WASHINGTON — The Penguins’ resounding rout in the season opener was barely a week ago. It feels far more distant.
Since beating the Philadelphia Flyers 7-0 and taking a 5-1 lead over the Montreal Canadiens in the home opener Saturday, the Penguins have devolved into a disheveled mess.
They blew that big lead before recovering to beat the Canadiens in overtime, gave up three third-period goals in a loss to the Winnipeg Jets and handed the Washington Capitals multiple goals with ugly turnovers in another defeat Wednesday.
Consecutive losses in the early stages of an 84-game season are hardly a cause for alarm. But amid the struggles, one of the Penguins’ greatest strengths is starting to look like a weakness.
Pittsburgh’s forward depth is real.
It led Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas to trade Filip Hallander to the Edmonton Oilers on Wednesday.
Read More
It led Elmer Soderblom to sit in the press box for the past three games despite a strong training camp and season opener.
It led Penguins coach Dan Muse to scratch Ville Koivunen after a dazzling goal to start the year.
“I can’t really think of a harder conversation that I’ve had to have, in recent memory at least,” Muse said Tuesday. “ ... [Koivunen has] done the things that were asked of him and he’s producing on the ice.”
But while Muse maintained the forward depth is a “good problem,” it hasn’t looked like that. He spent the past two games shuffling the forward lines to little effect. Frustration is setting in for the odd men out, even as they say the right things.
“Of course it’s tough,” Soderblom said Tuesday. “It’s not fun to be out of the lineup, but just gotta keep working hard and be ready and focus on what I can control.”
And it’s not hard to imagine those feelings being even stronger across the state in Wilkes-Barre, where the Penguins have multiple promising forwards who have little paths to NHL playing time. That could have negative implications for the future of the franchise.
And there’s still more pain to come. The Hallander trade didn’t fix the Penguins’ numbers crunch. Because they brought in defenseman Spencer Stastney, they’ll have to open up another roster spot once Andrei Kuzmenko returns from the non-roster list, which could happen Saturday.
Of course, another injury could solve that problem for them. And either of the two depth defensemen, Stastney or Ilya Solovyov, could be waived to make room for Kuzmenko.
But regardless, Muse still has to sort out the complicated forward picture.
He started the season with a top line of Nick Robertson, Sidney Crosby and Rickard Rakell. Robertson was on the fourth line Wednesday.
Hendrix Lapierre got a shot on the top line against the Capitals. It didn’t go well, and Muse eventually slid Bryan Rust back to his traditional spot.
Though Ben Kindel has been one of the Penguins’ best players, the third line has been a revolving door. While Connor Dewar and Blake Lizotte have played on the fourth line in each game, they’ve been joined by Soderblom, Hallander, Lapierre, Robertson or even Kindel.
The only consistent line has also been the best — Egor Chinakhov, Tommy Novak and Evgeni Malkin. It’s no coincidence they’re the only trio to carry over from last season.
Pittsburgh’s forwards need some time to develop chemistry. Robertson probably deserves a longer look on the top line. He’s scored three times in four games.
Putting Soderblom back with Dewar and Lizotte would give the Penguins a physical fourth line with some scoring acumen like they had last season.
Kindel and Rust clearly connect well. Koivunen, Kuzmenko or Lapierre could work alongside them to round out the third line.
But regardless of what Muse chooses, letting the same lines play together for two or three games — even if it means a talented player takes a seat for a while — might help heal the turnover bug that has plagued the Penguins.
It’s not just shuffled lines, though. If they decide to keep eight defensemen, the Penguins could end up putting Koivunen, Soderblom or Lapierre on waivers. None of them are a lock to clear.
Koivunen has played well this season, with two points in three games and a team-high plus-5 rating. The main thing scaring other teams off would be his $32 million contract. His playmaking and two-way potential might be tantalizing enough for someone to take the risk anyway.
Lapierre is a 24-year-old former first-round pick who’s shown some positive signs this season.
Soderblom’s 6-foot-8 frame and puck protection make him a unique weapon.
They could help a lot of teams. Losing any of those three for nothing would be bad business.
Then there’s the opportunity question. Rutger McGroarty is back in the AHL. So is Avery Hayes. Both look ready for the NHL, even if they didn’t have eye-popping training camps. But they’re exempt from waivers and stuck behind several forwards who aren’t.
And if performances like Hallander and Koivunen had in the season opener can’t earn them a consistent opportunity, that could send a discouraging message to the rest of the Penguins’ depth pieces and prospects fighting for a spot.
“It’s always going to be frustrating,” Hallander said of being scratched before the trade. “ ... Every time you play good, you want to be in. It’s a tough situation with a lot of people. So obviously you’ve just got to do your part, and then it’s not up to you all the time.”
Competition is healthy. But the Penguins’ forward logjam already forced them to give up on a useful player. It seems to be destabilizing the lines.
Pittsburgh’s lineup looked deep and dangerous in Philadelphia. Perhaps they’ll rediscover that form again soon. But at the moment, the glut of forwards isn’t looking like such a “good problem.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.