NEW YORK – Those poor Penguins, huh?
Really can’t catch a break. The team has been saddled with injury after injury dating back to training camp. Bryan Rust. Evgeni Malkin. Nick Bjugstad. Alex Galchenyuk. Jared McCann. Patric Hornqvist. Kris Letang. All of them missed time — or are missing time — with various injuries.
And now, most significantly, the face of the franchise and one of the game’s greats, Sidney Crosby, is out.
Penguins coach Mike Sullivan has declined to provide any more information other than to say he’s being evaluated. However, a report from The Athletic says that Crosby has been dealing with a sports hernia all season and — after further aggravating the injury in Saturday's win over the Chicago Blackhawks — he’s pondering surgery that could keep him out four to six weeks.
What bad luck, right? Maybe. But maybe it’s also something more.
Looking at the injuries as a collective whole, there are a few common threads. They’ve hit the team’s biggest stars, the highest-paid players and, also, the oldest players. That last part might be the most critical.
Read More
The Penguins have five players on their roster who are 32 or older. Three of them – Crosby (32), Letang (32) and Hornqvist (32) all missed Tuesday’s overtime loss to the New York Rangers. Malkin, who missed the first month of the season with a lower-body injury, is the oldest player on the team at 33. He’s also missed more time than anyone else. The only other player who is 32 or older is defenseman Jack Johnson.
Put together, Malkin ($9.5 million), Crosby ($8.7 million), Letang ($7.25 million) and Hornqvist ($5.3 million) make a total of $30.75 million. That’s 37.6% of the $81.5 million salary cap.
That’s not just a significant financial investment in a group that’s spent major chunks of time off the ice. It’s also the wager the Penguins have placed to keep their championship window open.
Sure, injuries can happen at any time in sports. (Just ask Rust, who was hit in the hand by a puck during the last preseason game.) But there’s no denying that as bodies age, the wear and tear of long seasons and longer postseason runs can take a toll. There’s a reason 30-year-old running backs in the NFL are looked at like spoiled milk.
Wayne Gretzky averaged 77 games per year in his 20s. But he was limited to just 45 games when he was 32 and 48 games when he was 34. Mario Lemieux, nagged throughout his career with chronic back pain, retired when he was 32. When he came back, he was limited to 43 games when he was 35, just 24 games at 36 and just 10 games at 38.
Yes, Jaromir Jagr somehow looks like he’s in better shape now than he was in his 20s. Gordie Howe played until he was 52. And in football, Tom Brady might be collecting social security checks before he retires. But these are largely the exceptions, not the norm.
Before the season began, Malkin brought up the finite nature of his profession on the first day of Penguins’ training camp. He said, “We have a couple, maybe two, three, four chances to win again.”
Hornqvist said, “I think the window starts for sure to slide a little bit. We’re starting to get older. But at the same time, we still have at least three, four good years in us.”
And Sullivan addressed the aging elephant in the room by saying, “They’re older, but they’re certainly not old. That’s a big difference.”
Currently, Crosby shows few, if any, signs of aging. He leads the team with 17 points, even while fighting the injury bug. Letang is third with 12 points, Hornqvist fifth with 10, and Malkin 11th with seven.
But even if age doesn't impact production, it might be a factor when it comes to keeping them all out there.
As sports science has evolved and coaches have become more aware of the value of rest and recovery, they’ve begun to find ways to manage workloads. The Penguins are one of the NHL teams on the forefront of this movement, often canceling morning skates.
For now, the Penguins will pay Letang more than $88,000 for every game his misses, while rookie defenseman John Marino (who makes less than $1 million) steps into his spot on the Penguins’ top defensive pairing. Crosby will make $106,000 for every game he misses, while Jared McCann ($1.25 million per year) plays in his spot in the middle. Hornqvist will be paid $64,000 each game he’s out, opening a hole for Sam Lafferty (who is paid less than $800,000).
Of course, the bet is that the stars will return in time to make that investment pay off. But will it? Only time can tell.
Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.