By Paul Zeise
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Pirates pitchers Gerritt Cole won his first four career starts but there were times in each of those four games that he looked like the rookie that he is despite his status as one of the most heralded prospects in the entire organization.
So it was inevitable in this season that he would have a few days when he labored through innings and struggled make pitches because bumps in the road and adversity are part of the growth process for young players.
Thursday, in his fifth start, Cole had one of those days as he was chased after just 5 1/3 innings in a 6-4 Pirates loss to the Phillies before 35,328 at PNC Park on Independence Day.
Cole (4-1) wasn’t terrible and did have some good moments (a 1-2-3 4th), but he gave up eight hits, three runs (all earned) and struck out five and he probably would have given up a run or two more had it not been for some excellent fielding by the Pirates.
Meanwhile another Cole – Phillies starter Cole Hamel s– showed flashes of the dominant pitcher he had been in recent years as opposed to the guy who has 11 losses and an era of more than 4.5.
Hamels pitched seven strong innings, gave up only five hits and two runs (one earned) and struck out seven and frankly was maybe only an error in strategy away from shutting out the Pirates for 7 innings.
That’s because the two runs he gave up came in the form of a two-out, two-run single by Andrew McCutchen in the bottom of the third inning and it was a bit of a surprise that McCutchen wasn’t walked in that spot – with runners on second and third and two outs.
Had Hamels walked McCutchen, he would have then pitched to Gaby Sanchez, a .232 hitter who was 0-for-4 Thursday, but he didn’t and McCutchen made him pay.
That gave the Pirates a 2-0 lead but was all the damage the Pirates would do against Hamels, who retired the next ten batters after McCutchen and gave up only one hit over his final four innings.
The Phillies threatened in the first inning with two hits but Pirates catch Russell Martin picked off Ben Revere and caught Jimmy Rollins attempting to steal second in order to help minimize the damage.
Cole, despite facing baserunners in three of the first four innings, managed to avoid trouble until the top of the fifth inning when the Phillies used two hits, including an RBI single by Ben Revere, to et their first run of the game.
And when Ryan Howard walked and Domonic Brown singled with one out in the top of the 7th, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle had seen enough and he replaced Cole with Vin Mazzaro in hopes of getting out of the jam.
But Mazzaro gave up consecutive singles to Delmon Young, Kevin Frandsen and Carlos Ruiz and the Phillies had their first lead of the day, 4-2.
The Phillies would then pick up their 5th run before the inning was over on a fielder’s choice by Ben Revere and tack on a sixth in the top of the 8th on a sacrifice fly by pinch hitter Michael Young.
Hamels (3-11) earned the win and Phillies closer Jonathan Papelbon pitched a scoreless 9th to pick up his 17th save on the season.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.