Wizards and wargs and wisecracks are so last week. It’s time for another edition of the Pirates mailbag, a weekly question-and-answer feature that sometimes touches on the game of baseball.

If you’ve got a question for next week’s mailbag, email snesbitt@post-gazette.com or shoot them my way on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt. Don’t miss our previous installments, either. Week 1: The uniformity of uniforms. Week 2: Super Two and you. Week 3: Pirates and Game of Thrones.

Here we go.

Mike: I am checking to see if you respond to emails? Please let me know.

Advertise with us

No.

Bill: I find it hard to believe that the Pirates gave this guy Francisco Cervelli a $31 million three year contract. He is arguably the worst defensive catcher in all of baseball. He can't catch the ball behind the plate. He leads the league in pass balls. He throws very few runners out at second base, and then finally we have the wonderful ending to yesterday's game. I watched three hours of a dreadfully boring 1-1 game only to see this bum ruin a well pitched game by Jon Neise by unexplainably throwing the ball six feet wide of John Jaso into right field, leading to four unearned runs and a sickening loss.

This team is a shell of itself from last year. The pitching staff is weak at best, Jung Ho Kang is no longer a major league player after the horrible injury. Starling Marte looks like a fool swinging at pitches in the dirt and others so far outside he can't even reach them with the end of his bat, and then we have Andrew McCutchen. I can't believe some of the balls that he has flubbed in the outfield this year that he normally gobbled up in past years. And he is certainly not about to challenge for the batting title this year. He may challenge for the league lead in strikeouts instead. Oh well, I guess it was about time for the Cubs to break that curse!!

I would be interested to hear your views on what I have pointed out above.

Anything, it could be argued, can be argued. You have picked a peculiar battle to fight. Cervelli is considered by many metrics and baseball experts to be a very good defensive catcher. He’s not peak Yadier Molina, and he’s not Buster Posey. The reason this guy gets a three-year, $31 million deal is because he’s above-average both offensively and defensively. He is a contact hitter, an excellent pitch-framer and he works well with the Pirates pitching staff. That’s a difficult blend to find, and it’s worth a lot of money on the free-agent market. Cervelli would have been the top catcher on the market this fall. He wouldn’t have made Russell Martin money (five years, $82 million), but barring injury or collapse he would have gotten more than three and 31.

Advertise with us

Cervelli’s 4.5 Wins Above Replacement since joining the Pirates last season is fourth-best on the Pirates — behind Andrew McCutchen (6.9) and Starling Marte (5.5) and tied with Gregory Polanco and Jung Ho Kang — and second among major league catchers to the San Francisco Giants’ Posey (6.6). So, he’s a good baseball player. That’s hard to dispute.

Your issue is with his defense. But it seems your primary contention is with a single play made — or not made — in the ninth inning of a tied ballgame last week. Cervelli committed an error, his fifth this season, and it cost the Pirates the game. That doesn’t seem like reason enough to void his contract. He had 10 passed balls last year. Know who had the most, with 19? Martin, in 11 fewer starts. The Pirates were abysmal against the running game last year; teams swiped 101 bases on Cervelli, who threw out only 29 runners. Clint Hurdle heaps most of the blame there on the pitchers. They’ve kept runners more honest this season, and Cervelli has thrown out nine of 26 would-be base-stealers, for 34.6 percent.

As for your other points, I’ll have to save them for another mailbag. There’s so much more to see!

Ed: Are we stuck with Jeff Locke for eternity?

Seems like a stretch.

Advertise with us

Thomas: Is Luis Heredia still considered a prospect? How is he doing?

Heredia hasn’t listed on top-prospect rankings in a few years now, but, sure, he’s still a prospect. He’s still only 21 and so far this season has put up great numbers for Class High-A Bradenton. He started pitching out of the bullpen in the Mexican Pacific Winter League this past offseason. In 15 outings this season, he has a 0.87 ERA over 20⅔ innings. He’s a long way from being part of the equation at the major league level, but now he’s back to building forward momentum.

Fred: Why is Pirates management obsessed with resting superior young athletes? Where's the evidence that this benefits the team?

It’s stored in their servers, and I forgot my login again. If I recall correctly, the evidence pointed toward a hypothesis that rest will keep them healthy and producing at a high level for many, many moons.

Glenn: How much longer should I stash Tyler Glasnow on my fantasy team? I understand Jameson Taillon is complicating the issue.

Advertise with us

Haven’t played fantasy baseball since middle school, so not sure how exactly rosters work nowadays. If it’s a non-keeper league and you’re thin on pitching, I probably wouldn’t hold onto him too tight. Taillon likely will be called upon first — maybe even Chad Kuhl — before Glasnow makes his anticipated debut. Glasnow has killer stuff, and he’ll continue to put up good numbers at Class AAA Indianapolis, but there’s another step it seems he has to take before they’re ready to call on him.

Thomas: What happened to those two guys from India whom the Pirates signed?

Rinku Singh’s storybook rise was badly derailed by injuries. He has a 2.99 ERA in four seasons in the minors but hasn’t played for a Pirates affiliate since 2012. He missed the past three seasons due to Tommy John surgery and a complicated recovery, followed by a broken elbow. The Pirates re-signed him to a minor-league deal last offseason, so he’s still in the organization.

Dinesh Patel made 15 appearances at rookie ball in 2009 and 2010 before he was released.

Thomas: Where is Brandon Cumpton when we could use him?

Advertise with us

Far, far away. Cumpton had Tommy John surgery in March 2015 and then right shoulder subacromial decompression surgery six months later. His estimated timetable to return was pushed to 13-15 months, which would be between October and December this year. So, don’t hold your breath expecting news on Cumpton. He and his wife, however, are expecting.

Adam: Do you happen to know what company makes Matt Joyce's bats?

The Old Hickory Bat Company.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.