CINCINNATI — In a tribute to the bizarre things that happen daily in baseball, the Pirates' hopes to play their way into no worse than a tie for the division title hinged on a showdown between Bobby LaFromboise and Ramon Santiago.

Santiago came out the winner, but the St. Louis Cardinals spared the Pirates from elimination for National League Central Division title race by also losing Saturday and extending the division race to the final day of the regular season.

Santiago hit a walk-off grand slam in the 10th inning and the Pirates lost, 10-6, Saturday against the Cincinnati Reds at Great American Ball Park. They fell 11/2 games behind the Cardinals in the NL Central before the Cardinals lost, 5-2, to the Arizona Diamondbacks.

The Pirates already had clinched a playoff spot and homefield advantage in the wild-card game Wednesday against the San Francisco Giants, but still can compete for the NL Central title. If the Cardinals lose today and the Pirates win -- against Reds ace Johnny Cueto, who will be trying to win his 20th game this season -- they would tie, forcing a tiebreaker game Monday at Busch Stadium. The winner of that tiebreaker would advance to the NL Division Series and the loser would play the San Francisco Giants in the wild-card game.

Advertise with us

Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said he would wait to see what the Cardinals did before determining whether to start Gerrit Cole against the Reds today or hold him back.

"I can't imagine why we wouldn't wait until the Cardinals game [Saturday night]," Hurdle said.

The score Saturday was tied, 6-6, going into the bottom of the 10th when reliever John Axford entered. He allowed two walks and allowed a single before Hurdle summoned LaFromboise to face pinch-hitter Brayan Pena. Pena popped out, but Santiago hit a 1-0 sinker to left to end the game.

"You get late innings, as we all know, and walks usually never turn out to be your friend," Hurdle said.

The Reds took an early lead against Francisco Liriano, who walked five batters and allowed four runs -- three earned -- in five innings. In the first, walks to Kristopher Negron and Todd Frazier sandwiched around a single by Brandon Phillips. Devin Mesoraco's two-run single and Chris Heisey's RBI groundout soon made it 3-0.

Advertise with us

"Physically I feel better than my last two starts," Liriano said. "I think I'm trying too hard, trying to overthrow my fastball instead of just hitting my spot."

The start ended his four-game win streak, and a six-game stretch in which he pitched at least six innings and allowed two runs or fewer.

The Pirates forced Alfredo Simon from the game after five and scored four runs against him. Simon, pitching through a calf and Achilles' tendon strain, couldn't run. Reds manager Bryan Price told him not to swing in his second trip to the plate, and he couldn't cover first base. But he could pitch, and he limited the Pirates to one hit until the fifth.

Jordy Mercer homered and doubled, and Neil Walker drove in three runs with two hits. The second was an RBI triple into the right-field corner that followed Andrew McCutchen's RBI single to boost the Pirates to a 6-4 lead in the seventh.

But John Holdzkom, who had not allowed a run in his brief major league career, gave up a two-run homer to Frazier (his 29th) that created a tie, forced extra innings and eventually led to Santiago's second homer this season.