For the third straight spring, the Stanley Cup playoffs will take place without the Penguins. They ended their season Thursday with their worst record since 2005-06.

As their offseason begins, the Penguins must mull the same existential questions they had in previous summers. Will their star players and head coach return next season? And if they do, is it still possible to put the right pieces around them and win?

Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas, now entering his third year, has already tipped his hand on some of this with both words and his recent actions. But at a high level, there is still much uncertainty about the length of this rebuild.

Here are nine questions that will define the offseason for Dubas and the Penguins:

Advertise with us

Will the Big Three be back?

Sidney Crosby spoke this week about the emotional cost of losing, which includes watching good friends and longtime teammates be traded. But by all accounts, his commitment to Pittsburgh has not wavered despite another year with no playoffs.

Will that change during a long summer with too much time to reflect? Perhaps it’s possible. But for two decades, the captain’s loyalty to the team, this city and teammates Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang has been limitless. So plan on him sticking around.

Speaking of those two others, Malkin has one year left on his contract and has stated he wants to finish it out here. Letang has not made such declarations, and this week he didn’t get an opportunity to speak on the record about his desires because of a heart procedure. So there is some murkiness there, but actions speak louder than words.

As for the Penguins’ side of things, Dubas publicly said before that he wouldn’t ask any of the Big Three to waive their no-trade clauses. To this point, honoring those NTCs has been meaningful to Fenway Sports Group, and that seems unlikely to change.

What about the head coach?

Dubas and Fenway Sports Group stood by Sullivan when the Penguins had an ugly stretch early in the season. The team was still competitive then, at least in theory. Sullivan steered them back into the playoff race for a while this winter, then Dubas started to dismantle the NHL roster. By March 7, the coach had little to work with.

Advertise with us

Where does that leave things with Sullivan now? FSG is obviously quite fond of the Cup-winning coach. And the praise that Dubas has given Sullivan publicly has not just been lip service. So it seems that Sullivan will be back for his 11th season here.

That could change if Dubas and Sullivan are not in alignment about the road ahead for the franchise. But Sullivan has said in media interviews that he wants to remain in Pittsburgh, continue to coach the Big Three and work with incoming prospects.

So it’s still the status quo, eh?

No, there might not be any seismic moves. But there should be significant changes.

Pittsburgh hung onto Erik Karlsson and Rickard Rakell at the NHL trade deadline, but that doesn’t mean they are untouchable going forward. In particular, Karlsson is an overpaid veteran player whom the Penguins should be eager to move if there is interest in him. There figures to be a taker or two, especially if salary is retained.

Bryan Rust’s no-trade clause will disappear this summer, which means Dubas can deal him anywhere if he wants. Obviously, Cup hopefuls would be keen on acquiring Rust. But the Penguins would need to be blown away to trade the homegrown forward.

Advertise with us

And then there’s the much-maligned Tristan Jarry and Ryan Graves, who have fallen well short of expectations since being part of Dubas’ signing spree a month into the job. Graves definitely has negative trade value, and Jarry probably still does, too. So to get their contracts off the books, it will likely take a salary-dump trade or a buyout.

Dubas’ eagerness to dump one or both depends on his target date for contention.

Will they try to upgrade in net?

This, too, may hinge on whether they aim to get back to the playoffs in 2025-26 or if the following year is the target. (More on that in a minute.) But we hear you. The biggest problem among the many ones the Penguins had this season was goaltending.

Jarry didn’t get his act together until it was far too late. Alex Nedeljkovic is miscast in a starting role. And Joel Blomqvist was a flop in his extended look this winter.

The Penguins are hopeful that Blomqvist or fellow prospect Sergei Murashov will eventually develop into a No. 1. However, they cannot bank on that for next season.

Advertise with us

So will they bring in a new veteran? Quite possibly. But it may not be a sure thing.

When will Dubas hit the gas?

Great question! Alas, we have no answer for you. Dubas has been mum on this one.

Truthfully, it’s conceivable that Dubas has yet to even make that determination at this point and could even head into the 2025 offseason with an open mind and wait to see which opportunities present themselves in the draft, trades and free agency.

One thing we do know is Dubas doesn’t want to take shortcuts to try to get Crosby and the veteran core simply back into the playoffs. Yes, he knows the clock may be ticking when it comes to showing Crosby proof of concept. But we’re not there yet.

What if they do seek a splash?

The Penguins will enter the offseason with approximately $24 million in salary cap space, per PuckPedia. Only 11 teams are projected to have more money to spend.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh also has 30 draft picks in the next three years to help facilitate trades.

The blue line must be a priority given the Penguins’ inability to defend this season. The top lefties set to hit unrestricted free agency will be Vladislav Gavrikov and Ivan Provorov. The Penguins don’t need to spend on a righty unless Letang or Karlsson gets moved. The best option on that side of the blue line is Aaron Ekblad.

It’s not a great year for goalies. Jake Allen is viewed as the top free-agent keeper.

There are several high-end forwards on expiring contracts, including Sam Bennett, John Tavares and Nikolaj Ehlers. But the name you will hear most between now and July 1 is Mitch Marner. Dubas has a relationship with him from his Toronto days.

The Penguins are also a team to watch with offer sheets for restricted free agents, although it would be shocking if they gave up their 2026 first-rounder to ink an RFA.

Advertise with us

Who are their free agents?

Matt Grzelcyk is the most notable one. Matt Nieto and Joona Koppanen will also be unrestricted free agents. Pittsburgh’s restricted free agents include Pierre-Olivier Joseph, Conor Timmins, Connor Dewar, Philip Tomasino and Vasily Ponomarev.

Which prospects make a leap?

We should see a few Penguins prospects get a shot to stick in Pittsburgh in the fall.

The likeliest are Ville Koivunen, Rutger McGroarty and Owen Pickering. All three had moments with the NHL club this season. Ponomarev, Blomqvist and Harrison Brunicke should push for roster spots. And somebody like Tristan Broz could surprise.

What’s their draft outlook?

The Penguins have 10 picks in the NHL draft, including their first-rounder. They could end up with an 11th selection depending on how those lottery balls ping-pong.

They are owed a protected first-round pick via the rival New York Rangers. If the Rangers’ pick this year lands in the top 13, the Rangers will decide whether to send it to the Penguins or give up their unprotected 2026 first-round pick to Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

The draft lottery will be sometime in May. The exact date is unknown. Typical NHL.

The Penguins have a 5% shot at winning it. If they do, Matthew Schaefer, Michael Misa and James Hagens are widely viewed as the top prospects in the 2025 draft.