Welcome back, Pirates fans. Many are in meltdown mode after Jeff Locke tumbled through three-plus innings — seven hits, five walks, five runs — in a 9-5 loss against the Milwaukee Brewers Wednesday night. The Pirates fell to 48-46 and now are nine games back of the National League Central division lead and three games out of the second NL wild-card spot.
Readers had some questions and complaints. Let’s get to them. If you’ve got a question for next week’s mailbag, email snesbitt@post-gazette.com or send them on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.
Here we go.
Chad: What blackmail does Locke have on Clint Hurdle and the front office? I know he isn’t pitching on performance.
Hey, what more do you need from a fifth starter than somebody who, more often than not, gives the team a chance to win. The Pirates are 9-9 in Locke’s 18 starts this season, so, in a way, he’s given them a shot. But his production has been so imbalanced that, given the Pirates’ other options, Locke’s security in the rotation has gotten shakier and shakier.
In Locke’s worst six outings, he has a 15.75 ERA — 42 earned runs in 24 innings.
Read More
In Locke’s other 13 appearances, he has a 2.47 ERA — 22 earned runs in 80 innings.
If that ain’t the definition of “maddeningly inconsistent” …
His overall ERA is 5.54, his worst since posting a 6.48 mark in four games in 2011. His xFIP, which takes into account defense, is 4.96, suggesting his ERA might be a little over-inflated. But, still.
When the Pirates were hamstrung by injuries the past couple months, Locke at times played the stopper. He still is their last starter to survive seven innings, which he has done five times this season. But when the Pirates are playing with a full deck — and particularly in a stretch such as this when they need just four starters — Locke simply isn’t one of their top options. The Pirates already decided Jon Niese wasn’t a top-four option by putting him in the bullpen, and they could choose to do the same with Locke, but they certainly don’t need two lefty long relievers in the bullpen.
More on that a little later on.
Joe: Will the Pirates FINALLY let Locke go?
They probably would be more likely to let Niese go than Locke. Both pitchers could conceivably be kept under contract for two more years, and Locke is cheaper and arguably has a higher ceiling. Niese has two club options left. If those were picked up, he would make $10 million in 2017 and $11 million in 2018. Locke has two year of arbitration remaining. He is making $3.025 million this season and would get moderate raises in arbitration, but not Niese money.
Josh W.: What are the chances Locke and/or Niese is shipped out at the trade deadline?
Josh C.: What would a return on Niese be now? Specific teams that have expressed interest? Would it be wise to keep him in ‘pen?
I’d peg it at a near-certainty one of them is gone by the deadline. For the reasons mentioned above, I’d guess the player most likely to leave is Niese. The Pirates started shopping Niese before the All-Star break and had a few scouts out to watch his July 10 start. Coming out of the break, the Pirates put Niese in the bullpen, a move that is unlikely to help his trade value, though he’s pitched five scoreless innings as a reliever. The Pirates don’t need two lefty long relievers, and neither Niese nor Locke is suited to be a one-inning guy or a LOOGY.
As for what sort of return the Pirates could get for Niese? Not much. Top-end starters will bring in huge hauls this year. Back-of-the-rotation starters or long relievers could help a ball club just trying to plug a spot in the rotation for the last two months of the season, but they won’t fetch much. Take, for instance, the J.A. Happ move last year. He had a 4.64 ERA with the Seattle Mariners at that point and cost the Pirates right-hander Adrian Sampson, a decent prospect but not among their top young guns. Niese has a 4.89 ERA and now would need to get stretched out again before he rejoins some team’s rotation. If the Pirates can find a suitor for him, they could dangle the fact that he has two club options left, but that likely won’t play a big factor in netting them a big return. At this rate, I don’t anticipate those options being picked up here or anywhere he might land. If Niese isn’t traded, sure, keep him in the bullpen and see what he can provide in the long-relief role. He probably won’t be needed back in the rotation.
John: How was Jameson Taillon able to continue pitching in the game if he went into concussion protocol?
There’s some good information in today’s notebook. It appears the Pirates took a number of precautions to check on Taillon during the game, but they did not feel it was necessary to remove him. The protocol began with them checking on the mound, continued with between-inning visits with a team doctor and continued that night and the following day. The Pirates team of athletic trainers and doctors, while running tests and all that goes with keeping tabs on a potential head injury, have 48 hours after the event to decide whether the player needs to go on the seven-day concussion disabled list.
Bucs: Doesn’t the long-term stability of a small-market team rely on getting return for expiring assets? Seems like a Mark Melancon trade makes sense.
Trading Melancon would bring a nice return — the Pirates, remember, gave up shortstop prospect Jacoby Jones for rental right-hander Joakim Soria last season — but the Pirates bullpen is unquestionably weaker without him. So long as the Pirates are still within striking distance of a wild-card spot when the deadline rolls around, I’d expect they hold onto Melancon and continue their push for a fourth consecutive playoff berth. I’d also argue that there’s a potential return coming if the Pirates keep Melancon through the season. If they offer him a qualifying offer this offseason — something we discussed in last week’s mailbag — they’ll either keep him on an expensive one-year deal in 2017 and again have a top closer or they’ll get a compensation draft pick, which is a quality asset to add.
Adam: When are we going to see Chad Kuhl and Tyler Glasnow join Taillon and Gerrit Cole in the rotation?
Not yet. As previously explained, the Pirates don’t need five starting pitchers right now. They can work with four for the next two weeks or so, and by that point they’ll have a better idea of who their options are. Glasnow should be here Saturday to make his second start, and that’ll help, too.
So, let’s look at their options at this point in time, ordered by number of starts:
Francisco Liriano: 5.11 ERA, 4.81 xFIP in 18 starts
Locke: 5.67 ERA, 4.99 xFIP in 18 starts
Niese: 5.13 ERA, 4.35 xFIP in 18 starts
Cole: 3.11 ERA, 4.01 xFIP in 13 starts
Juan Nicasio: 5.05 ERA, 4.28 xFIP in 12 starts
Taillon: 3.44 ERA, 3.40 xFIP in 6 starts
Kuhl: 4.19 ERA, 5.42 xFIP 4 starts
Ryan Vogelsong: 1.29 ERA, 2.82 xFIP in 2 starts
Steven Brault: 2.25 ERA, 4.24 xFIP in 1 start
Glasnow: 6.75 ERA, 3.97 xFIP in 1 start
Wilfredo Boscan: 21.00 ERA, 8.28 xFIP in 1 start
So very many options.
As it stands today, the Pirates’ top three are Cole, Liriano and Taillon. Liriano has not pitched well, but he will not be bumped from the rotation anytime soon. Behind them is a long line of either ineffective or inexperienced starters. Best-case scenario probably is that Glasnow shows well on Saturday and takes a rotation spot in August. That’s four. The last spot likely would go to Locke or Kuhl — who was OK for three starts and terrific in his final start — or Niese, if he’s still around. Kuhl could win that spot, but I do think it would be somewhat of a surprise to see the Pirates to ride three rookie right-handers down the stretch if they stay bent on reaching the playoffs.
Bill: What’s your take on Steven Brault … one of the pitchers they got from the O’s in the “Lunchbox Hero” [Travis Snider] trade?
That trade just keeps getting better. Brault is a really promising young arm. He held his own in his debut this month, despite being a guy who did not at all enter spring training expecting he’d reach the majors in 2016. He won’t be an ace, which is fine, but he projects to be a productive left-hander to add to the rotation somewhere down the road — and probably not terribly far down the road. He tossed six no-hit innings the other day and has a 2.23 ERA and 1.18 WHIP in 11 games with Class AAA Indianapolis.
Plus, he’s got a killer honeycomb-pattern sleeve tattoo on his right arm.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.