The Penguins fired Ron Hextall as general manager Friday after his team failed to make the playoffs for the first time in 16 years. Here’s a look back at the moves that most contributed to the Penguins’ struggles and led to his ouster.
Trading for Mikael Granlund — The nadir for so many reasons. The biggest was obviously his horrific production after the March 1 deal that brought him to Pittsburgh. In 21 games, he scored just one goal and registered just four assists for a grand total of five lousy points. All while Brock McGinn and Kasperi Kapanen — two players shipped out of town at the deadline for their own lacking totals — outscored him with Anaheim and St. Louis, respectively. Making matters worse, the deal wasn’t just a bad rental. The Penguins enter the offseason owing Granlund $5 million for the next two seasons, during which he’ll be hurdling toward his mid-30s already in a state of clear statistical decline. He’s scored more than 50 points just once in the past four seasons. Granted, that one was last year, when he tallied 11 goals and 53 assists for a total of 64 points. But the trend line was obviously heading down well before Hextall made the call to add him. And the Penguins will now face the salary cap consequences of dealing with such a bad contract.
Letting Jared McCann go to Seattle in the expansion draft — No one saw his 40 goals this season coming. At least not when the 26-year-old was in Pittsburgh from 2019 to 2021. In parts of three seasons here, he never scored more than 14 times and missed a fair amount of action because of various injuries. Still, analytics always suggested he had a chance to get better and at least become a 25- or 30-goal kind of guy. And it was a big surprise when the Penguins chose to protect Jeff Carter — a veteran with the kind of pricey contract that expansion teams shy away from — instead of McCann, a younger guy with potential. Technically, they shipped him to Toronto before he was ultimately selected by former Penguin and Seattle general manager Ron Francis in the draft. But the practical effect was the same. Hextall chose a player who was in decline rather than one who was on the rise. And regardless of where McCann’s career goes from here, the firepower Hextall gave up in letting him go was a major reason he’s now unemployed.
Re-signing Jeff Carter — Bringing the two-time Stanley Cup champion to Pittsburgh from Los Angeles in April of 2021 was actually one of Hextall’s best moves. Initially, at least. Carter scored nine times in just 14 regular season games after the deal. And he stayed hot in the postseason, tallying four more goals as the Penguins lost in six games to the New York Islanders in the first round. And with one extra season left on his deal, the trade had a chance to pay more dividends without much of a commitment. But rather than let things play out, Hextall signed Carter to a two-year extension last January. He was 37 at the time, and his production nosedived almost immediately. He scored just one goal in the playoff series last season against the New York Rangers. And this season, he managed just 13 goals and 16 assists while playing his fewest minutes since his rookie year of 2005-06 and finishing with an ugly minus-16 rating. And the worst part? They’re still on the hook for still another year — when Carter will be 39 — at more than $3 million. That’s valuable cap space that would be better spent on improving the team around Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang. Instead, the next general manager will have to find a way out from under this albatross of a deal.
Re-signing Kasperi Kapanen — Fans and media were shocked when Hextall brought the veteran winger back this past offseason. Kapanen played just 40 games of limited production in 2020-21 after former GM Jim Rutherford re-acquired him from Toronto. And he was wildly inconsistent in 2021-22, totaling just 11 goals and 21 assists in 79 games. At that point, most felt Hextall should allow the 26-year-old to become some other team’s problem. Instead, he signed him to a new deal for not one, but two more seasons at a higher cap hit than many expected. The results were ugly. Kapanen totaled 20 points in 43 games this season — production so bad the Penguins had to put him on waivers. The deal contributed to the salary cap crunch that prevented the team from making a bigger splash at the trade deadline — the type that might have saved them from missing the playoffs by just two points.
Sticking with Tristan Jarry as the No. 1 goalie — Sometimes a general manager screws up with the moves he doesn’t make, and that was definitely the case with Hextall. Regardless of all of these other moves we’ve discussed, goaltending has loomed as the Penguins’ biggest issue for some time. Jarry cost them with a lack of availability in the playoff bubble in 2020. He was terrible in the playoff series against the Islanders in 2021. He was absent for most of the playoffs once again last season, leaving the team in the incapable hands of a AHL-caliber Louis Domingue for the loss to the New York Rangers in seven games. And he was once again riddled with injuries this year while posting some terrible results. His 2.90 goals against average ranked 23rd. His .909 save percentage ranked 17th. And he played just 47 games total, forcing backup Casey DeSmith to carry nearly half the season load. Hextall did nothing to address the situation at any point, choosing not even to bring in a veteran backup who could push Jarry for time when he struggled. It wasn’t his only downfall, obviously. But had he come up with a better answer in net, it’s much more likely he’d have gotten the team into the playoffs with a chance to advance and save his job.
Read More
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.