Three and a half hours of 1-0 baseball can have a cooling effect on extreme cases of pennant fever, particularly if you're on the wrong end of it.
That the Milwaukee Brewers took the middle game of this final home series Saturday night might not be rich in palatable story lines, but there is the one about discretion being the better part of valor.
Even when they lose right now, the Pirates create a productive vibe.
Perhaps you've noted that certain Matholympians, using probability models I'm sure are fail-safe, are putting the Pirates postseason chances in the high 90s, percentage-wise, but it's still useful to cite the game's long history in this regard.
And especially today.
Fifty years ago on this date, Sept. 21, 1964, on a dark night in a North Philadelphia ghetto, Chico Ruiz stole home for the Cincinnati Reds in the sixth inning of what had been a scoreless affair.
At the start of that game, the Phillies were cruising toward the National League pennant (there were no divisions then); they led by 6½ games with 12 to play. They lost the game, 1-0, then they lost the next night, and the night after that. Then they lost for a week. They lost 10 games in a row, and no pennant came to Philadelphia.
So Saturday night, in another game in another pennant race that went scoreless into the later innings, this a game that might not be remembered for 50 hours let alone 50 years (yeah, things tend to stick with you when you're 11), the presumably postseason bound Pirates did a very good thing.
By doing nothing.
At least nothing in the way of retaliation for the second pitch that bored into MVP Andrew McCutchen from the right hand of Brewers starter Matt Garza.
Garza hit McCutchen in the back with two out in the third, so after Edinson Volquez shaved a few theoretical stitches off the front of Ryan Braun's blouse just minutes later, home-plate umpire Marty Foster warned both benches that there would be no more of that.
And there was more of exactly that.
Garza hit McCutchen again, again with two out and nobody on, this time in the fifth, on a 1-2 pitch that got Andrew on the arm.
The Pirates seethed. Gerrit Cole was livid in the Pirates dugout. Garza was ejected. Garza seethed. Garza was livid in the Brewers dugout, then went to the clubhouse to seethe lividly some more.
"The right move was made," Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said of Garza's ejection. "It was the right call at the time. I mean if he doesn't get tossed, then I do. Somebody's gonna leave."
In my view from the crow's nest, Garza didn't hit McCutchen intentionally either time. There's no room to be sending messages when you're trying to claw your way back into the wild-card picture, just as there's no utility in putting a runner on base in front of the cleanup hitter in a meaningful 0-0 game on Sept. 20, let alone twice.
There aren't a lot of sound strategies when it comes to dealing with McCutchen, who didn't get his league-leading .402 on-base percentage and .532 slugging percentage at the dollar store. Pitching him inside, particularly up in the strike zone, is among the few demonstrably effective gambits.
"I don't think [Garza] hit him on purpose," said Volquez, whose seven shutout innings were wasted. "There were two out both times. I know [McCutchen] is one of the best hitters on the team, but I don't think he hit him on purpose.
"Sure we were [ticked] off. You don't like to see your best guy get hit, so we were pumped up, started screaming, but again, I don't think he tried to hit him."
At that point, there was nowhere else to go had the Pirates decided to plunk somebody. That would have emptied both benches, and as much as baseball fights get ridiculed for general passivity, players do get hurt in them. It's not unusual at all.
Would you have wanted an enraged Cole to fly out of there and break a knuckle on some numbskull?
For the moment, the Pirates have more to lose than the Brewers. In the heat of that moment, they decided to keep it that way. They lost, 1-0, but they'll likely shower that one off. Had they lost a postseason body, well, that would have been stupid.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.