This is the fourth installment of Penguins primers leading up to the start of training camp on Sept. 13. Today, let’s about the goalies. Note that this series will resume Monday.
Both of the following statements about last season’s Penguins are true:
• The Penguins almost missed the playoffs because of Matt Murray.
• The Penguins would have missed the playoffs if not for Matt Murray.
For the two-time Cup-hoisting goalie, 2018-19 was a tale of two seasons.
He got off to a shaky start, at one point during the team’s November swoon got yanked three times in three weeks, and then went on injured reserve for a month with an injury that, to outsiders at least, seemingly came out of nowhere.
Read More
At that point, he had a 4.08 goals-against average and .877 save percentage. And, in related news, the last-place Penguins won just twice in 11 games.
With Murray on the shelf, Casey DeSmith, in his first season as Murray’s full-time backup, helped the free-falling Penguins turn their season around.
Murray returned in late December and got on a roll, picking up where DeSmith left off to put the Penguins on firmer footing. Then, from Feb. 1 on, he carried the Penguins across the finish line – with the help of the Crosby line – by morphing into Playoff Murray and going 14-7-5 with a .927 save percentage.
The postseason, of course, was not pretty for the Penguins, nor was Murray’s stat line in that sweep. But Murray had very little to do with that meltdown.
So, yeah, the 25-year-old’s final regular-season numbers — 2.69 GAA, .919 save percentage — turned out pretty good. But 2018-19 was a roller coaster.
The Penguins, who must decide how much money the soon-to-be free agent deserves to make on his next deal, would like a smoother ride this season.
And that’s the rub with Murray. As reliable as he was during the last two Cup runs, he has yet to show that he can be elite over the long regular season. Whether it has been injuries or up-and-down play, he has not topped 50 starts or a .920 save percentage in the two seasons since Marc-Andre Fleury left town.
His play down the stretch last season, when he started 20 of the team’s final 21 regular-season games, gave hope that maybe he found the right mindset. And after playing a bunch of playoff games over the past four springs, he appeared to have a relaxing summer, picking up a third ring and petting his giant dogs.
We’ll see if that all results in a Vezina-caliber season in 2019-20 for Murray, or if he again takes turns tantalizing and frustrating the Penguins and the fan base.
Who backs him up?
There will at least be a little intrigue with the battle to back up Murray.
DeSmith was critical in that role last season. He carried the load and probably saved the Penguins’ season while Murray regained his health and his form. He typically was solid when his starts again became sporadic. And he has the ideal makeup for a No. 2 in that he has no delusions about who’s the No. 1.
Tristan Jarry, meanwhile, is no longer a youngster and could be entering his last camp with the Penguins. He was a little better last season than his so-so American Hockey League numbers suggest. That young squad was far from stacked on the blue line, as they missed the playoffs for the first time since 2002.
His practice habits and in-game focus have improved. But there are concerns about how he would perform if he was only starting once every week or two.
Money might be a factor here. If the Penguins are to get Marcus Pettersson back in the fold without trading a player in a cost-cutting move, they will probably have to pinch some pennies. Jarry makes just under $600,000 less than DeSmith.
It is also worth noting that both goalies will be subject to waivers.
That magic number
OK, let’s say DeSmith, assuming it’s based strictly on stopping pucks, holds off Jarry to hang on to the gig. How many games should the No. 2 ideally start?
As noted earlier, the most starts that Murray has made in his young career is 50. In each of his three full seasons, he landed in the 45-to-50 range. The Penguins would surely like a healthy Murray to hit at least 55. But what’s too many? 60? 65?
Around the NHL, there has been a push to limit the loads of starting goalies. The Hurricanes and Islanders probably had a near 50/50 split last season because, no disrespect meant toward Robin Lehner, they didn’t have a bona fide stud.
The Bruins, meanwhile, are a more interesting comparable. Sensing that Tuukka Rask wore down from overuse in the past, they scaled back his starts and gave 37 to backup Jaroslav Halak. Rask responded with arguably the best postseason of his career, leading Boston to Game 7 of the Stanley Cup final.
Sure, Rask has several years on Murray. But it’s still something to keep in mind.
Down on the farm
The Penguins made a pair of noteworthy additions between the pipes, importing Emil Larmi from Finland and inking steady AHL veteran Dustin Tokarski.
Both guys helped their respective teams win championships this past season. And neither signed with visions of spending the season in the ECHL. So, depending on what happens with Jarry and DeSmith, there could be a logjam in WBS.
The Penguins definitely need to find regular work for Larmi, a 22-year-old who has a chance to become an NHLer if his game translates to our smaller rinks.
Larmi, whose sprawling style turned heads at June’s prospect development camp, will presumably start two of three games at this weekend’s Prospects Challenge. Alex D’Orio, a southpaw ticketed for Wheeling, would get a look in the other.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.