When the NHL paused its season in mid-March, Tristan Jarry retreated to the peace and quiet of his 60-acre barley farm in Sherwood Park, Alberta, an urban town about half an hour from Edmonton.
Locked down and far from any training facility, the 25-year-old Penguins goalie with quiet confidence bought a net online and got creative. His girlfriend, Hannah, tossed tennis balls. And to keep his stick-handling sharp, Jarry enlisted his two English Mastiffs, Diesel and Kitty.
“Diesel is a lot better,” Jarry said during training camp. “Kitty just kind of laid down and played dead.”
Oh, kind of like the Penguins in Game 3?
After a four-month pause that gave the Penguins unexpected health and enviable forward depth, a veteran team that’s hoisted three Stanley Cups since 2009 played the second period as if they’d spent intermission on the parade route with Olli Maatta. They looked lackluster and loose as the No. 24 seeded team in the 24-team tournament stormed back from a 3-1 deficit to push the Penguins to the brink of elimination.
Now, trailing 2-1 in the five-game series, the Penguins’ backs are against the bubble. They’ll need to win Friday night on Sidney Crosby’s 33rd birthday and Saturday just to advance to the “first round” of 16 teams.
Read More
Coach Mike Sullivan took the patient approach after a Game 1 loss. Rather than shake things up for Game 2, Sullivan did the opposite. Same lines. Same defensive pairings. Same goalie.
The only thing that was different was the result. Matt Murray rewarded the coach for his confidence by pitching 57-plus minutes of shutout goaltending.
However, after Murray allowed four goals — including a game-winner from a brutal angle — will it be too late if Sullivan waits any longer?
"Any time a coach or a group makes changes, there’s always an element of risk associated with it,” Sullivan said. “But one could argue there’s an element of risk associated with not making a change, as well."
If Sullivan chooses to mix up his lineup, the third line is an obvious place to start. It could have been an X-factor but has turned into a complete non-factor. The third defensive pairing of Jack Johnson and Justin Schultz has been hemorrhaging scoring chances. That’s another clear problem area.
But just like the rest of this season, it all comes back to the goalies eventually. Sullivan added two more banners to PPG Paints Arena by making the tough decisions in the crease at the right time.
This is different.
The coach doesn’t have the benefit of taking the pulse of his goalies over an 82-game warmup to the postseason. He has to make a call — and right now — on how he thinks Jarry will perform in his first live game action since March 8.
Over the course of the entire season, Jarry was the better goalie. He posted a .921 save percentage and 2.43 goals-against average to Murray’s .899 save percentage and 2.87 goals-against average. More consistency. More shutouts. More of a chance to steal a game.
That’s especially true when the Penguins were at their best. Sans Sid, they went 18-6-4 from Nov. 9 to Jan. 14 thanks to this formula: The Jake Guentzel-Evgeni Malkin-Bryan Rust line provided the overwhelming majority of the scoring chances; the upstart goalie shutting the door. Jarry went 14-3-1 during that stretch with a .932 save percentage.
Had Jarry kept it up, we wouldn't be having this conversation. However, when Crosby came back to the lineup, Jarry returned to Earth.
Jarry left the door open for Murray, going 4-6-0 in his last 10 appearances with a .900 save percentage. He last won a game on Feb. 18 and in his final four appearances before the pause, Jarry allowed five goals, two goals, five goals and six goals. He lost all four.
Then, Jarry went to the farm.
Maybe his girlfriend secretly has a live arm and zips fastballs like Randy Johnson. Or maybe his dogs dangle like Mario Lemieux. But to go from seeing no live shots at all to seeing a Montreal team that led the Eastern Conference in shots on goal and high-danger scoring chances will be no easy task.
“Playing against them this year, they shoot a lot of pucks from the corner,” Jarry said before the series — a quote that now feels like foreshadowing after the way Jeff Petry ended Game 3. “When they have an opportunity to get the puck on the net, it’s coming at you.”
One of the factors that likely swayed Sullivan to go with Murray is that he stood tall during two Stanley Cup runs.
Jarry, who has never appeared in an NHL postseason game, doesn’t have the benefit of that experience. What he does have, unfortunately, is the familiar queasy feeling the Penguins are experiencing now after a postseason gut punch.
Back in 2014, after years of serving as the understudy to Laurent Brossoit, Jarry earned the No. 1 goaltending job for the Edmonton Oil Kings during the Western Hockey League finals. Just as Wednesday night’s 3-1 loss evaporated, the Portland Winterhawks stormed back from a 5-2 deficit to stun Jarry and the Oil Kings.
“The guys were just disasters,” said Derek Laxdal, the former head coach of the Oil Kings and current assistant for the Dallas Stars.
But behind the steady hand and sly stick-handling of Jarry, the Oil Kings captured a 4-1 victory in Game 7, a third consecutive WHL title and eventually the Memorial Cup.
Now, the question is if Jarry can once again be the goalie to steady a series. Will it happen? And will he even get the chance?
While there are no easy answers, one thing is certain. By late September, Jarry will be back in Alberta. The only question is if he’s baling barley or 30 minutes down the road in the Edmonton bubble.
Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.