The NHL has “paused” its season due to the COVID-19 pandemic and it’s unclear if it will resume. With one eye still on the future, the Post-Gazette is looking back at what each Penguins player did in 2019-20, starting with the captain, No. 87, and counting down by jersey number.

The timing might have been the cruelest part.

Just hours after Jake Guentzel was named an All-Star for the first time in his career, he collided violently into the boards. The Penguins’ 25-year-old winger had just scored a dazzling goal on what very well might be his last touch on a puck in the 2019-20 regular season. But the goal horn that echoed through PPG Paints Arena was quickly turned off, as the whole building sat stunned and silent.

Before the injury, Guentzel was on pace for his second consecutive 40-goal season. There’s an argument to be made — and a pretty good one — that he was the Penguins’ best player through the first 39 games. He led the Penguins in in points (43) and goals (20) at the time of the injury on Dec. 30.

Advertise with us

That moment, in some ways, was also the turning point in the Penguins season. The Penguins were 24-11-4 before Guentzel’s shoulder surgery. They went just 16-12-2 after.

During a season in which so many significant players missed so much time, Guentzel was one of the few constants keeping a rapidly evolving team photo in focus. When Evgeni Malkin went down with an injury just days into the season, Guentzel and Sidney Crosby helped carry the Penguins. Guentzel tallied 14 points (eight goals, six assists) in the 17 games with the captain. Then, when Crosby went down, Guentzel somehow was even better with Malkin. He posted 29 points (12 goals, 17 assists) in the 21 games without Crosby.

The chemistry Guentzel, Malkin and Bryan Rust found was almost instantaneous. And why wouldn’t it be? A 40-goal scorer in Guentzel. A former Hart Trophy winner in Malkin. Rust in the middle of his career year. Yeah, that should work.

When Guentzel underwent shoulder surgery in the hours after the collision, the Penguins estimated he’d miss four to six months. With the NHL season now paused, the extra couple months of recovery might be the difference between Guentzel finishing his season in the press box and him contributing to a Stanley Cup run.

Of course, that assumes the NHL returns this summer. At this point, that might be a big assumption.

Advertise with us

DEFINING MOMENT: Midway through the third period of the Penguins’ 5-2 win over the Ottawa Senators, Rust zipped a pass to Malkin on the left side of the goal mouth. Malkin creatively fed the puck across the crease. Racing at full speed, Guentzel tipped the puck in with the skill of a 40-goal scorer. But as he extended his stick, Guentzel tripped over Thomas Chabot and flew into the wall.

STAT THAT STANDS OUT: In the 21 games without Crosby, Guentzel tallied 12 goals and 17 assists to lead the Penguins to a 14-5-3 record.

IF THE SEASON RESUMES: Might Guentzel’s season resume along with it? Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford and coach Mike Sullivan both seem confident Guentzel will be back at some point during a postseason run. The Penguins initially estimated he’d miss four to six months, which means he could be health enough to play as soon as the end of April. The NHL plans to abide by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s recommendations to limit mass gatherings until at least the middle of May. At this point, it’s probably time to stop worrying if Guentzel will return and instead wonder if the season will.

LONG-TERM OUTLOOK: Rutherford is always aggressive in the trade market. But Guentzel’s injury added even more reason to go out and get Jason Zucker from Minnesota. When the season was postponed, Zucker was playing alongside Crosby on the top line. Whether the season resumes this year or in the distant future, the Penguins will have some decisions to make. Zucker is signed through 2022-23 and Guentzel through 2023-24. The most likely scenario is Guentzel rejoins Crosby. But with as effective as Guentzel and Malkin were together, Sullivan might want to at least experiment with that combination from time to time.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo. 

Advertise with us

PENGUINS ON PAUSE SERIES

April 1: No. 71 Evgeni Malkin

March 31: No. 72 Patric Hornqvist

March 30: No. 87 Sidney Crosby