CHICAGO — The Pirates are back to square off against the Chicago Cubs, who swept them last week, and we’re back for another mailbag. As tends to happen around this time in years when the Pirates have prospects on fire at Class AAA Indianapolis, the reader questions this week all were super.

Super Two, that is.

If you’ve got a question for next week’s mailbag, email snesbitt@post-gazette.com or send them on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.

Thomas Kerr: Are there any of the Indy starters who don’t have Super 2 issues and could be called up as improvements on current Pirates starters? Wilfredo Boscan?

Advertise with us

To answer your question briefly, no, I don’t believe there is an immediate upgrade currently waiting at Class AAA Indianapolis that isn’t named Jameson Taillon or Tyler Glasnow. If anything, the Pirates likely would shift a long reliever, say, Ryan Vogelsong or Kyle Lobstein, into the rotation to make a few starts here in May before Taillon and/or Glasnow are ready for promotion.

But, hey, I think this is a perfect time for a Super Two explainer.

A typical major league season includes 183 service days — 162 games, 21 off days. A player accrues service time for every day he is on the 25-man active roster or MLB disabled list. If he reaches 172 service days in a season, that’s considered a full year. With me so far?

Teams own a player’s rights for his first six full years in the majors. So until his service time reaches six years, zero days — this is written 6.000 (Years.Days) — he’s under team control.

The pay structure those six years generally begin with three years at or slightly above league-minimum salary ($507,500 in 2016), followed by three years of salary arbitration and, finally, the freedom of free agency.

Advertise with us

Consider this hot-shot prospect we’ll name Gene Collier. Collier, a great ballplayer, made the opening-day roster this year. His service time currently is 0.037, and he is making a league-minimum salary. Should he remain in the majors through September, he surely will eclipse 172 service days by the end of the season and have a full year of MLB service time under his belt.

So, barring a contract extension making this moot, here’s how Collier’s next six years will look.

2017: With 1.000 service time, Collier will earn ≈$500,000, with maybe a small raise.

2018: With 2.000 service time, Collier will earn ≈$500,000, with maybe a slightly bigger raise.

2019: With 3.000 service time, Collier enters Year 1 of arbitration. Let’s say he gets $3 million.

Advertise with us

2020: With 4.000 service time, Collier enters Year 2 of arbitration. Let’s say he gets $6 million.

2021: With 5.000 service time, Collier enters Year 3 of arbitration. Let’s say he gets $9 million.

2022: With 6.000 service time, Collier is a free agent.

Simple enough, right?

But wait. Teams would really prefer to keep Collier from reaching the magic 6.000 until his seventh year in the majors. How might they pull that off?

Advertise with us

There are two important time periods to watch in a rookie year.

Mid-April

Remember all the fuss over the Chicago Cubs waiting almost two weeks to call up whiz kid Kris Bryant last year? He ended his rookie season with 0.171 service time — exactly one day short of a full season. That strategic move means the Cubs still have six full seasons before he hits free agency. It’s a rather mean play, since Bryant deserved a spot on the opening-day roster, and so Bryant filed a grievance for service-time manipulation, but most teams would sacrifice a star prospect for two weeks in April in order to gain an extra year before he hits free agency. 

While the Cubs made delayed Bryant’s promotion, their right fielder Jason Heyward benefitted from the Atlanta Braves not doing so in 2010. Heyward made the Braves’ opening-day roster as a rookie and spent five years with them. After one year with the St. Louis Cardinals, his service clock hit exactly 6.000. Heyward became a free agent at 26 years old and netted a monster eight-year, $184 million offer from the Cubs. Had the Braves kept him in the minors for a couple weeks in April 2010, he’d have ended last year at or below 5.171 and would still be under Cardinals control.

June

OK, here’s when Super Two comes in. For players with service times between 2.000 and 3.000 every winter, those ranked in the highest 22 percent of service time are given a fourth year of salary arbitration. This is the Super Two exception. Teams attempt to measure the Super Two cut-off date — which is not an specific date each year but a range of days — to keep prospects out of that top 22 percent.

Advertise with us

Here are the Super Two cut-offs the past few years:

2015: 2.130

2014: 2.133

2013: 2.122

2012: 2.140

Advertise with us

2011: 2.146

2010: 2.122

2009: 2.139

The cut-off, then, likely is above 2.120. That means if a team keeps a prospect in the minors for at least 63 days, they’re in a pretty safe zone for avoiding Super Two arbitration with him down the road.

Take Gerrit Cole. The Pirates called him up June 11, 2013, and he’s been in the majors ever since. His service clock entering this year was 2.111. The Pirates avoided Super Two with him. Had he been at 2.130 or higher last winter, he’d have been Super Two and would have gotten an early year of arbitration and would certainly be making more than his current $541,000 salary. Instead, he’ll hit arbitration for this first time this winter, and his salary will accelerate.

Advertise with us

Take Bryant, again. Assuming he remains in the majors, after the 2017 season he’ll be at 2.171 and will no doubt be in the highest 22 percent. He’ll be Super Two, and the Cubs will have to start paying him bigger money a year earlier than had they called him up in June.

So, there you have it. Prospect promotions are carefully watched in order to save money and extend a year of team control, though oftentimes these players have plenty to work on during 60-70 days in the minors.

Carter Brock: What is the possible ETA of Glasnow and Taillon? Soon?

The possible ETA, I suppose, would be right around June 5. If my numbers are correct, that’s the 64th service day this season. But, again, the actual Super Two cut-off could long before that, we just won’t know the actual number for a couple more years. And like with Cole, the Pirates could wait another week past the projected cut-off date to call someone up, if they do.

Chris Davis: Who's promoted first? Glasnow or Taillon? Just give me a date and I'm good not much to ask for.

Advertise with us

No dice on the date, Chris.

I think we’ll see Taillon in the majors before Glasnow. Glasnow’s raw stuff may be better, but Taillon is a more seasoned pitcher, even having missed the past two seasons to injury, and from what I saw at spring training Taillon seems the more polished product.

Here are their pitching lines so far this season:

Taillon: 6 G, 37.1 IP, 25 H, 4 BB, 32 K, 1.69 ERA, .187 AVG, 0.78 WHIP.

Glasnow: 6 G, 33.0 IP, 21 H, 13 BB, 48 K, 1.64 ERA, .184 AVG, 1.03 WHIP.

Advertise with us

Those are some exciting numbers. The Pirates are faced with a choice of not only if or when to make a call to Indianapolis, but who to grab first. Both guys are still working through things — they aren’t being kept in the minors just to save money — but both appear deserving of a shot to start in the majors.

It’s not entirely clear how the Pirates pitching staff would shake out should Taillon or Glasnow be called up and plugged in to the rotation. If both are called up, mercy, it’ll cause a pretty wild reshuffling. The most likely option to see both would be because of injury to a starter or two. So far, there’s been nothing significant enough to go beyond Vogelsong for a spot start.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.