UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. – The countdown to Penn State’s annual spring game is on and with the final week of spring practices underway there are four areas of concern that James Franklin mentioned on Saturday.

James Franklin addresses the media on March 17 before the start of Penn State’s spring practice. (Associated Press)

One position that Franklin isn’t concerned with is at defensive end where Garrett Sickels and Carl Nassib are highlighting a rotation that also includes Evan Schwan, Curtis Cothran and Torrence Brown. Sickels looks like he’s finally putting it all together after redshirting as a true freshman and playing in the d-end rotation last year. He pushed left tackle Paris Palmer back into Christian Hackenberg during Saturday’s practice and Sickels finished the play by scooping up Hackenberg’s fumble.

By the looks of it right now the defensive line hasn’t missed a beat with the two new defensive ends, but of course that also means Penn State’s development at left tackle is still a work in progress.

How is middle linebacker shaping up? It was supposed to be one of the biggest spring questions, but replacing Mike Hull at middle linebacker is Nyeem Wartman, who despite being limited for part of spring practice, knows exactly what’s expected of him. I talked with Wartman last week who said the development of the linebackers around him-- particularly Brandon Bell and Jason Cabinda-- are making his transition inside easier. Remember, Wartman came to Penn State as a middle linebacker where he backed up Glenn Carson as a freshman before getting hurt early in the season. This is a natural progression for him and defensive coordinator Bob Shoop doesn’t have concerns about Wartman being a leader on defense.

Advertise with us

So, defensive end and middle linebacker, once thought to be two areas of need entering spring are no longer issues.

Below are the four positions Franklin identified as areas of concern as well as my analysis of each position and what, if anything, can be done to fix it.

1) Left tackle 

Why it’s a problem: No surprise this is the big one and either Paris Palmer or Chance Sorrell have to make great strides this summer to take hold of the position. Both have to put on more weight and while the staff raves about Palmer’s footwork and his transition since enrolling in January, he physically doesn’t look the part right now.

Penn State offensive line coach Herb Hand and tackles Charlie Shuman, Albert Hall, Brendan Brosnan and Chance Sorrell watch Paris Palmer run a drill. (Audrey Snyder / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Listed at 6-7, 278 lbs. Franklin wants Palmer around 305 lbs. when the season starts. Will he be able to move as well as he does now with the extra weight? No doubt Palmer has the upper hand in experience because of the two years of junior college football under his belt, but right now he needs more time to grow into the position while Sorrell, at 6-5, 285 lbs., needs the same.

Advertise with us

How to fix it: Time and a lot of protein. The offensive linemen stayed after Saturday’s practice where Palmer and Sorrell worked on footwork once more. There’s no quick fix here and I don’t think moving right tackle Andrew Nelson over to left tackle is much of an option at this point.

Nelson says he can do it and did so a bit last year when Donovan Smith was injured, but even if they’d move him there would still be a vacant spot at right tackle. Those candidates would likely include walk-on Albert Hall, redshirt freshman Chasz Wright, Palmer and Sorrell. Palmer took one rep at right tackle during his time at Lackawanna College and that was in a spring game so he’s certainly not comfortable there. Sterling Jenkins, while big at 6-8, 321 lbs., looks like a tackle, but still is a ways away from being able to contribute. Unless there would be injuries I’d be very surprised if he is called on to play this season.

2) Tight end depth

Why it’s a problem: Gone is Jesse James and back is redshirt sophomore Adam Breneman. Well, sort of. Breneman did take some live reps this spring, but he is not back to full strength after rehabbing a knee injury that sidelined him last season. Breneman will be fine by the time camp opens in August, but right now the staff is easing him back in and monitoring his progress.

Penn State tight end Kyle Carter (87) is tackled by Illinois defensive back Earnest Thomas in a 2013 game. (John Beale / AP)

Brent Wilkerson also has been limited this spring and while he’s an older player he doesn’t have the game experience. Mike Gesicki is improving as a blocker and should look much more comfortable in his second year with the team.

Advertise with us

How to fix it: Get Breneman healthy and continue to work on making these guys better blockers. It’s the last go around for senior Kyle Carter who was a non-factor for much of last season, but as he showed early in his career he can be a large part of the offense. If Breneman, Carter, Gesicki and Wilkerson are all healthy this should be a really interesting group to watch this Fall. Jonathan Holland enrolls this summer and he will play tight end though he could move to defensive end in the future if needed.

3) Running back depth

Why it’s a problem: Behind starter Akeel Lynch it’s anyone’s guess. A trio of redshirt freshmen are vying to be his backup, but one of them, Johnathan Thomas, has been limited this spring. If something would happen to Lynch this could be a mess. It’s no surprise Franklin has questions about the depth here.

Akeel Lynch (22) runs for a touchdown during the third quarter against Temple in 2014. (Gene J. Puskar / AP)

How to fix it: Mark Allen, Nick Scott and Johnathan Thomas are going through their first year of spring drills and Allen has left a favorable impression. At 5-7, 186 lbs. Allen brings a different dimension to the backfield, but how quickly all three of the redshirt freshmen can continue progressing will be key because if not competition is on the way. The three have the upper hand for now, but this group will be much deeper this summer.

Four-star signees Andre Robinson and Saquon Barkley arrive in late June and both put together high school careers that made them two of the biggest gets in the 2015 class. How quickly they can pick up the offense, particularly pass protection, will go a long way in determining what the depth chart looks like by the time September rolls around.

Advertise with us

4) Punting woes

Why it’s a problem: James Franklin’s evaluation of the punters and snappers certainly wasn’t glowing. You can read more about it here from Sunday’s Post-Gazette story, but with no scholarships invested at kicker or punter no relief is on the way.

“There are still concerns and questions about our punting. It’s not where I think it needs to be,” Franklin said on Saturday. “I think our snapping and our punting from the time the season ended to now hasn’t progressed the way I think it should progress. We’ve got to look at what we’re doing there and make some changes.”

Sophomore Daniel Pasquariello and redshirt freshman Robby Liebel are the front runners with a few other players who can kick and punt also in the competition. Chris Gulla’s kicker turned punter experiment ended at the end of last season when he started focusing on kicking, the position he was most comfortable with before walking on with Bill O’Brien’s staff and being asked to take on punting.

How to fix it: Special teams coordinator Charles Huff has his work cut out for him again this year. When Penn State brought Pasquariello, an Australian born punter, to campus early last summer Penn State was in a bind at the position, but they also saw something they liked.

Advertise with us

It’s a matter of finding the most consistent option and Franklin even added a kicking and punting competition to the spring game this year to see how his specialists will do in front of a crowd. This position battle, much like it was last season, could extend into the season unless Pasquariello, Liebel or anyone else settles it. Fans will want to stay in their seats during halftime of Saturday’s Blue-White Game as the punters take the field.

Audrey Snyder: asnyder@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @audsnyder4