Welcome back, baseball fans. The Pirates wrapped up their 2016 season Sunday. They finished 78-83 and had as many wins (one) as ties (one) in their final 10 games of the season.

If you’ve got a question for the next mailbag, well, hold onto it. This is the last letters column for the season, but it surely will be back next spring. Please do email me at snesbitt@post-gazette.com or tweet @stephenjnesbitt with questions and comments throughout the offseason. You made the mailbag a fun item on my weekly to-do list during the long baseball season.

Here we go.

Mark: What would a reasonable/likely return be for 22 [Andrew McCutchen] in a trade this offseason?

Advertise with us

The Boston Red Sox traded Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees in 1920 for $100,000. I think that’d be a fair swap for McCutchen — $100,000 and a Robinzon Díaz to be named later.

I don’t expect the Pirates will trade McCutchen this offseason, just as I didn’t expect them to extend his contract last spring or shop him at the trade deadline. And this would seem to be the exact wrong time to trade McCutchen, too, given how his value is as low as its ever been during his terrific eight-year major league career. ESPN’s David Schoenfield had a smart write-up in August about how McCutchen’s decline this season truly was unprecedented for a superstar hitter. The story also happened to coincide with McCutchen’s late-season surge — his OPS+ (league average is 100) rose from 91 to 103 over the last two months of the season — but Schoenfield’s point still was salient: No hitter of McCutchen’s caliber and similar track record had posted a sub-110 OPS+ season before his thirties. McCutchen turned 29 in August.

The Pirates can choose to believe in McCutchen’s 2011-2015 seasons (.905 OPS) or in his April-July this season (.719) or in his August-October (.852). The truth, as ever, is probably somewhere in the middle. But to trade him today would be to sell low. Don’t read this wrong: McCutchen still would fetch a big return, but not nearly as big as he would have 10 months ago. Plenty of teams would be happy to pay him $14 million in 2017 and then have the choice to pick up his $14.5 million salary in 2018 or hand him a $1 million buyout. That’s not exactly a contract the Pirates are trying to get off the books in a hurry. In this day and age, that’s about as cheap as a perennial All-Star can come. To trade McCutchen this offseason, the Pirates would both have to be blown away by the offer and believe McCutchen won’t return to his five-plus WAR days.

A reasonable return for McCutchen probably would be a package deal that includes prospects and major league-ready players. With the bats and arms they’ll return the next few years, the Pirates aren’t likely to punt on a couple years by swapping McCutchen only for prospects. The center fielder in waiting, Austin Meadows, isn’t ready to be an everyday player in the majors. The window for the Pirates is now, so they would have to spend to fill the hole left by McCutchen. Their best bet, from where I sit, is to stick with their star and hope for vintage McCutchen in 2017. It’d be awful tough for those in the grandstands and those in the clubhouse to stomach if McCutchen carried another team to the playoffs the next two years.

J. Howard: Projected opening day 2017 lineup?

Advertise with us

At this point, it’s hard to project any real surprises for the Pirates’ opening-day nine April 3 against the Red Sox and their likely Cy Young-winning right-hander Rick Porcello. The Pirates have all their starting position players under contract still, with only Sean Rodriguez and Matt Joyce headed toward free agency this fall. So, my best guess right now at an opening-day lineup is this:

1. Josh Harrison 2B

2. Josh Bell 1B

3. McCutchen CF

4. Gregory Polanco RF

Advertise with us

5. Starling Marte LF

6. Jung Ho Kang 3B

7. Francisco Cervelli C

8. Jordy Mercer SS

9. Gerrit Cole RHP

Advertise with us

That would leave such names as David Freese (1B/3B), John Jaso (1B/3B/OF), Chris Stewart (C) and Adam Frazier (UTIL), and a free agent/non-roster invitee on the bench.

Brian: There is lots of discussion about whether the Pirates should/would trade McCutchen. In my opinion, given Josh Bell's defensive deficiencies and relatively high value to an AL team, he is the better trade candidate. What are the chances the Pirates package Bell with Tyler Glasnow or another high level prospect to get a quality controllable pitcher such as Chris Sale, Chris Archer, or Sonny Gray? Relatedly, what is your sense of the Pirates' belief in Bell's ability to improve defensively? His defense now seems prohibitively bad at 1B and RF.

It would fly in the face of everything the Neal Huntington regime has preached to trade its top two prospects, Bell and Glasnow, at this point. I agree with you that the price to acquire Sale (signed through 2019), Archer (2021) and Gray (2019) would require parting with cream-of-the-crop prospects. But let’s be clear here that those three starters are in three distinct tiers. Sale, 27, is a Cy Young candidate again this season. Archer, 29, pitched pretty well (4.02 ERA) for a bad team. Gray, 26, was one of the very worst starters in the majors. He had a 5.69 ERA in 22 starts. Nobody wants to give up on him because his stuff is ridiculous, but at this point Gray is no Sale.

Bell gave the Pirates a lot to be excited about this season. He had a .273 average and .775 OPS in 45 games in the majors, and you’d expect he’ll continue to be productive with more reps next season. Offensively, he is what the Pirates have hoped and expected he would be.

But Bell was shaky defensively. That also was expected. He had three errors in 150 innings at first base, and one error in 108 innings in right field. He had -8 defensive runs saved, according to Baseball Info Solutions. Only Mercer (-9) and McCutchen (-28) were lower on the charts, and they played the full season. The Pirates front office says it believes Bell’s defense will improve in time, and perhaps it will. Bell still has only played first base for a relatively short while, but I think it’s fair to assume he’ll never be a Gold Glover. And that’s fine. I don’t think his glove is the reason the Pirates would give up on him and trade him away to the American League. If he can be a high-average, high on-base hitter with some pop, that’ll go a long way at this level.

Advertise with us

Regis: With influx of youth arms in rotation next year, do Pirates bring in Kiefer Sutherland & Emilio Estevez for a "Young Guns" theme?

Time well spent.

Jake: Is Gerrit Cole a top of the rotation ace?

When healthy, yes. Problem is, he’s only been healthy for one full season, so there’s not a whole lot of numbers to back up the claim that he is a true, top-tier ace. If you ask around the clubhouse, as I did at the end of the one healthy season, everybody around sees him as an ace. An unhealthy ace, though, is of little use to a contender. And so Cole still has plenty left to prove.

At this point, Cole has earned respect in the clubhouse and around the league, but he hasn’t earned a spot among the top aces in the National League — Clayton Kershaw, Madison Bumgarner, Max Scherzer, Johnny Cueto and every man in the Chicago Cubs rotation.

Advertise with us

Kid Robbie: Besides the pitching uncertainties headed into 2017, my biggest concern for next year lies at the other end of that 60'6" stretch of the diamond. Cervelli is good enough, especially defensively when he's healthy, but we know he won't be all year. That leaves Stewart (also fragile), Elias Diaz, and maybe Jacob Stallings to get the team through the year. I assume Eric Fryer is not in the plans unless disaster hits. Do you think Diaz can be a good alternative in 2017 when Cervelli goes down? Does Stallings have the talent to someday be an everyday MLB catcher?

There certainly are question marks for the Pirates at catcher, and you provided two of them. The Pirates used six different catchers this season. That wasn’t part of their plan. Cervelli has been injury-prone throughout his career and was dinged up a couple times this season, including a midsummer stint on the disabled list. Suffice it to say the Pirates will need to rely on a backup catcher at some point next season. Option A is Stewart, who is coming off knee surgery that he admitted was the only way his career was going to be able to continue. Stewart has been steady and reliable, for the most part, and he’s signed through this season. Fryer is still under team control, but if Stewart is healthy the Pirates won’t roster three catchers to start the season, and Fryer is out of minor league options. So you’ll probably see Stewart or Fryer with the Pirates next season, but not both.

If Cervelli goes down next season and Stewart is his backup, I think Diaz would have to be the long-term replacement. Stewart isn’t positioned to start every day for a long period of time. The book on Diaz, 25, is that he is an excellent defender with a strong arm. He’s hit .261 with little power in parts of three seasons with Class AAA Indianapolis. Stallings isn’t a realistic option to fill in for Cervelli on an everyday basis. He is a capable defensive replacement but has hit .237 in his minor league career, with a .214 average at Indianapolis this past season.

Josh: Will Clint Hurdle be on the hot seat for next season, considering he has as many losing seasons here as winning one’s?

Hurdle wasn’t really dealt a winning hand this season, as his roster cycled though a franchise-record 55 players this year. Set aside the injuries for a moment and remember that this team started with a rotation of Cole, Francisco Liriano, Jon Niese, Jeff Locke and Juan Nicasio and ended with Jameson Taillon, Ivan Nova, Chad Kuhl, Glasnow/Steven Brault and Ryan Vogelsong. To miss the playoffs with that turnover and that motley crew seems forgivable. Some of Hurdle’s lineups tweaks worked, some didn’t. Some bullpen moves worked, some didn’t. But none of his moves explain a 98-win team dropping by 20 wins.

Advertise with us

As I’ve said in previous ‘bags, the thing that gets a manager such as Hurdle booted at this point is a rift between him and the front office. The Pirates have shown no such scuffles, and so Hurdle’s job appears to be safe. There’s more to a manager’s resume than the fact he has three winning seasons and three losing seasons since taking over for a team that lost 20 seasons in a row.

Interstate44: When does the Spring Training schedule get released? Thats the best part of the season, full of optimism, great weather, etc.

Look for the schedule to be released in mid-November. It was Nov. 10 in 2014, Nov. 17 in 2015.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.