $300,000 for the next two years, in addition to the overage tax. Essentially, teams can blow through the bonus ceiling for the right international prospect, but won’t do the same when draft picks are on the line.
“A lot of people feel that way,” McCutchen said. “No one ever speaks upon it. I was just sharing what was on my mind.”
Pirates principal owner and chairman Bob Nutting comes at the issue from a different perspective. Major League Baseball successfully negotiated the draft spending limits into the most recent CBA, meaning signing bonuses remain low even as more teams become savvy to the value of good drafting. It is worth noting that drafted players are not members of the Major League Baseball Players Association until they make a 40-man roster. But the Moncada deal displays how teams with greater financial resources can, to an extent, circumvent the penalties.
“It’s never going to be a level playing field,” said Nutting, who believed an international draft would benefit the Pirates. “We’re never going to have all of the same opportunities as every other team.”
McCutchen still commands attention, as evidenced by the four-person MLB camera crew that tailed him for most of Wednesday, though now the focus shifts back on the field. The avulsion fracture involving the cartilage attached to a rib that sent him to the disabled list in August had healed by the end of the season, he said, and required no additional procedure or treatment. He spent the offseason improving his overall game, nothing specific, and sees no holes in the Pirates lineup. “I think we’re going to be really good,” he said.
McCutchen’s status might have opened the door to the forum, but the thoughtfulness and gravitas have always been there to some extent.
“Don’t kid yourself,” former bench coach and current Texas Rangers manager Jeff Banister told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette during spring training in 2012. “ … When he decides to say something, the importance of it resounds loudly.”
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.