The Penguins will enter the Stanley Cup playoffs as one of the highest-scoring teams in the NHL. Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin appear to be peaking at the perfect time. And they’ve already been installed as the favorite in the first round against the Philadelphia Flyers.

But Pittsburgh still has major questions at the most important position in hockey.

Penguins goalies have absolutely played a major part in snapping the team’s three-season playoff drought and clinching second in the Metropolitan Division. They’ve combined to rank 14th in overall goals saved above expected, per Sportlogiq.

But Pittsburgh locked up home-ice advantage despite recording just four goalie steals this season, according to Sportlogiq — a stat that marks when a goalie’s saves above expected exceeded his team’s winning margin. That was tied with Edmonton and Vegas for the lowest mark in the league.

Advertise with us

Penguins coach Dan Muse has mostly used a game-by-game goalie rotation all season. It began with Tristan Jarry and Arturs Silovs. Sergei Murashov got a few opportunities in November and December. After Jarry was traded to Edmonton for a package including Skinner, the former Oilers goalie stepped in and has been alternating games with Silovs.

“I feel good on both guys,” Muse said Sunday. “Both goalies have been a huge part of why we’re where we’re at.”

But rotating goalies in the postseason would be highly unconventional. Even teams that split time fairly evenly between their netminders in the regular season usually ride one in the playoffs.

ESPN analyst Ray Ferraro believes the Penguins should break the mold.

“I don’t know why they would change anything that they’re doing,” Ferraro recently told the Post-Gazette. “I know it is unorthodox.”

Advertise with us

Ferraro used the 2022-23 Boston Bruins as a cautionary tale. They had rotated Linus Ullmark and Jeremy Swayman for much of the season on their way to an NHL-record 135 points. But Ullmark drew the first six postseason starts.

The Bruins fell to the Florida Panthers in a shocking first-round upset.

“I don’t care that every other team uses one goalie,” Ferraro said. “So what? Good for them … [Skinner and Silovs] seem to work best in a game-on, game-off sort of deal.”

But the evidence in Skinner’s favor is starting to mount.

He’s saved 8.68 goals above expected across his past 10 starts, according to Sportlogiq.

Advertise with us

That includes earning his second steal as a Penguin in a critical shootout victory against Ottawa on March 26, stopping two goals above expected in another game with massive playoff implications against Detroit on March 31 and saving more than a shot above expected in Pittsburgh’s playoff-clinching win over New Jersey on Thursday.

In other words, Skinner showed out in perhaps his three most important starts of the season. That’s not surprising for a goalie who’s been in the past two Stanley Cup Finals, but it's still a positive sign for the playoffs.

Meanwhile, Silovs has saved 3.26 goals below expected in his past 10 starts. The Penguins have won six of those, but the 25-year-old Latvian's counting stats in that stretch aren’t much better.

His .853 save percentage since March 5 is sixth worst in the league, entering Monday’s action. He’s allowed an average of 3.84 goals per game over that span. Silovs has not stolen a game this season.

Skinner’s numbers in the past 10 games won’t blow anyone away: 4-4-2 record, .886 save percentage, 3.36 goals-against average. But the advanced stats show he has frequently faced opposing onslaughts and has held up his end of the bargain.

Advertise with us

Another number that could be particularly important in chaotic playoff hockey: Skinner’s inner slot save percentage with the Penguins is .811, good for 18th in the league through Sunday (Sportlogiq). Silovs’ is .764, placing him 52nd.

Skinner is denying more Grade-A chances from right in front of the net — something Pittsburgh will need in the postseason.

Penguins skaters consistently praise both goalies. But this quote from defenseman Ryan Shea about Skinner stood out.

“He’s just super calm, and he’s a great guy. He’s honestly one of the best guys I’ve played with…,” Shea said after the win against the Red Wings. “Obviously, in Edmonton, when you get kind of dragged through the mud like he did, and he comes here, you could just see his smile kind of rejuvenate.

“We’re playing our hearts out in front of both our goaltenders, and hopefully, they can feel it when they’re in the crease."

Advertise with us

The Penguins’ effort is almost never the question. That doesn’t mean they’ve always made life easy on their goaltenders.

Pittsburgh ranks 18th in expected goals against, per Sportlogiq.

They allow among the most rush and forecheck opportunities in the league. They surrender the 22nd-most high-danger scoring chances.

Those frequent “loud” looks, to use one of Muse’s favorite terms, left some wondering if the Penguins should bring up Murashov — who seems to have greater upside than Silovs and Skinner from a talent perspective.

In limited NHL action, Murashov registered a higher save percentage and lower goals-against average than his more experienced counterparts, though the advanced numbers weren’t as rosy. The 22-year-old has dominated American Hockey League competition this season, compiling a 23-8-4 record with a 2.24 goals-against average and .918 save percentage.

Advertise with us

But it would be wise to give Murashov some AHL playoff experience before throwing him into the NHL fire. After a fantastic season with the Wheeling Nailers of the ECHL last year, he struggled in the postseason at that level. Further playoff seasoning will allow him to develop into the Penguins’ goalie of the future.

It certainly helped Silovs, who was named Calder Cup MVP after leading the Abbotsford Canucks to an AHL title last season. He also played well when pressed into action for Vancouver in the 2024 Stanley Cup playoffs, helping the Canucks eliminate Nashville in the first round and take the Oilers to Game 7.

Murashov is capable of delivering a moment like that if given the opportunity. But the Penguins don’t need him to. With 50 career NHL playoff starts, Skinner looks ready to claim the postseason net.

He is Pittsburgh’s best goalie, at least for now. He should start Game 1 of the first round and probably most of the games after.

But if Muse decides to continue the rotation, it will be hard to blame him. That’s what has carried the Penguins to their first playoff berth since 2022.

Advertise with us

Ferraro used a quote from Vegas Golden Knights general manager Kelly McCrimmon to explain why he would roll with both Skinner and Silovs.

“He said, ‘Look, every team runs their own race,’ ” Ferraro said. “And I thought that is one of the best lines that every manager should think about. I don’t care what the other team is doing. This is my team. This is the race we’re running.”