1. The days and weeks after the Penguins’ 2018-19 season ended with a thud were nothing short of fascinating. Kris Letang fumed when asked about taking a more conservative approach. Also on breakup day, Phil Kessel questioned why anyone would want to talk to him — “They’re just going to trade me,” the enigmatic winger quipped, with nobody knowing whether or not he was serious.
Behind closed doors, while he was every bit as angry as his players, general manager Jim Rutherford began to realize that one of his fears had come true: The Penguins had slipped, and Rutherford knew that if he didn’t act, they’d soon tumble from their perch as one of the NHL’s elite teams.
So Rutherford set out to rebuild his roster on the fly, a difficult task for any general manager. Out went Kessel and Olli Maatta. In came Brandon Tanev, Dominik Kahun and Alex Galchenyuk — all 27 or younger.
While from the outside it may have seemed reactionary, with even more wheeling and dealing from Trader Jim, the reality is that what we saw transpire this past offseason has much deeper roots.
“I think it really started at the end of not this past season but the season before,” Rutherford told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. “I felt that we had to start to transition the team, hopefully, on the fly and not get to a point where we have to totally rebuild it at some point in time. If you look at the moves last year, they were for needs, but they were also for younger players.”
Those moves included trades for Marcus Pettersson, Nick Bjugstad and Jared McCann, and they got the ball rolling for what Rutherford did this summer, when he finally addressed his team’s speed, hunger and style of play.
Read More
2. In explaining his thought process behind the busiest summer he’s experienced in Pittsburgh, Rutherford said a big starting point was the Penguins’ lack of depth at center.
It’s almost ironic given they have two of the league’s best pivots in Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, but Rutherford admitted that position had become something of a weakness for the Penguins.
Jordan Staal and Nick Bonino left. Derrick Brassard and Riley Sheahan (mostly) flopped. Matt Cullen retired. If the Penguins wanted to remain strong down the middle, a necessary component to any good team, Rutherford went into last season knowing he would probably have to do something significant.
“We were sitting here at this time last year not comfortable with our center ice position,” Rutherford said. “We didn’t have a lot of depth there. The trade with Florida changed that.”
3. That deal netted the Penguins Bjugstad and McCann. Meanwhile, and perhaps equally as important, they rid themselves of Brassard and Sheahan, who accumulated excuses the way the Penguins wished they would’ve picked up points.
And this summer, Rutherford acquired another possible center in Galchenyuk, who for now has been occupying the left wing spot on Malkin’s line.
Further down the depth chart the Penguins began to entertain the idea of Dominik Simon playing some center, a position he played in the Czech Republic, while Sam Lafferty’s development has been a pleasant surprise.
“Now we have a lot of centers,” Rutherford said. “And we got younger doing it.”
It’s a good thing, too, after the recent injuries suffered by Malkin and Bjugstad.
4. You’ll notice that the Penguins’ new pregame hype video is a techno remix of the Beatles’ “Come Together.”
That’s not an accident or because the Fab Four are big in the dressing room. Last year, coming together as a team was one of the primary knocks against the Penguins.
That’s sort of a vague term in sports. It’s not easily quantified, but it’s glaringly obvious when it’s missing. The Penguins, for a few different reasons, never jelled.
“That was really the start of it, going back to last year,” Rutherford said of his team lacking the cohesion it had in previous seasons. “It wasn’t a horrible year. We had 100 points, but it didn’t end right.
“There was never a comfort level, I don’t think, with anybody, including the players, that our team ever came together.”
5. The biggest deal Rutherford made, without question, involved trading Kessel, defenseman Dane Birks and a fourth-round pick to the Arizona Coyotes for Galchenyuk and another defenseman, Pierre-Olivier Joseph.
It might be easy to pin the Penguins’ issues on Kessel. He struggled during five-on-five play in 2018-19 and was one of the primary factors in them allowing so many short-handed goals, but Rutherford hardly viewed this trade as addition by subtraction.
Kessel remains an elite player, Rutherford very much believes. But for the Penguins to get the necessary salary cap space to retool their team, someone making a decent chunk of change had to go.
“I have the utmost respect for Phil, and I really like him,” Rutherford said. “This was not pointing the finger that he had anything to do with last year. Far from it. It’s more projecting out where we’re going to be a year from now, two years from now, three years from now. I still believe in him as an impact player. I think he’ll be really good in Arizona.”
6. Dating back to his time building a Stanley Cup-winning team in Carolina, Rutherford has always been wary of having too many 30-something stars with little left to prove. He likes the young-and-hungry guys, players who’ve not yet tasted the ultimate success, and felt that the Penguins needed to have more of those types on their roster.
Kessel has done some great things in Pittsburgh. Had become a fan favorite. Won two Cups. With his curmudgeonly personality, he had been almost universally loved by his teammates, a walking laugh. But complacency had set in, and Rutherford knew his team needed a major change.
“We went through a period, a successful period, where we needed all of those impact players,” Rutherford said. “You have to be careful how many you can have as players get into their 30s.
“We have guys who have been here their whole careers — Sid, Geno and [Kris Letang] — and so that’s where that decision was made.”
7. Another of Rutherford’s offseason comments that was revisited during the course of this interview was the one he repeated about complacency, how he felt some players had gotten a little too comfortable.
Rutherford did not want to single out Bryan Rust, so please don’t interpret this that way, but Rust was absolutely one of the players Rutherford was talking about. It’s also understandable, the GM said.
“When you look at Bryan Rust’s camp, Bryan Rust was our best player at camp this year,” Rutherford said. “Not that he played poorly, but he’s an example of a guy who I don’t think played at the level he was capable of a year ago. That just gets to contentment.
“He’s not the only guy. I’m not trying to single him out or pick on him. And when you win two Cups in a short period of time, it’s a natural thing. I’m not sure I know of anybody who wouldn’t be content in some ways.
“Then what you have to do is you have to make changes where you bring some guys in who play with that determination.”
8. That leads us to this year’s team, which looked nothing like the way it was supposed to look last Thursday for opening night. The Penguins did look content. They lacked any shred of the intensity that Rutherford sought.
It took Saturday’s 7-2 victory over the Blue Jackets to remind us all that the season is young, and no firm opinions should yet be formed.
But based on the entirety of training camp, Rutherford couldn’t possibly be happier with how things have turned out. After the rest of the NHL had literally and figuratively caught up with the Penguins, their general manager feels that their speed has once again become an asset.
“We lost our speed,” Rutherford said. “We lost our depth at forward over that period of time. Now, we’re back. We should have good speed and the type of player who can bring the determination.
“We have to see how it all comes together over time. How much does everybody like each other? How hard are they going to play for each other and support each other? That’s what every team looks for. We’re in a much stronger position for that to happen now.”
9. I couldn’t agree more here. I also don’t remember Rutherford openly admitting the Penguins had become too slow, although I have not been following day-to-day coverage like I did when I was on the beat.
However, I do give Rutherford a lot of credit for admitting when things don’t work out the way he intended. He does it better than a lot of his contemporaries, both inside and outside of hockey.
To me, that’s what happened here. The Penguins weren’t what they once were. They had lost a step, for pretty understandable reasons. And instead of being stubborn, Rutherford made some shrewd business moves that likely made the Penguins better in the long run.

10. I find the acquisition of Brandon Tanev to be fascinating for a couple reasons.
If you haven’t read Mike DeFabo’s story on him, I would absolutely recommend doing that. But Tanev intrigues me because he’s absolutely something the Penguins have lacked, the type of guy who will go into corners, create some havoc and play every shift like his hair is on fire.
Frankly, he reminds me a little of Pascal Dupuis in that regard. It’s possible the Penguins overpaid, giving Tanev a six-year contract, but Rutherford also saw what his team lacked and acted accordingly.
Can you really crush him for that?
“We did our homework on him,” Rutherford said. “We were looking for a team guy, a guy that plays with a lot energy, gives everything he’s got. He can play up and down the lineup.
“When you watch Tanev play, I think that helps a guy like Bryan Rust. He comes into camp and gets right back to where he was.”
11. A couple of off-topic things to round out my interview with Rutherford …
Rutherford has always been a big baseball fan, which I’ve covered in this space before. He’s also been a huge supporter of former Pirates manager Clint Hurdle, to the point that I brought this up with Hurdle during my first day on the Pirates beat.
The GM has gotten to know Hurdle some over the years and, suffice to say, was disappointed to learn Hurdle was fired.
“I felt very bad when I heard that Clint wasn’t coming back to the Pirates next year,” Rutherford said. “He is a real inspirational guy in Pittsburgh, an inspiration to people in my position. He sends out his daily emails and everything like that. I always looked forward to getting them. Always looked forward to seeing him. He’s a guy in our sports community, for people like me, who will really be missed.”
12. Rutherford and I also talked about the current baseball playoffs.
His World Series prediction?
“I’ll predict that the Red Sox won’t repeat,” he joked.
“The Astros and the Dodgers,” Rutherford continued. “That’ll be fun. Baseball is the same as hockey now. You get in the playoffs, anybody can win. You don’t want to discount any team. That’s what makes it fun.”
My bracket actually looks the same, with the Dodgers over the Cardinals in the NLCS and the Astros over the Yankees in the ALCS. Feeling OK about those right now.
13. Moving on … I’m convinced this is going to be a big year for McCann. Whether it’s on the wing with Sidney Crosby or centering his own line, McCann is poised for big things.
Has the right attitude. Can skate. Possesses a sneaky-good shot. Assuming he stays healthy, I’m looking for him to score 20 goals, perhaps 30.
It’s funny how we all made such a big deal of the Penguins getting Bjugstad, with the possibility of Bjugstad becoming a top-six winger. Thus far and by far, McCann has been the better piece in the trade.
14. Credit to Kris Letang for his power-play tally late in a five-goal second period Saturday against the Blue Jackets. Nifty goal. Through some traffic. Great feed from Galchenyuk.
But the Penguins power play has looked disjointed at times without Kessel. Has been evident on their breakouts and their ability to set up in-zone. Kessel played such a valuable role in the left circle. The Penguins have ample talent, but they definitely need someone to find a comfort level there.
15. I might be in the minority here, but I like the Penguins’ new goal-scoring song — House of Pain’s “Jump Around.”
The key is fast-forwarding some, which they did on Saturday. Like anything, it’s going to take some time. But I happen to like it. “Party Hard” had run its course.
16. Count me among those who were skeptical of the Jack Johnson-Erik Gudbranson pairing that debuted on Saturday.
I was pleasantly surprised, though it was only one game against a Columbus team that might be worse than many expected. But the two of them weren’t terrible.
It’s worth noting that Johnson played some of his best hockey with Denis Savard in Columbus. Gudbranson is obviously way more like that than Justin Schultz.
17. The only thing I hate more than continually seeing Simon on the top line is not continually seeing Simon on the top line.
Too much shuffling. Let it stick. Give him some time with Crosby early in the season. If he stinks, let’s move off this thing once and for all. If he’s good, you found your solution.
18. It’s crazy walking into the Penguins dressing room right now.
Gudbranson, McCann and Bjugstad used to be the new guys. Now it feels like they’re the elder statesmen. A lot of new faces.
“It’s been nice to know I’m coming back here this year, be able to prepare for it and wrap your mind around the way we play the game,” Gudbranson said. “Obviously being at camp and figuring out those intricacies over a longer period of time has been nice.”
19. Stat of the week: 16
That’s the number of wins for Penguins coach Mike Sullivan against John Tortorella and his Blue Jackets since Sullivan took over behind the Penguins bench. Sullivan is 16-3-1, including playoffs.
The two of them get together every offseason. Have to imagine Sullivan has brought that up a time or two.
20. Non-hockey thought of the week: Thank you.
Seriously. It’s been a really cool experience getting to walk back into my former life, and I wanted to say thanks to all of you who have made me feel welcome around the Penguins and have offered a few encouraging words regarding my work on hockey or baseball.
It’s been fun getting to experience this again and see so many people I’ve missed.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.