The Pirates certainly didn’t meet the demands of their first series against the Chicago Cubs — they were soundly swept and have now lost four games in a row — but I’m up to the challenge of dumping out the contents of our first Pirates mailbag and trying to make sense of it all.
Plenty of questions after a week that began so well and ended so poorly for the Pirates, who are 15-13. If you’ve got a question for next week’s mailbag, email snesbitt@post-gazette.com or fire them my way on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.
There obviously is only one place for this to begin. Here are Ryan Vogelsong and Gerrit Cole chirping the Washington Capitals from the first row in the Penguins’ big Game 4 win last night.
Gerrit Cole, a Californian who loves his hockey, fitting right in at Pens-Caps Game 4. Here’s @AmandaJupena’s video: pic.twitter.com/403bXxfaLe
— Stephen J. Nesbitt (@stephenjnesbitt) May 5, 2016
NBCSN caught Gerrit Cole being told to cool it on the heckling. Seemed like he was a good sport about it. pic.twitter.com/bdGCohJgmk
— Alex Iniguez (@alexiniguez) May 5, 2016
Andrew McCutchen also had thoughts.
— andrew mccutchen (@TheCUTCH22) May 5, 2016
Now, to the questions. Did myself a favor and skipped the ones suggesting Jake Arrieta and/or Neil Walker are on steroids.
Mark Gleason: I know the NBL does not have a dress code like the NFL. However, this does not preclude players dressing alike. The big thing now seems to be not to dampen the players’ enthusiasm, no throwing bats after home runs, no making faces or excessive demonstration.
For a number of years I used to write to the manager of the Pirates each year and suggest the team all dress alike, like the Pirates of old. Dress like ball player. No long pants. We were such a poor playing team, at least they could look like the [Roberto] Clemente teams of old. Look alike, play the best you can, but look like a ball team even if you aren’t.
I went to a ball game one night and Kevin Young was on first base. His long pants were tailored bell bottom. Now we have a mixture. One night Andrew wears long pants, the next night he wears the Clemente striped socks. Still a great player.
A few of the players wear black socks, not striped. Can’t dampen their enthusiasm.
I had a reply once from a manager who said this was a good idea, all dressing like players used to, and he would suggest it. Suggest it?
They are doing great. But Just think how they would look each day, with striped socks, like the Clemente teams of old. All together and it would not dampen their enthusiasm.
At first, it seemed absurd to print this whole prompt, but then it seemed absurd not to. So, I walked around the Pirates clubhouse the other day, handed my phone over to a couple players and asked them to read the email and respond. So, they read, laughed, and then replied.
Read More
“Can’t knock his enthusiasm,” reliever Kyle Lobstein said. He paused for seven seconds before continuing. “Well, honestly, I don’t know that he’s wrong. I can’t say I feel that strongly either way.”
The consensus was that players should be able to choose whether they wear their pants long, down over their shoe-tops, or pulled high to the knees. It’s a comfort thing. When you’re playing 162 games, comfort matters. You don’t want to be picking at your jersey all day.
“My response to that would be: no,” Jordy Mercer said. “Here's my reason why: Some guys like to wear their pants down. It's personal preference. … It’s not going to have anything to do anything with the way we play. Zero. You're just going to be less comfortable that way.”
Here’s a twist to this debate: Most minor-league teams require players to wear their pants up with the same socks. Lobstein, who wears his pants low now but didn’t when he played in the Tampa Bay Rays and Detroit Tigers minor league systems, says if minor-leaguers gripe about their pant lengths, coaches tell them, “If you don’t like it, play better.”
You know how back in Little League, if you wanted high socks you’d just pull up your long pants? Well, in the majors, players have the option of two pants in their lockers, a long pant and a short pant, so they won’t have excess material bunched at their knees. Not so in the minors.
“I think part of it is so they save the pants a bit,” Lobstein said. “Less material."
Mercer wore high socks through the minors with the Pirates. When he was called up, he was excited for many reasons. One of them was he know had a choice of how to dress on the field.
“That's one of the privilege you get of being called up,” Mercer said. “You get to wear your pants down.”
Now, Mark, you would want to take that privilege from them, would you? This falls under the umbrella of old-school vs. new-school, so you’re sure to find lots of folks on either side of the fence. You made a strong case, kudos to you, but I think the same-pants ship has sailed. If you get a chance, write back next week and let us know which manager agreed with your suggestion. Or perhaps we should guess.
Christy Rosati: Have you seen/heard anything about an innings or pitches limit for Tyler Glasnow and Jameson Tallion this year? If so, how do you see that factoring in to when they're called up and how they may be used?
The Pirates have made no such suggestion, but they’ll keep a careful watch on their workloads. The best guess is to look at how many innings they’ve thrown in previous seasons — and, with Taillon, it’s tricker to predict, since he’s missed the past two seasons with Tommy John and hernia surgeries.
In 2012, Taillon threw 142 innings. In 2013, 147 1/3. He made 26 appearances each year.
Glasnow’s highest innings count was 124 1/3 at Class A Bradenton in 2014. Last season, slowed by a midseason injury, he threw 109 1/3 innings.
So, neither guy is going to blow those numbers out of the water this season. But, man, they’ve come out of the chute firing. Glasnow has a 2.08 ERA in five starts (37 strikeouts, 12 walks in 26 innings), and Taillon has a 1.19 ERA in his first five starts (26 strikeouts, four walks, 0.76 WHIP in 30 1/3 innings).
I don’t expect an innings count will affect their potential promotions too much. If they’re needed in the majors, the Pirates will determine which guy is a better fit and plug him in. But you’re not going to see them tossing complete games, either. Their pitch counts have stayed relatively low so far, with Glasnow going five or six innings a pop, and Taillon getting through seven when especially efficient.
@TKerr46: Are the Pirates likely to modify the shallow outfield philosophy? Cutch would have caught Anthony Rizzo’s double on the track last year.
When the Pirates go against the grain with an analytically minded move such as this one, with their outfielders all setting up shallower in the outfield, it’s based off piles and piles of data they’ve collected and mined over the years. They likely won’t be quick to abandon this experiment, either. You’ll be able to pick out a few plays here and there where a bad route or poor positioning led to an extra-base hit, but the evidence goes both ways. The difference is, when having a shallow outfield burns you, that means a ball gets to the wall for extra bases and, often, extra runs. (Like the other day when two balls got over Gregory Polanco’s head after he read them poorly off the bat.) A couple balls falling in front of you don’t have quite the same immediate effect. So, I could see them changing course a little should their pitching staff continue to get hit pretty hard, but I’d also expect they stick with the shallower outfield for more than 30 games this year.
@JSteinbeck1939: When will Jung Ho Kang return? Where will he play upon his return?
Rehab assignments for position players can last a maximum of 20 days, which would mean Kang should be back around Sunday. But the Pirates can always pause or halt a rehab if they feel Kang needs more time. The Pirates expect Kang to slot right back in at third base when he returns. Neal Huntington said that from the first hour after he signed David Freese in March, making it crystal clear Freese will back up Kang and platoon at first base. Huntington said the other day Kang likely will start two of every three games to start out, and be available to pinch hit on the off day. So, Freese will still get plenty of playing time.
@Thejoke_err: is there a real first baseman in the system?
Depends what you mean by “real first baseman.” Do they have a first baseman ready for the majors? Sure, Josh Bell looks darn close, like he could come up and perform in a pinch. But — and what I expect you mean is — Bell is a natural outfielder still learning the position at first base. He’s coming along well, but there’s still work to be done. There’s definitely an argument to be made that the Pirates have failed to bring along a natural prospect at first base after Pedro Alvarez was drafted and rushed through the system, but Bell isn't a bad option to have there, either. Plus, depending on how you feel about his age, Jason Rogers is a pretty real first baseman who still is under team control for a while. The Pirates have John Jaso signed through next year, and with Rogers and Bell in line after that, that should suffice all right. Also, keep an eye on Class AA Altoona first baseman Jose Osuna, who has put up some nice numbers.
@petey77us_mark So with McCutchen complaining about the error and Cole getting drunk at a Pens game does Clint Hurdle need to refocus the team?
The first half of this question is referring to McCutchen disagreeing with the official scorer’s decision to award him an error in yesterday’s game. That is a thing that happens. Players, particularly Gold Glovers, don’t like adding errors to their name.
As for Cole … come on, man. God forbid that at some point over the course of a maddening 162-game season a guy goes to a hockey game with his fiancée and his pal Vogey and his wife and has a good time and a Miller Lite tall boy or two. I’m sure the Penguins appreciated the support, and plenty of people got a lot of enjoyment out of seeing Cole’s rather harmless antics.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.