Welcome back to Mike’s Mailbag (Patent pending)!
Every other week, I beg you to send me your Penguins questions and then I answer the best ones here in this segment. My bosses call it reader engagement. I just like the idea of making you do half my job for me.
We’ve got a lot to get to this week, so let’s jump right in.
Joseph B.: Jim Rutherford made his big move by acquiring Jason Zucker. Is this enough? Or do the Penguins still need to make another trade to position themselves for the postseason?
Mike: There are two ways to answer this question. First, do the Penguins need to make another move? No. I really believe if they can get healthy and stay relatively healthy, this team has all the pieces to contend late into the summer. After all, this is the same team that racked up the NHL’s most points in December even though they were without Sidney Crosby for the entire month.
But will they make another move? That’s a different question. My answer here is, yes. There are two main areas Rutherford might address: a bottom-six forward or a left-handed defenseman. Let’s examine each case.
Read More
In terms of forwards, Zach Aston-Reese is week-to-week with a lower-body injury. Nick Bjugstad has followed a non-linear path back to the ice after core muscle surgery. It’s tough to know exactly when he’ll be back or what the Penguins will get from him when he does return. Plus, one of the top call-up options, Joseph Blandisi, was traded on Thursday. Adding one more piece to a third or fourth line could improve the depth and allow coach Mike Sullivan to roll four lines more consistently.
When it comes to the defense, that somewhat hinges upon the health of John Marino and Brian Dumoulin. Right now, Marino is estimated to miss three-to-six weeks after undergoing surgery to repair broken bones in his face. That seems like a fair estimate and a predictable recovery time frame.
But Dumoulin is the X-factor. He recently began his on-ice rehab from ankle surgery. Still, it’s fair to wonder how quickly he can return from such significant surgery and if he’ll be the same player that he was before the injury. Adding a little insurance on the left-side of the blue, like a sixth or seventh D-man, in exchange for a mid-round pick wouldn’t be the worst move.
Joe W.: With the prices as high as they are for defensemen at the deadline, is there any chance GMJR can move Jack Johnson's contract? Teams might be desperate enough.
Mike: As much criticism as Johnson got last year — much of it merited — he’s been much, much better this season. After training hard this offseason, becoming more familiar with the Penguins’ style and playing on his natural left side, Johnson has proven himself as a reliable piece of the blue line. Just look at what he’s doing now with Dumoulin out, playing on the top pairing next to Kris Letang.
All that said, I agree that his deal is not great. He’s 33 now. In 2022-23, he’ll be 36 years old and carry a $3,250,000 cap hit.
Still, I don’t see the Penguins trying to move him. As I mentioned earlier, with Dumoulin sidelined, the Penguins are thin on the left side of their blue line, as is. The three healthy lefties are Marcus Pettersson, Johnson and Juuso Riikola. Reading the tea leaves, it doesn’t seem the Penguins are all that fond of Riikola’s game, going as far as to play Chad Ruhwedel on his off-side instead.
If the Penguins moved Johnson, they’d be even thinner on the left side. If anything, I think the Penguins would add a left-handed defenseman rather than trying to move one.
Ross C.: Do you think Zucker can average a point per game alongside Crosby? He gets/creates about 5-6 high quality scoring chances a game and really meshes with Sid well.
Mike: The Penguins had their eye on Zucker for about three years and it’s easy to see why. His speed, ability to drive the net and complement top-six centers fits exactly what the Penguins needed, especially with Jake Guentzel sidelined.
Entering Thursday night, he’s tallied four points in four games next to Crosby. Can he keep it up? Well, during his best season in 2017-18, Zucker had 64 points (33 goals, 31 assists) in 82 games. I see no reason he can’t improve upon that production if he continues to skate next to a dynamic playmaker like Crosby.
I’m also curious to see if Zucker earns some time with the top power play unit as he becomes more comfortable here. The Penguins have been much-improved on the man-advantage since Crosby returned. If Zucker can add a couple points there, I could see him inching closer to that point-per-game average.
Lisa N.: Do you think the Pens would consider trying to convince Matt Cullen to come out of retirement? They need a fourth-line center badly and Bjugstad does not appear anywhere close to coming back. I am sure he has stayed in good shape and we have seen others like Mike Fisher come back late in the season.
Mike: This is a fun one to consider. Who wouldn’t want to see a 43-year-old come out of retirement for one last run?
Unfortunately, I don’t think it’s likely. By the end of last season, it really felt like the right time for Cullen to step away. Plus, the Penguins might be better off at center than they seem. I get that Bjugstad is a big question mark now. But as long as he does eventually return, I think the Penguins are solid up the middle with Crosby, Malkin and Teddy Blueger. Bjugstad or McCann would make sense as the fourth center. Dominik Kahun and Dominik Simon can also play center in a pinch, so there are a couple options.
Louie W.: This is your first season covering the Penguins as a sports journalist. As a Pittsburgher (Latrobean—close enough), what has surprised you most about the job? The personalities, the coaches & management, the grind, the road trips, interacting with other folks on the beat?
Mike: Honestly, I do have to pinch myself sometimes. To cover the hometown team for the paper I grew up reading has been an incredible experience. For the most part, everyone — players, coaches, management, other writers — have been really welcoming.
To answer your question, I always heard stories about how hockey players are good with the media. But I’ve still been a little surprised by it, especially when it comes to the stars. In the Penguins locker room, that starts with Crosby. He’s one of the best players in the world but sits there and answers every question from every reporter like he’s some no-name who was just recalled from the minors. I think that really sets the tone within the locker room with his humility and accessibility.
Along the same lines, I’ve really appreciated Rutherford’s openness, honesty and accessibility. Not all general managers are like that, especially to newcomers. For a first-year beat writer, he’s definitely helped make my job so much easier. In turn, hopefully that’s made all of you more well-informed and educated Penguins fans.
Tyler B.: Drums or flats?
Mike: Okay, I saved the most controversial question for last. If you know me, you know that I’m a chicken wing connoisseur. During my drive to Toronto this week, I actually stopped for wings in Buffalo, like my own personal pilgrimage to Mecca.
So, as a noted chicken wing guy, the answer is flats. Yeah, they might take more work to eat if you’re a rookie. But if you know what you’re doing, you can pop them in your mouth and eat the entire thing in one bite. Great party trick. Ladies love it.
Whatever you prefer, drums or flats, just don’t eat boneless wings. They are not wings. They’re chicken nuggets meant for a child. Just gross, leftover scraps of a bird glued together and fried. Be an adult. Don’t eat chicken nuggets.
And would you look at that. Somehow, once again, we’re talking about food. Everyone get yourself some wings and enjoy the games this week. I’ll be back on March 5 with another mailbag.
Have a Penguins question? Need dating advice? Problem with a coworker? No question is a bad question. If you have one, tweet me @MikeDeFabo, slide in my DMs or send me an email at mdefabo@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.