From The Point is a weekly Penguins column from insider Matt Vensel, powered by North Shore Tavern, Pittsburgh’s home for steak on a stone.
This summer, I flew to Montreal to not just witness, but participate in, one of Kris Letang’s legendary workouts for a story that was published in the Post-Gazette on Aug. 19. That painful experience gave me a greater appreciation of what has made Letang, 36, one of the NHL’s best defensemen in his era.
Afterward, Letang brewed us two espressos and then we talked about his rise to stardom and his hopes for this season and beyond. As our long chat wound down, I asked Letang if he felt he was worthy of the Hockey Hall of Fame.

“If I end up in the Hall of Fame or I don’t, it doesn’t matter. I won what I won, and this is what makes me proud. It’s not like I’m going to wear a Hall of Fame coat to dinner,” he joked. “If people appreciate what I did throughout my career and they want to give it to me, fine. If they don’t, ... it’s out of my control.”
The fact Letang spent five minutes telling me he didn’t care suggested to me that maybe he does. And why shouldn’t he? This is his legacy here.
But I do understand why Letang might guard himself against the expectation that he should one day get the call to the Hall. He has been overlooked relative to his NHL peers and is underappreciated even by some Pittsburgh fans.
Read More
The reality is, though, Letang might already have a Hall of Fame resume.
An accountant turned analyst named Paul Pidutti, whose story we will get to later in this column, created a statistical model that factors in the accomplishments of existing Hall of Famers to determine which players deserve to join them in the Hall. Pidutti uses a scoring system to stack those players into tiers.
His “Inner Circle” tier consists of roughly 40 of the greatest players ever, including Mario Lemieux and Sidney Crosby. Then there is the “Qualified” tier, followed by “Borderline” and then the “Hall of Fame Standard,” which reflects all the players who are in, even if they maybe weren’t as deserving as others.
Anyway, Letang has already ascended into the “Qualified” tier. Which, in the words of Pidutti, means he “easily” clears the bar for enshrinement in the Hall.
No, Letang has never won a Norris Trophy. But Pidutti’s “High Noon” metric, which aims to capture where a player ranked among his active peers over a three-year span, said he was the NHL’s best defenseman from 2013 to 2016.
Pidutti also pointed to Letang’s longevity, despite some scary health problems that cut into his prime. In the eight years in which Letang was aged 24 to 31, only one blue-liner produced at a higher rate. Some guy named Erik Karlsson.
“The thing that everyone misses with Letang’s case is this,” Pidutti said. “By having so many seasons in his [prime] shortened by injury, he quietly played near a Norris level annually but never had the in-year counting stats to show it.”
And Pidutti argued that if you adjust his point totals to reflect the eras Letang has played in, it is even more impressive that he is closing in on 700 points.
Pidutti said that if you also consider his “average defensive play,” his three Stanley Cups, his All-Star appearances and eight top-10 finishes in Norris voting, he meets the statistical standard while also having an inspirational narrative.
Letang winning the Masterton Trophy doesn’t factor into the model. But it will likely resonate with the Hall selection committee when Letang becomes eligible.
Add all it up and Letang is already one of the 30 best defensemen in NHL history, per Pidutti’s model. And Letang still hopes to play five more seasons.
“His brilliance has simply been masked by a lack of full, signature seasons,” Pidutti said. “He doesn’t need them, though. He was great nearly every year.”
KRIS LETANG easily belongs in the @HockeyHallFame. One of the most underrated players of his generation & now formally recognized for a life of defying the odds & dedication to his craft. #LetsGoPens #NHLAwards pic.twitter.com/JWOODrxQ6K
— Paul Pidutti (@AdjustedHockey) June 27, 2023
Back in August, at Adrenaline Performance Center in Montreal, I pulled out my iPhone to show Letang the player card Pidutti made for him, the one suggesting he was a Hall of Fame lock. Letang glanced at it then politely waved it away.
“Individual honors are cool,” Letang told me. He added he “obviously” wishes he could “win a Norris or something like that.” But, earnestly, he insisted the main thing he cares about is “being part of a core” that won four Cups.
He mentioned the Montreal Canadiens, New York Islanders and Edmonton Oilers of decades past and noted that no team has done it in the salary cap era.
He would be honored to one day get into the Hall. But it would be more meaningful to him to be “part of a group that did something that people remember.”
“Maybe I’ve been on Sid’s team for so long and he doesn’t give a [bleep] about those things?” Letang said. “At the end of the day, he just wants to win Cups.”
POINT SHOTS
• So why did Pidutti start crunching these numbers? That’s a pretty cool story.
The Ontario resident grew up playing hockey and as a kid was fascinated by stats. He said, “My entire life I wanted to objectively compare and rank players. Who has the time, right?” Suddenly, the pandemic lockdowns provided that.
Looking to make something positive out of the situation, Pidutti began to build his “Pidutti Point Share” model. He opened his @AdjustedHockey account on Twitter last fall and started to share some of his Hall of Fame analysis. Soon, his work was being mentioned on DailyFaceoff.com, the Athletic and Sportsnet.
Pidutti, 37, said he plans to take the next step with his “fun side hustle” and branch out beyond Hall of Fame content on his website, adjustedhockey.com.
• Pidutti in July campaigned for former Penguins defenseman Sergei Gonchar to be inducted into the Hall of Fame. But Gonchar was passed over again.
The PPS model has Gonchar comfortably in the “Qualified” tier (and slightly ahead of Letang for now). Gonchar was also first in the “High Noon” metric at one point. Pidutti believes Gonchar and others from the late 1990s and early 2000s are being overlooked because they played in the NHL’s “Dead Puck Era.”
Pidutti argued the Hall has “slept on an entire generation of greatness,” most notably Gonchar, who won a Cup with Pittsburgh and put up 811 career points.
• Who else from Pittsburgh’s recent title teams are Hall-caliber, per Pidutti?
Evgeni Malkin is already in the “Inner Circle,” an all-time great. Marc-Andre Fleury is above the borderline and a “great candidate,” he said. Pidutti thinks Phil Kessel has a legitimate case even though the model has Kessel below the borderline. And with five more strong years, Jake Guentzel will get in the mix.
• Me talking here: I think Kessel is a fascinating case. An imperfect player and an imperfect personality, but he has three Cup rings, he holds the league’s “ironman” mark and if he plays this season, he could hit 1,000 career points.
THREE STARS
3. Bryan Rust. Rust has started the season hot by scoring four times in the first four games. His goal Wednesday in Detroit was impressive, swatting the puck in out of midair. That was one of two deflection goals Rust has steered in so far.
2. Erik Karlsson. Karlsson was incredible in Detroit. He buried his first goal in black and gold, dished out two assists and completely controlled play in the third period. Pittsburgh might need more of that with Letang potentially sidelined.
1. Evgeni Malkin. On Monday, Malkin was named the NHL’s Third Star of the Week after he had six points in his first three games. Geno followed that up with another goal Wednesday. His early chemistry with Reilly Smith is encouraging.
YOU ASKED...
Do you agree that the Penguins would have won 3 cups in a row? Had they kept Mark Andre Fleury over Matt Murray?
— Lil Honky Dick (@LilHonkyDick) October 18, 2023
I will start off by saying the decision to protect Murray, a 23-year-old who stood in the crease for two Cup-clinching wins, was completely defensible at the time. With the benefit of hindsight, we can now see that injuries wrecked his career.
But I’ll indulge you. Let’s say they let Vegas take Murray. The $2 million difference in salary between Fleury and Murray would have prevented the Penguins from keeping one of free agents Brian Dumoulin, Justin Schultz and Conor Sheary.
The bigger piece here may be team chemistry. Fleury was a big part of their heart and soul. Six years later, they might still be trying to fill some of that void.
All that said, that 2017-18 team simply ran out of gas. Sure, Murray didn’t perform like he did the previous two seasons. But goaltending isn’t why they lost.
To me, the more fun hypothetical is asking what the Penguins would look like today had they traded Murray to another team for a couple of high draft picks, instead of giving one to the Golden Knights to incentivize them to take Fleury. Maybe one of them turns into a young star who keeps their Cup window open.
STAT N’AT
11 – players, coaches and execs from Pittsburgh’s 1991 and 1992 teams who were selected to the Hall. Tom Barrasso, the latest, gets enshrined next month.
FINAL BUZZER
Sticking with the Hall of Fame theme, I asked Crosby to name the man or woman whom he feels is the most deserving to be in the Hall but has yet to be voted in.
“[Alexander] Mogilny,” he said with little hesitation. “I was always impressed by him as a player. ... [When I was] growing up, he seemed pretty dominant, and I know he had good numbers. I had a chance to skate with him [informally] when I was younger, too, and he always seemed like a guy that had a pretty good chance.”
Crosby is far from alone. Many feel the Russian should be in the Hall. Me, too.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.