For the eighth straight season, the Penguins failed to win a playoff series.
Their regular season surpassed all reasonable expectations. Pittsburgh was projected to be one of the worst teams in the NHL but finished second in the Metropolitan Division thanks to a magical combination of career years, bounceback seasons and a new coaching voice.
The magic ran out in the postseason, as the Philadelphia Flyers eliminated the Penguins in six games Wednesday.
“From start to finish, just going back to training camp, what the outside expectations are were never what the inside expectations were,” coach Dan Muse said. “All I really cared about was what this group thought and how they believed in themselves. How, when things got hard, they found a way to keep pushing and just dig in. I’m proud of each guy on this team and everything we worked to accomplish this year.”
The Penguins were supposed to plunge further into a rebuild this season, trading away veterans to acquire more young talent and draft assets. Instead, the aging core raged against the dying of the light.
They proved they could still power a winning team, at least in the regular season. But the swift playoff exit has left the Penguins with more questions than answers entering a critical offseason.
Read More
Here are some of the biggest:
Will Malkin return?
Evgeni Malkin’s contract situation was one of the subplots of the season. He spoke publicly several times about how he wanted to play another year in Pittsburgh.
The 39-year-old Russian forward made clear that he was waiting on Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas to extend that invitation. Dubas played coy on his plans for Malkin when asked after the trade deadline.
Before the season, not resigning Malkin might have been easier for Penguins fans to swallow. His play was slipping. His skating showed his age.
But in his 20th season in Pittsburgh, Malkin was one of the team’s best offensive players. He scored 61 points in 56 games with one of the top on-ice goal differentials on the team. He wasn’t as dynamic in the playoffs but still found the back of the net twice.
Still, he missed many games due to injuries and was suspended for five games at a critical juncture of the season after slashing Buffalo’s Rasmus Dahlin in the head.
The Penguins’ team speed and physicality looked woefully inadequate as they fell behind 3-0 to the Flyers. That could offer Dubas the cover to move on from Malkin.
But that would risk angering Sidney Crosby, particularly since Malkin proved he can still be a helpful player — at least for now.
What about Letang?
The other member of the Big Three, Kris Letang, looked further from his prime this season.
The 39-year-old had the second-highest ice time per game on the team and put up 34 points in 74 games. But he was on the ice for more even-strength goals against than any other Pittsburgh player.
Letang gave away far too many costly turnovers and no longer provided the offensive dynamism to make up for it. Though he rebounded later in the series, Letang was on the ice for five of the Flyers’ first six playoff goals.
But there’s not much the Penguins can do about it. Letang is signed for two more years at a $6.1 million cap hit. Thanks to the 35-plus contract rule, they wouldn’t get any cap savings from buying him out.
Letang’s deal carries a no-movement clause. Beginning next season, he’ll have a 10-team approved trade list — but other teams are unlikely to covet him given his expensive contract and declining play.
He is far from Dubas’ only problem on the blue line.
Ryan Graves and his $4.5 million cap hit are on the books for three more seasons. After arriving in a February trade, Sam Girard was a liability at times and is signed for another season. And one of the team’s best defensemen this season, Ryan Shea, is an unrestricted free agent.
The good news is Pittsburgh has both members of its top defensive pairing — Erik Karlsson and Parker Wotherspoon — under contract for next season. Prospect Harrison Brunicke could be NHL-ready next year. The Penguins will have coveted NCAA free-agent signee Jake Livanavage, as well.
If they can resign Shea and get Girard back to his Colorado level, the Penguins’ blue line could be better next season. But it has a long way to go.
Who are free agents?
The Penguins have nearly $46 million of projected cap space to work with this summer. They could end up spending a lot of it on players from this season’s team. In addition to Shea and Malkin, a number of the Penguins’ key contributors are set to hit free agency.
Leading goal-scorer Anthony Mantha will be an unrestricted free agent. Noel Acciari and Connor Dewar, two-thirds of Pittsburgh’s excellent fourth line, will be unrestricted free agents. Ditto for Connor Clifton, a regular member of the lineup in the second half of the season.
And then there are goalies Stuart Skinner and Arturs Silovs, neither of whom is signed for next season. We’ll get to them in the next question.
Meanwhile, winger Egor Chinakhov, who scored 18 goals in 43 games as a Penguin, will hit restricted free agency. The two sides will need to settle on the right price for him.
It’s a relatively weak free agent market, so Dubas will probably face stiff competition to both retain his own players and sign new ones.
Who are the goalies?
After largely playing well since arriving in a mid-December trade, Skinner will likely receive interest in free agency this summer. Silovs, who led the Penguins with 38 starts this season and excelled in the playoffs — particularly in a 31-save Game 6 showing — is a restricted free agent.
The only Pittsburgh goalie with NHL experience who is under contract next season is Sergei Murashov. After starring in the American Hockey League this season, the 22-year-old appears likely to at least be part of the Penguins’ goalie rotation next fall.
Joel Blomqvist, a restricted free agent, had a strong season with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton, as well, and could be back in the mix for an NHL role.
The Penguins’ goaltending wasn’t a strength this season, but it wasn’t a weakness, either. It could certainly be better next year if Murashov translates his minor league success to the NHL and Pittsburgh identifies a solid second option. Silovs stated a strong case with his play this past week.
But those are not guaranteed. Penguins goalies will once again be among the most pressing offseason questions for Dubas and the front office.
Ready to take a leap?
For all the progress the Penguins made this season, it wasn’t a great year for some of their top prospects.
At the end of last season, Ville Koivunen and Rutger McGroarty looked poised for everyday NHL roles. But Koivunen had seven points in 39 games and a minus-10 rating. McGroarty’s season was hampered by injuries, and he put up just six points in 24 NHL games. Both are back in the AHL.
Brunicke made the NHL roster out of training camp but was eventually sent back to juniors. Fellow blueliner Owen Pickering played poorly in four NHL appearances before spending the rest of the season in Wilkes-Barre.
There were plenty of positives. Avery Hayes continued to light up the AHL and scored five goals in 16 NHL games. Bill Zonnon and Will Horcoff, two of their three 2025 first-round picks, had big seasons in the QMJHL and NCAA, respectively.
And, of course, the Penguins’ other first-rounder last year, Ben Kindel, played a major role for the NHL club all season.
As the Flyers took control of the series, they exposed the flaws in the Penguins’ aging roster. They need some of their young players to reach the NHL next season. How many do and how they look when they get there will go a long way toward determining whether Pittsburgh can match or exceed this year’s success.
Will they make a splash?
The Penguins have 19 picks in the first three rounds of the next four drafts — a significant surplus. They have tons of cap space. While their prospect pool is not elite, it’s vastly improved and has some intriguing pieces.
Dubas could cobble together a compelling trade package to acquire a big name if any are on the market.
Dallas Stars dynamo Jason Robertson will be a restricted free agent. His team’s challenging cap situation could compel them to deal him.
Superstar Auston Matthews’ future with the Toronto Maple Leafs is uncertain. If Matthews truly becomes available, Dubas could pull off the blockbuster of the summer and add a player he’s very familiar with.
There are probably less high-profile moves on the table that could still infuse the Penguins with high-end talent their paltry playoff performance showed they need.
Crosby and Karlsson are still stars, but their window could be closing. This might be the summer for Dubas to make a win-now move. He has the assets to do it.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.