NEW YORK — The Penguins appeared to be well on their way to a series-clinching win Wednesday when their captain disappeared into the dressing room.

It was past the midway point of the second period and the Penguins were up, 2-0, and in complete control. Sidney Crosby was dominant again. The New York Rangers looked ready to hit the links. Madison Square Garden was subdued.

But the game quickly turned after Crosby was clobbered by a high hit from Rangers defenseman Jacob Trouba. The Rangers pumped three goals past Louis Domingue and went on to win, 5-3, in Game 5 of their first-round playoff series.

Losing Crosby was deflating, but the Penguins didn’t use that as an excuse.

Advertise with us

“We’ve got plenty of leaders on our team that have been through a lot. You never want to see a player like that leave, but we’ve got the group to step up,” said Jake Guentzel, who had two more goals in the loss. “We know we’ve got a lot of capable guys in that locker room. We’ve got to find a way to get that done.”

The Penguins, up 3-2, will get another chance to clinch Friday in Pittsburgh.

Will Crosby be available for Game 6? That was unclear late Wednesday night.

Coach Mike Sullivan said after the game that Crosby’s upper-body injury was still being evaluated. He also made it clear he was not a fan of Trouba’s hit.

Crosby had gloved a puck out of the air in the offensive zone and briefly glanced down as he tried to settle it on the blade of his stick. At that moment, Trouba, who has a reputation for borderline hits, stepped up and delivered a high check on Crosby. Trouba appeared to catch Crosby in the face with his left elbow.

Advertise with us

Crosby’s head snapped back and he fell. He hopped up and skated to the bench. He took his last shift with about seven minutes left in the second period.

With his history of concussions and neck issues, which took away a big chunk of his prime, the hockey world holds its breath whenever Crosby goes down.

Sullivan was asked if he thought Trouba had an intent to injure on that play.

“Did you see the hit? You probably have the same opinion I do,” he replied.

Soon after Crosby was knocked out of Game 5, the Rangers came roaring back.

Advertise with us

In the first half of the game, the Penguins had kept the Rangers on the perimeter. Louis Domingue was hardly tested. But the Rangers started to build momentum, got their grind game going and hogged the puck in the Pittsburgh zone.

They buried three goals in two minutes, 42 seconds late in the second period.

Adam Fox woke up the Madison Square Garden crowd when his long shot made it through a thicket of skaters and surprised Domingue. Alexis Lafreniere, left alone in front, tied it up after New York cycled Pittsburgh’s second defensive pair out of position. Then Trouba’s backhand squirted between Domingue’s pads.

Trouba’s go-ahead goal had Madison Square Garden rocking and rolling again.

“We were comfortable for the majority of the game. We felt like we had complete control of it,” Sullivan said. “Give the Rangers credit. They pushed.”

Advertise with us

Guentzel scored, off another pretty Evgeni Malkin assist, just 13 seconds later. He has scored in all five games during this series. In Penguins postseason history, only Mario Lemieux has posted a longer streak, a record run of seven games.

But Filip Chytil netted the winner early in the third period, with the Rangers on a power play. His spinning shot from the right dot beat Domingue’s blocker.

“It was just kind of a broken play,” Teddy Blueger said. “A little bit of bad luck.”

Domingue couldn’t elevate his play and get the Penguins through. None of the goals was bad. But another goalie may have made a couple more saves.

Igor Shesterkin, meanwhile, built some momentum after his rocky two starts at PPG Paints Arena. He made 29 saves on Wednesday, none bigger than when he stretched out his right pad to rob Evan Rodrigues as the Penguins pushed for a late equalizer. Ryan Lindgren would put it away with an empty-netter.

Advertise with us

This has been a wild series, with thrilling games and unexpected twists and turns. To outsiders, it might have felt as if the trajectory changed again when Crosby exited Game 5. The Penguins may be without their franchise player and their emotional heartbeat. And the Rangers and their star goalie have new life.

The Penguins did their best to present a positive front after Wednesday’s loss.

“[Crosby is] a real important player for us. But I think throughout the course of the year, when we played without him we did pretty well. We’ve battled through injuries,” Blueger said. “So I don’t think it’s anything we can’t overcome.”

If Crosby misses time, the Penguins will lean on Malkin to fill some of the void.

Sullivan felt he had another strong game Wednesday. Malkin picked up a pair of assists, including a perfect pass to Kris Letang on a 2-on-1. After Crosby left, he set up Guentzel from behind the New York net. Those two, along with Bryan Rust, have clicked in years past. That trio was unstoppable two seasons ago.

Advertise with us

Blueger and Jeff Carter would also be thrust into bigger roles if Crosby were to sit out upcoming games. Brian Boyle would likely be moved back to center.

The Penguins now get two days to regroup before they get another shot, this time at PPG Paints Arena, to clinch their first playoff series win since 2018.

“We’re going back home. We had two good games at home,” Marcus Pettersson said. “So stay positive. Keep our heads up. And know that we’re going back to our building and it’s going to be fun playing there. We’ll get another crack at it.”

Matt Vensel; mvensel@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @mattvensel.