Hockey fans have probably had this debate a billion times with their buddies: What’s the best current rivalry in the NHL?
NBC Sports posed that question on Twitter Thursday night but framed it around two teams that some didn’t even realize were considered to be rivals.
Is this the best rivalry in hockey right now? pic.twitter.com/YRFX1FPadh
— NHL on NBC (@NHLonNBCSports) August 29, 2019
When it comes to hockey rivalries, the ones that usually come to mind first are Canadiens-Maple Leafs, Rangers-Islanders or even Blackhawks-Red Wings. Sharks and Golden Knights though? That’s a new one.
There was a vocal contingent that responded to NBC Sports by suggesting another rivalry is the best in hockey right now: Penguins and Capitals.
LOL.
— Church of Baseball ⚾ (@churchofbasebal) August 29, 2019
No, it's Caps-Pens.
It will always be Caps v Pens
— formerly burakovskyeet (@vranaenae) August 29, 2019
caps vs pens
— 🌫 (@iwillbutcheryou) August 30, 2019
pens vs flyers
habs vs bruins
hawks vs blues
devils vs rangers
isles vs rangers
sens vs success
all better rivalries
Pens/Caps, always.
— Lyndsay Petruny Bersuder (@LPetruny) August 29, 2019
As long as Crosby and Ovechkin are in the league it will always be Penguins-Capitals.
— Daniel 🦅 (@DanielDmanx123) August 29, 2019
For the record, the Sharks and Golden Knights have had some fierce battles over the past two seasons. They may have a legitimate rivalry that has a chance to grow into one of the best in hockey if both teams keep playing at such a high level.
But right now, it’s not better than the Penguins and Capitals, whose respectful disdain for each other goes even further back than the Crosby and Ovechkin eras.
Read More
"There were some knockdown, drag-out fights and battles," Penguins broadcaster Mike Lange said of the Penguins-Caps rivalry two years ago. "There had been an ongoing rivalry between those two teams since the early ’80s."
That includes some intense playoff matchups in the early ’90s, a few more in the last few years as the Penguins made their way to two Stanley Cup wins and, finally, the Capitals beating the Penguins in the postseason on their way to winning the franchise’s first championship.
It’s a rivalry that spans 225 games and had NBC Sports itself asking just last year, “Is Washington Capitals-Pittsburgh Penguins the best rivalry in the NHL today?”
No offense to the brewing Sharks-Golden Knights rivalry, but they’ve only played eight games against each other, mostly because the Knights have only been around for two seasons. Such a small sample size does not warrant labeling their rivalry the best in hockey.
It’s worth mentioning that NBC Sports has a habit of calling just about any NHL matchup between two teams a “rivalry.” It called the games it carried on its network “Wednesday Rivalry Night” up until last season when it rebranded to “Wednesday Night Hockey,” maybe after realizing how silly it was to call a midseason Oilers/Blues game a clash of rivals.
Regardless, whether or not the Penguins-Capitals rivalry is the best in hockey, it’s definitely better than Sharks-Golden Knights.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.