Avery Hayes signed an AHL deal with the Penguins in part because he saw a “depleted prospect pool.”

“I thought I could be one of their younger guys right away,” he said in April.

He wasn’t wrong. But even as the Penguins have stockpiled young talent since Hayes joined the organization in June 2023, the undrafted winger has just kept climbing.

And he’s now one of the franchise’s most promising prospects — particularly if his incredible week is any indication.

Advertise with us

The 23-year-old was thrust into his NHL debut on short notice Thursday in Buffalo after Rickard Rakell, Blake Lizotte and Noel Acciari all suddenly became unavailable.

Hayes, coming off a one-goal performance in a win with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton the previous night, drove four-and-a-half hours from eastern Pennsylvania to western New York with the American Hockey League club’s manager of team operations, Derek Avery.

It says a lot about his nerves — or the lack thereof — that he was able to sleep for much of the ride.

“I didn’t really have much time to think about the game, which honestly was pretty nice,” Hayes told reporters in Buffalo. “It wasn’t too stressful.”

But as his team sleepwalked through part of the first period in Buffalo, Hayes was wide awake. He flew past a Sabres defender to collect a loose puck and then beat Alex Lyon with a snappy wrister for his first NHL goal on his first NHL shot to tie the score.

Advertise with us

Hayes gave his team a lead going into the first intermission with a rifle of a one-timer that snuck just over Lyon’s glove and into the top corner of the net.

How did it feel to become the fourth NHL player since 1917 to score multiple goals in the first period of his debut?

“Honestly, I blacked out a bit, but it was a ton of fun, and it was a great win for the team,” he said.

Apparently, that blackout extended through the weekend because Hayes followed up his dazzling debut with another unbelievable AHL outing.

He registered a hat trick — including an overtime winner so heavy it broke his stick — in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton’s victory over Hershey on Saturday.

Advertise with us

That put the Westland, Mich., native at a team-leading 16 goals in 32 games with the Baby Penguins. Hayes finished tied for the team high with 23 goals in 60 games last season.

It’s hard to imagine how the former Ontario Hockey League standout made it through three NHL Drafts without being selected.

He’s fast, even compared to NHL competition. He’s scrappy and wins puck battles. He obviously has a dangerous shot. He’s undersized — 5 feet 10, 180 pounds — but hardly plays like it.

Hayes resembles another right winger from Michigan who’s done all right for the Penguins despite his size: Bryan Rust.

Of course, Hayes has a long way to go before he can truly earn that comparison. At his age, Rust was a key part of the Penguins’ 2016 Stanley Cup squad. The veteran came with higher pedigree, too, as a 2010 third-round pick.

Advertise with us

But Hayes is clearly more than an AHL star. He looked at home playing against one of the hottest teams in the NHL. He and his close friend Rutger McGroarty formed a pesky line with Kevin Hayes that dominated the Sabres in its limited ice time (97.7% of the expected goals, per Natural Stat Trick).

Both Hayes and McGroarty were sent back down to play with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton over the Olympic break. Their path to consistent playing time with the Penguins this season is still not clear, as good as they looked Thursday (and in McGroarty’s case, over his four-game stint before the break).

Dan Muse’s 12-man forward lineup is fairly set. The fourth line would appear untouchable. Same for the top six. Anthony Mantha (42 points), Ben Kindel (six goals in the past six games) and Justin Brazeau (15 goals) probably aren’t going anywhere, either.

But when injuries inevitably arise or a player struggles through several games, Hayes and McGroarty are waiting in the wings, ready to bring their hard-nosed 200-foot games to NHL ice. And they’re both a big part of the Penguins’ increasingly bright future.

“Obviously, now we have great prospects. It’s awesome to see how far it’s come in just one year,” Hayes said in April.

Advertise with us

And he’s certainly one of them.

Around the world of Penguins prospects

• It’s safe to say Avery Hayes made a strong impression on Kyle Dubas and the Penguins’ front office. They picked his brother, Travis, in the fourth round of the 2025 NHL Draft. The 18-year-old forward has 12 goals and 18 assists in 46 games for the Soo Greyhounds of the OHL.

• It was a week of debuts for the Penguins franchise. Tanner Howe played his first pro game Feb. 1. He recorded an assist in his debut with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton and scored a goal in his second AHL contest.

Melvin Fernstrom has made quite the impact in his first two games with the Baby Penguins since coming over from the Swedish Hockey League. He had two assists in his debut Friday. The 19-year-old added a goal Saturday.

After a difficult season in Sweden, the change of scenery has been good for the 2024 third-round pick, who came to the Penguins in a trade with Vancouver last February.

Advertise with us

• Matt Dumba can’t really be called a prospect, though the 31-year-old defenseman has been with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton since December. That hasn’t always been a happy marriage — Dumba has seemed to not particularly care for playing in the minors at times — but he’s turned it on recently.

He earned AHL player of the week honors after six points in two games Jan. 31 and Feb. 1, including a goal that he dedicated to a young cancer patient he met before the game. He added six more points last week, registering the Baby Penguins’ first hat trick of the weekend Friday.

 
 
 
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by AHL (@theahl)

The right-shot defenseman plays a position of need for the Penguins, particularly if Kris Letang’s recovery drags beyond the initial four-week timeline. Despite his pricey contract, he could also be an enticing trade chip for Dubas at the deadline.

It’s in the best interest of both Dumba and the Penguins for him to continue this AHL surge.

• Tristan Broz returned from injury after missing nearly three weeks for Wilkes-Barre/Scranton. The center had two assists Friday and continues to provide an option for the Penguins if they need help up the middle.

Advertise with us

• After a slow start in his return to the AHL, Ville Koivunen is back to racking up points with the Baby Penguins. He had one goal and five assists in two games last weekend, bringing the 22-year-old to 11 points in the past seven contests.

The organization’s forward depth is a real asset.