RALEIGH, N.C. — Erik Karlsson set the trap at the point.

The Penguins’ defenseman sucked in Sebastian Aho by pulling the puck toward the boards. Once Aho lunged to steal it, Karlsson whipped the puck around the Carolina Hurricanes’ center and went right by him. He drove into the high slot and fired in his second goal of the game.

It was just the latest example that Karlsson is truly back.

“Karl’s got a swagger about him right now that is good,” Bryan Rust said. “Anytime you get a player with that much skill and who can do that many amazing things with the puck, when he has that swagger and has that confidence, you see him be able to make plays that most other players can’t make.”

Advertise with us

Karlsson’s nasty move tied Wednesday’s game, which the Penguins lost in overtime, with just over five minutes left. It was his second equalizer of the third period. And just before Karlsson snatched Aho’s ankles, he saved possession at the blue line with his skate while falling.

Karlsson is the highest-scoring defenseman in the NHL since the Olympic break, with 17 points in 12 games. He put up 10 points in Pittsburgh’s five-game road trip, all against playoff teams.

This is the player the Penguins thought they were trading for in August 2023.

All season, Karlsson has been excellent, playing much closer to his three-time Norris Trophy form than he displayed in his first two seasons in Pittsburgh. He’s taken it to another level recently.

“When things are tight, who’s going to be able to create that momentum shift or create that play? Erik’s done that throughout the year,” Penguins coach Dan Muse said.

Advertise with us

With Sidney Crosby missing the first 11 games after the Olympic break and Evgeni Malkin serving a five-game suspension in that stretch, as well, Pittsburgh needed someone to step up and carry the offense.

Karlsson understood the assignment. He rode the momentum from his largely solid Olympic performance with Sweden into his best hockey of the season in March. He probably deserves the most credit for the Penguins remaining in second place in the Metropolitan Division.

For the season, Pittsburgh has outscored opponents, 70-52, in Karlsson’s even-strength minutes. That differential ranks second on the team behind only Ryan Shea, despite Karlsson often facing the opponent’s toughest matchups.

Since the Olympic break, the Penguins’ goal differential with Karlsson on the ice has been 17-9.

He’s up to 52 points in 63 games this season, five points away from surpassing his previous high with Pittsburgh. His 43 assists lead the team, and many of them have been spectacular.

Advertise with us

In Monday’s rout of the league-leading Colorado Avalanche, Karlsson launched a perfect stretch pass from the goalline to Anthony Mantha nearly at the opposite blue line. Mantha’s breakaway goal gave the Penguins a first-period lead they wouldn’t relinquish.

Karlsson is clearly enjoying himself this season, as well. He shoved a shaving cream pie in Rust’s face after the Penguins’ win in Utah on Saturday.

When ESPN’s Erik Johnson asked him on Monday’s broadcast about what goes into his head when he sees Nathan MacKinnon coming at him, Karlsson flashed a mischievous smile and said, “Oh [expletive], here we go,” followed by a hearty laugh.

That doesn’t mean he is not competitive. Wednesday, after the Penguins’ 16th loss after regulation, Karlsson was visibly frustrated and grumbled about their continued struggles there.

“We have a good enough team in here to be better at them, but they haven’t been on our fortune this year,” Karlsson said. “That’s the way it is sometimes. I don’t think that there’s a particular reason for it. It’s very unfortunate. It sucks losing that way.”

Advertise with us

Karlsson was a huge reason they were in a position to even pick up a point against the Hurricanes. He’s a huge reason the Penguins are in position for their first postseason berth of his Pittsburgh tenure.

His reemergence as one of the most dangerous defensemen in the league gives the Penguins a far better chance of advancing should they hang onto a playoff spot.

Meanwhile, the other legendary defenseman on the Penguins’ roster is not having such a sterling season. Karlsson’s brilliance stands in stark contrast to Kris Letang’s continued struggles.

The Penguins have a minus-8 goal differential in Letang’s even-strength minutes since the Olympic break, the worst mark on the team. That matches the eye test. Letang is committing killer turnovers and giving up far too many good looks in front of the net.

He was playing some of his best hockey of the season before missing the last few pre-Olympic games with a broken foot. Letang has not been the same since.

Advertise with us

It’s probably not a coincidence his worst stretch of the year came after the partner he played best next to, Brett Kulak, was traded away to Colorado. Letang and the defenseman acquired in that trade, Sam Girard, were a terrible mix. Things haven’t looked much better next to Shea.

The Penguins’ expected goals percentage with Letang on the ice since the Olympic break is 34.3, per Natural Stat Trick. He snapped out of a similarly poor stretch earlier this season. The Penguins need him to do so again to survive an ultra-tight playoff race.