Bill Brink: Welcome to today's Pirates chat ... here we go ...
Sanguillen71: When do we find out who is on the 25 man roster?
Bill Brink: They have to set it by 10 a.m. Wednesday. I broke it down this morning here: http://sportsblogs.post-gaz...
JamesinNYC: Personally I like starting Volquez, starting pitchers on short rest is always suboptimal. If they win then they are set up a lot better for the next series right?
Bill Brink: They are set up well if they win. They have Cole on regular rest or Liriano on one extra day of rest Friday, the other Saturday. Volquez would be on regular rest for Game 3 Monday.
Austin: Can I have some Edinson Volquez stats after the all star break please?
Bill Brink: Because you said please ...
2.20 ERA, 5-1 in 13 starts, 81.2 innings, 69 hits, 28 runs, 20 earned, 5 homers, 34 walks, 67 strikeouts, .232 opponent average.
Jim in VT: Gaby starts at 1B, right? Aside from that,t he question is who's in RF. Snider?
Bill Brink: I think Snider stays in right but bats eighth. Gaby at first sounds logical. Bumgarner is tough on lefties.
Hunter Pence: Do you agree with me that season two is the best season of Friday Night Lights?
Bill Brink: That one made me laugh. What was with the whole Landry and Tyra side plot? TV strikes are the worst.
Shaun: What happens to Pedro this off-season? Can his performance issues be fixed?
Bill Brink: On one hand, I find it hard to believe Huntington will bail on a No. 2 overall draft pick and the first pick he made as GM. They will probably allow him to go to instructs and try to re-learn third base, or learn first base. But I also don't think they will pay two arbitration-eligible, left-handed first basemen, so either he or Ike Davis might go. And Huntington traded for Davis, so it's a similar situation.
Matt: Do you believe that the intensity, emotion, and sheer energy of PNC park last october (most notably the wild card game) will ever be matched again in Pittsburgh?
Bill Brink: Not for a long time.
Chris: Russell the Muscle good to go?
Bill Brink: We don't have access to the clubhouse until 3 p.m. today and we talk to Hurdle just before, so we won't know until then.
Steve Y: Do you think that Edison Volquez is the right pitcher to be starting the WC game? Was it a bad idea to start Cole on Sunday?
Bill Brink: It would have been really hard for Hurdle to tell his players, "Look guys, we're punting on the division, we want to save Cole for Monday -- which we probably won't get if we roll Pimentel out there -- or Wednesday. Just lay down out there today. Good luck against Cueto."
The players wanted to play for the division title. That means a lot to them. A 162-game season is a much better judge of a team than even a seven-game playoff series. And if you can avoid a one-game elimination contest, you have to try, even if it burns Cole.
Chris: How can a 162 game season come down to one game? Shouldn't this at least be a best of three?
Bill Brink: There are some that feel that way, and it might eventually change to that. I think part of it was, when it was instituted, they had to shoe-horn it into a pre-existing schedule and three games wasn't feasible. We could see that change. I thought the infield fly rule debacle with the Braves might have forced a change sooner.
JAL: If you put the normal Giant lineup at 100%, how much of that is lost with Pagan being out?
Bill Brink: Not as much as we might think. Blanco has been a good replacement as a leadoff hitter, with an OBP of only a few points below Pagan's. They both stole 16 bases. And Blanco has hit very well -- .296/.365/.449 -- in the second half.
Mike in Downtown: What were the travel plans for the team had they won Sunday? Stay in Cincy until the StL game was over?
Bill Brink: They were going to stay in Cincy and watch the Cards game to see where they were going next.
jwburgh: Does Walker stay at cleanup vs lefty...he has batted down in order against LHP most of season. Martin in 4 hole ? And MARTE 5th Gaby 6th? Mercer in 2 hole his best spot?
Bill Brink: That's what I would imagine. Harrison 5 Mercer 6 McCutchen 8 Martin 2 Marte 7 Sanchez 3 Walker 4 Snider 9 Volquez 1 would be my guess, with Sanchez and Walker possibly flipped.
Jeff lalonde: Who do the pirates play if or when we get by the Giants.
Bill Brink: They head to Washington to play the Nationals.
Jordan: I think tomorrow will be just as ruckus of a crowd as it was last year, do you think it will be more subdue?
Bill Brink: It'll be hard to match 20 years of pent-up frustration being unleashed, but I think it'll be rocking.
JAL: Stats say this should be a close low scoring game so are we more likely to see a 8-6 game?
Bill Brink: With two good starters, a rested bullpen and no incentive to let a struggling starter "figure it out," I think it will be low-scoring, but who knows, the Pirates scored four in the first inning off Bumgarner earlier this year, Volquez gave up eight in less than two innings and the Pirates hit three home runs in last year's game.
Bill Brink: What other questions do we have today?
Jordan: How do you see the Giants setting their lineup?
Bill Brink: My guess would be Blanco Panik Posey Sandoval Belt Pence Ishikawa (!!!) Crawford Bumgarner. But I'm not sure what he does with Pence and Belt against the righty.
Austin: Jameson Taillon any update?
Bill Brink: Still rehabbing. Probably about halfway through.
fox: do u expect the bucs to be aggressive on the bases as much as in reg season?
Bill Brink: Because their season has 27 outs remaining, I don't expect them to give any away on the bases, especially with a lefty on the mound. Reading balls in the dirt, though, I think so.
John: Do you think that Volquez not pitching against the Giants this year is an advantage or disadvantage?
Bill Brink: An advantage. Video is one thing. It's always easier for hitters when they've stood in the box and seen the guy.
Guest: Travis Ishikawa in left field at PNC? That has to work to the Pirates advantage doesn't it?
Bill Brink: They might run Chris Dominguez or Juan Perez out there for that reason. That's a toss-up.
JAL: Walker looked like he was breaking out of his slump the last couple of games. Is that you saw it?
Bill Brink: Yeah, he was looking better the past three games. Hitting the ball hard. He said Sunday his timing was better.
JamesinNYC: Anyone make it for this game but left off the next series if they make it? Sanchez as a catcher would be one I would think of.
Bill Brink: Depends on the health of Stewart and Martin. They'll need to remove two position players to add the third and fourth starters. I could see Sanchez, or people like Tabata, Lambo or Morel.
fox: does the buccos having a year wxperience in a wildcard help this years bucs?
Bill Brink: I don't think so. Playing at home in front of their crowd will help, but there's only so much to the "they've been there before" thing if Bumgarner deals and Volquez doesn't.
Justin: How do you think Clint Hurdle ranks in NL Manager of the Year voting? Any chance to repeat?
Bill Brink: He's up for consideration, along with Williams in Washington, Bochy, maybe even Redmond in Miami.
Jordan: Who do you like in tonights game?
Bill Brink: I like Lester, going against the Royals' lefties -- Hosmer, Moustakas, Gordon. But I wouldn't pick against Shields.
JAL: Do the pirates rely too much on home runs to score or do they string hits together more often that it seems?
Bill Brink: The past week, runs were tough to come by save for one game. I don't think it's anything to worry about.
Bill Brink: Gotta head to the park soon. Lightning round. Go.
Jordan: How many pitchers would you expect on wildcard roster for Pirates?
Bill Brink: Nine. Seven relievers, Volquez and an emergency starter (probably Worley). That's what they did last year.
Jim in VT: The longest Volquez goes even with a lead is...
Bill Brink: If he's dealing like he has been recently, no reason he can't go seven. Hard to see him go past that with Watson and Melancon, but you never know.
Bob: Expectations for Wednesday's game?
Bill Brink: I expect it will take place. Other than that, I suspend expectations and write about what happens.
JAL: Will Martin's physical problems make teams leery about giving him a long term contract?
Bill Brink: It might knock a year or a couple million off the offers. When an issue bugs you since spring training, forces you to the DL for a month and still bothers you in September, teams notice.
Loran: What is the Pirates approach to facing Bumgarner?
Bill Brink: He's got five pitches at four different speeds, so they need to be ready to hit hittable pitches and mistakes because he doesn't make many.
russ: I just want to say that I am a bay area giants fan but totally respect the resurgence of the Pirates. It really is awesome to see. I wish the Pirates luck tomorrow.
Bill Brink: Should be a fun game. That's it for today. We'll chat again this week, not sure when because it depends on what happens Wednesday. Thanks for the questions!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.