Sidney Crosby and the Penguins had a record of just 11-12-3 on Dec. 11, and at that point they sat six points out of a playoff spot in the Eastern Conference.

Since then, they have picked up at least one point in 15 of their last 20 games.

When they woke up Monday, they were ... still five points out of playoff position.

Yes, even with their improved results the last several weeks, the Penguins have improved to 10th in the East but have hardly inched closer to a postseason spot.

Advertise with us

So what do the Penguins need to change about their team game coming out of the All-Star break to make a meaningful climb up the East standings? Digging through the data, we found nine numbers that must improve down the stretch:

13.1%: The Penguins’ power play success rate — worst in team history

The lack of production from the star-studded power play is the season’s biggest disappointment and is the primary reason why the Penguins have failed to meet expectations, both internal and external. One could pinpoint at least five games in which its impotency cost the Penguins at least one point in the standings.

Even after watching this unit turn down shots, attempt risky passes and usually operate with the urgency of a plastic bag being blown down the street, it’s still stunning to see that the Penguins rank 31st in the league on the power play.

There is enough talent on the roster and experience on the coaching staff that it is possible the Penguins turn it around and produce like a top-10 unit after the break. But if they don’t, it is difficult to picture them accomplishing much. Given their roster construction, the power play must become a difference-maker.

0.72: The gap between Pittsburgh’s expected goals and the actual total

For the second straight season, the Penguins have one of the league’s biggest differences between their total of expected goals and the number of pucks they have actually put in the net. Basically, based on the quantity and the caliber of the chances they have created, they should have 33 more goals this season.

Advertise with us

Their struggles on the power play obviously are a big factor. But their finishing issues extend into 5-on-5 play, as well. As a result, the Penguins rank just 22nd in goals when the underlying numbers say they should be second in the NHL.

6.6: Rush chances against per game given up by Mike Sullivan’s squad

This is always the bellwether stat for the Penguins. When they are playing their best, they make smart decisions with the puck and do not allow many odd-man rushes. When they stray from their structure and attempt risky passes in pursuit of goals, they start to bleed rush chances and hang their goalies out to dry.

The Penguins allow the ninth-most rush chances in the league, per Sportlogiq. They have been a bit better the last two weeks. But there is plenty of room for improvement, and sustained success in this area will go a long way for them.

17: Even-strength points for Evgeni Malkin in the team’s last 32 games

Simply put, the Penguins need far more from Malkin — and he admitted as much the other night. After piling up six goals and 11 points at even strength in their first 14 games, he has just seven and 17 over their last 32. That is not going to cut it for Pittsburgh, which has a clear shortage of scorers in the bottom six.

Perhaps the return of Reilly Smith after the break helps Malkin to get going.

Advertise with us

.748: Pittsburgh’s total save percentage on shots from the inner slot

Overall, Tristan Jarry and Alex Nedeljkovic have mostly been fine. The Penguins as a team rank in the middle of the pack in Sportlogiq’s quality starts stat. But those two have “stolen” them just three wins, which is 22nd out of 32 teams.

The Penguins would benefit from getting another big save or two in every game. Their goalies have combined for a .748 save percentage on shots from the inner slot, per Sportlogiq. Just four teams have a lower mark in that key category.

4-7: The Penguins’ record in games decided in overtime or a shootout

How an NHL team fares in 3-on-3 overtime and the shootout has no translation to how they might perform in the playoffs, when extra time is all 5-on-5 OT. But it can be the difference in whether or not they make them in the first place.

The Penguins have just two wins in games decided in overtime. Their win against the Montreal Canadiens on Saturday snapped a losing streak of five games in overtime. They are at least 2-2 in the shootout, with Sullivan this season opting to use his most successful shooters ahead of his longest-tenured players.

Still, if they were 7-4 instead of 4-7, they might be in a playoff spot right now.

Advertise with us

Their disciplined defense and line changes in Saturday’s victory suggested that they might have finally remembered that these extra points can be essential.

36: Goals scored by the Penguins in the first period, which ranks 27th

In the season’s first two months, only two NHL teams had scored the first goal in a game more often than the Penguins. But since Dec. 1, they have been one of the league’s worst teams during the first period with a minus-9 differential.

They have shown an ability to rally back to salvage points in some games. But they would have more wins if they built early leads and played from ahead.

34: Points for Erik Karlsson, well off his Norris Trophy pace of 2022-23

After he was the first NHL defenseman in three decades to tally 100 points with San Jose, Karlsson was not expected to do it all here. But he can do more.

Some of his advanced stats are sparkling. But others show he has not been as impactful as hoped. He has only 12 rush chances and five shots from the inner slot, per Sportlogiq. He ranks in the 75th percentile in speed bursts over 20 mph, per NHL Edge. He has possessed the puck for just 48 seconds per game.

Advertise with us

Karlsson has looked more assertive in the last few games, making a concerted effort to join the rush or dart in from the point when the Penguins have the puck down low in the offensive zone. Perhaps that is a sign Karlsson is finally starting to understand exactly what Sullivan and the Penguins need from him.

2: Winning streaks of three games in a row or more for the Penguins

Summing all of this up, Pittsburgh’s myriad problems have prevented them from gaining traction as a team and thus climbing the Eastern Conference standings.

They won five games in a row in November to snap out of their early funk. But since then, they have won three in a row just once — in the first week after the Christmas break. Unless the Penguins find a way to reel off a few wins in a row here soon, it will be tough for them to leapfrog some of these other teams.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and @mattvensel on the website X