From The Point is a weekly Penguins column from insider Matt Vensel, powered by North Shore Tavern, Pittsburgh’s home for steak on a stone.
Jake Guentzel traded to the Oilers or Flames? A Marc-Andre Fleury reunion? Ryan Graves shipped out of town in exchange for a signed Ian Moran jersey?
In what has become an annual From The Point tradition, I asked Penguins fans (the ones who are foolish enough to still frequent the site formerly called Twitter) to send me fake trade ideas they think Kyle Dubas and Co. should consider.
I got a bunch, ranging from blockbuster deals to sensible cost-cutting moves, plus that one ridiculous proposal to get rid of Graves. (Give the guy a break!)

Anyway, the point of this exercise is to talk through all of the things the Penguins must consider while they decide how to proceed at the March 8 trade deadline. Pittsburgh figures to be one of the NHL’s most fascinating teams this year.
So, without further ado, let’s get into a few of your Penguins trade proposals.
Read More
TO EDM:
— pens road warrior (@ontopmtwash1) February 1, 2024
Jake Guentzel (50% retained -$3M)
Alex Nedeljkovic (50% retained -$750K)
TO PIT:
Beau Akey
Mattias Janmark
Ryan McLeod
2024 1st Round Pick
Oilers swing big after the Lindholm to Vancouver trade.
Let’s start with the big, burning deadline question: Will Guentzel get traded?
Nobody asked me, but I think the Penguins should keep Guentzel. Will they? I will share my read on that later in this column. But for the purposes of this piece, let’s say they are ready to rebuild. Would this be a good haul for Guentzel?
I actually think they might be able to shake another future asset loose from the Oilers, especially because they are getting Alex Nedeljkovic in this proposed deal, too. But the return is comparable to what Calgary just got for Elias Lindholm, who is not as good at Guentzel but plays center — a more premium position.
That first-rounder is a must, and Beau Akey is one of Edmonton’s top prospects, a fast and skilled right-shot defenseman who is a few years from the NHL. Ryan McLeod and Mattias Janmark don’t do much for the rebuild, but whatever.
So, not bad. But I would be surprised if Dubas pivoted into a long-term rebuild right now, with Sidney Crosby still a top-10 NHL player. If he does sell Guentzel for futures in an attempt to retool around Crosby, it would make more sense to target prospects and young NHLers who are ready to contribute in 2024-25.
Sean Monahan (CAL) for 2024 2nd. Improved center center depth, net front presence to improve horrible PP
— Jer???? (@Swaggadactyl) January 31, 2024
Arthur Kaliyev (LAK) for Harkins or DOC and a pick? Not sure what his value is but he’s a young, disgruntled prospect that could address lack of scoring
The Penguins would really need to pick up their play over these next few weeks to justify buying before the deadline. And even if that does happen, their options will be limited due to a lack of salary cap space and future assets with appeal.
That said, if Dubas does that sort of swap, this one makes sense on paper.
Monahan, who has had a bounce-back season in Montreal, has a cap hit just under $2 million. That is a salary the Penguins could add without trouble, and this cost is palatable. And while he’s an imperfect player, he could provide needed offensive ability to their bottom six and maybe boost the power play.
(Last One) Unrealistic pipedream:
— Kaeser (@colingtonyinzer) January 31, 2024
To Minnesota:
Tristan Jarry
To Pittsburgh:
Marc-Andre Fleury
2026 3rd Rounder
Both with NMC's, Dump Jarry's Contract, let Fleury finish where he belongs (hopefully talk him into one more season).
As much as the writer in me would endorse this storybook ending — and Fleury might, too — I don’t see this one happening. For starters, why would Minnesota do this? They aren’t making the playoffs this season, and Jesper Wallstedt, one of the top goalie prospects in hockey, is knocking on the door of the NHL.
If you want to hold out hope that Fleury will sign back here this summer, that’s fine. But, yes, it is a pipe dream right now with Nedeljkovic doing his job well.
Nedjelkovic to Leafs for Nick Robertson
— Matt B (@talisker66) January 31, 2024
Interestingly, multiple people sent me the exact same offer. And I definitely think that Nick Robertson, the brother of Dallas star Jason and a second-round pick for Toronto under Dubas, is a youngster Penguins fans should keep tabs on.
The skilled but smallish winger has averaged a point per game in the American Hockey League, but his scoring success hasn’t translated to the NHL level.
To get Robertson or make a similar bet on Kings winger Arthur Kaliyev, it would probably take more than Nedeljkovic. The Penguins might also have to include Pierre-Olivier Joseph — another young player who might benefit from a change of scenery — or their 2025 third-round pick. Even so, I think I would do that.
I’m willing to bet Reilly smith goes for just cap space purposes, given that DOC may be developing into a solid 2nd line LW
— The Hockey Educator (@hockeyboiii1) January 31, 2024
Our last trade is one the Penguins could do if they continue to tread water.
Acquiring Smith made sense last summer, but it has not panned out as hoped. So if Dubas decides to sell, he can likely recoup a draft pick by dealing Smith.
Rickard Rakell and Marcus Pettersson also fall into the category of players with term who could be shopped to clear cap space and/or acquire future assets.
POINT SHOTS
• I don’t know what — if anything — the Canucks trading for Lindholm says about Guentzel’s availability. It is possible the Penguins told Jim Rutherford that Guentzel is not getting dealt, so Rutherford pivoted to Lindholm. But Vancouver also needed a center, and we know GMJR likes to get his trades done early.
That said, knowing Rutherford and his desire to win again, I suppose it’s not out of the question he tries to get Guentzel, too, if he becomes available. But ...
• I don’t have inside info right now on what the Penguins and Guentzel’s camp are thinking, but my gut is telling me the two sides will figure something out.
Dubas is pot-committed to the current core, and it’s hard to find a Guentzel trade that makes the Penguins better in the next two years. And I don’t think Guentzel will try to break the bank. My sense is he cares more about his connection with the team and the city than with how his contract stacks up with his peers.
• Something that has not been discussed enough with this Guentzel situation is ownership. Fenway Sports Group has full confidence in Dubas and his ability to rebuild the roster when the time is right. But does FSG think that time is now? Based on Tom Werner’s comments in December, it doesn’t appear so.
• One more thought on Guentzel: He should have been an All-Star this season, which brings me to my one big gripe with the showcase game. The best players in the world should all be picked to play. Enough with needing every team to be represented. Most fans want to see stars, not a random Duck or Coyote.
• The Penguins have talked a lot about the importance of just getting points in the standings. But even after picking up points in 15 of the last 20 games, they are only one point closer to a playoff spot. What they need is wins, not the loser points. And to get them, they must be better on the power play and in OT.
• It will be interesting to see who is on the ice at the first practice after the break. Might we see Sam Poulin or Jesse Puljujarvi get the call to Pittsburgh?
THREE STARS
3. Erik Karlsson. I have been critical of the defenseman in recent weeks, but I have to give credit when it is due. He had a 10-game point streak going before he was held off the score sheet in the Jan. 27 overtime win over Montreal.
2. Marcus Pettersson. The stay-at-home Swede surprisingly sniped Canadiens goalie Jake Allen in that win last weekend, scoring his first career OT winner. I jokingly told Pettersson I was putting him atop my Norris ballot for that one.
1. Sidney Crosby. Last Saturday, Crosby headed into the break with a bang by making that jaw-dropping, game-changing pass to Guentzel. That is one of his top 10 passes ever, and he’s been doing this for nearly two decades now.
YOU ASKED...
My frustrated friend Daniel P., via a text message in our group chat: Will the Penguins change anything on their power play if the results don’t improve?
My buddy, Daniel, speaks for many Penguins fans when he wonders if they will make lasting changes to the power play personnel and approach. After all, they have played 46 of their 82 games and are on pace for the worst power play in team history. With a success rate of just 13.1%, they rank 31st in the NHL.
The power play did look better last weekend when Mike Sullivan took Karlsson and Evgeni Malkin off the top unit, but I’m skeptical those changes will stick. He will at least move Malkin back, even if it’s just to keep him mentally engaged.
As for the tactics, we can debate who needs the puck and which player should line up where. But it won’t matter unless they are more urgent and decisive.
STAT N’AT
33 – the difference between the Penguins’ expected goals and actual goals. To translate, the fancy stats say they should be second in scoring. They’re 21st.
FINAL BUZZER
I think Dubas will do something, especially if the Penguins fall out of the playoff race, but don’t be stunned if the trade deadline passes without a major move.
Last season, the writing was on the wall for the Penguins, but Ron Hextall still gave up a high pick to take on Mikael Granlund and his onerous contract. I get it — Hextall was desperate to save his job. But I don’t think Dubas will make the same mistake and throw away future assets if the ship is taking on water.
If the Penguins are a fringe playoff team a few weeks from now, he might make minor tweaks or maybe just stand pat, letting the current club sink or swim.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and @mattvensel on the website X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.