TORONTO — The Penguins could see this coming.

After thumping the Toronto Maple Leafs Tuesday night at PPG Paints Arena, the Penguins anticipated a redemption-hungry home team would punch back in the second half of the home-and-home series. No way it would be so easy on the Maple Leafs’ home ice.

“I would expect them to be a motivated group,” Penguins captain Sidney Crosby said Thursday morning. “Points are important always, but especially this time of year. Playing a team a couple times in a row like this, you expect the intensity and the emotion to be high.”

It turned out the captain was right.

Advertise with us

In a lopsided, 4-0 loss, the Penguins yielded three goals in the span of less than eight minutes in the second period. That was more than enough offensive support for Toronto’s All-Star goaltender Frederik Andersen, who made 24 saves to pitch the shutout.

The Penguins (37-16-6) entered the night sitting alone in first place in the Metropolitan Division, one point ahead of the Washington Capitals. After the Penguins’ regulation loss and the Capitals’ overtime loss, the two teams each have 80 points in the standings.

The Penguins do have a game in hand, as it has played one fewer game than the Capitals. But an opportunity to cushion their lead in the standings instead slipped away.

“We didn’t deserve to win tonight,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “They played better than us. They outplayed us. They got what they deserved and so did we.”

The Maple Leafs (32-22-8) have been a bit of a Jekyll-and-Hyde team this season. On one hand, they’re one of the league’s worst defensive teams, a group that frequently gives up odd-man rushes and grade-A scoring opportunities. On the other hand, they have one of the game’s best players in Auston Matthews leading a forward group that’s full of firepower.

Advertise with us

After the Penguins rolled through the first type of team Tuesday, they felt the full brunt of that potent offense showed up Thursday.

After a scoreless first period, the Maple Leafs took a 1-0 lead at 7:45 in the second period. Toronto defenseman Jake Muzzin ripped a shot from the point, through a Denis Malgin screen and past Penguins goalie Matt Murray.

Moments later, the Penguins were forced to play 3-on-5 with Marcus Pettersson and Brandon Tanev in the penalty box. The ice was already beginning to tilt heavily toward the home team. And it only continued in that direction. Off a faceoff win, William Nylander found himself all alone in the left circle. Murray got a piece of the shot, but not enough to keep it from trickling into the net for a 2-0 lead.

Just over three minutes later, Alexander Kerfoot sprung Kasperi Kapanen on a breakaway. He didn’t miss, beating Murray high on his blocker side.

Two nights ago, the Penguins were coasting through the second period with a 5-0 lead. Now, just like that, they found themselves with the shoe on the other foot, trailing the same opponent by three goals.

Advertise with us

The Maple Leafs continued to pile on in the third period. Zach Hyman batted a shot out of the air, then cleaned up the rebound to give Toronto a 4-0 lead, effectively sealing the win.

“We’ve got to learn from it,” Penguins forward Bryan Rust said. “Teams like that with good offenses, we’re going to see a lot of them down the stretch. We’ve got to know how to play the right way in order to win these games.”

Murray entered Thursday night playing his best hockey of the season. He began the night with a 6-1-1 record since the calendar turned to 2020, a .929 save percentage and a 2.22 goals-against average.

None of the four goals were necessarily huge mistakes. Plus, one could argue he had almost no chance on the power-play goal and the breakaway. Nonetheless, Murray dropped his second start since the turn of the year and gave up four goals for the first time since allowing four in back-to-back starts Dec. 21 and 28.

“We knew they were going to bring their best for sure,” Murray said. “I think they did. They were good all night. You’ve got to give it to them. They were pressuring the puck. It felt like the whole second period they were pressing. Give credit to them.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins added injury to insult late in the game. Dominik Kahun, playing in just his second game back after recovering from a concussion, blocked a shot off his left knee and left the game. Sullivan did not provide any additional details about his status immediately after the game.

The Penguins won’t have to wait long to redeem themselves. As the schedule gets busier, they will play host Saturday afternoon to the Buffalo Sabres, then turn around and head to Washington for a Sunday matinee against their Metro rival.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.