Jason Mackey: What's up everybody? Welcome to my weekly chat. Last one of the year. Leave your questions here. Gonna grab some lunch, and I'll be back to answer them at 1:15 p.m., after my weekly hit with Cook & Joe on the Fan.
Jason Mackey: Alright folks, let's do this ...
Ryan: Do you think Calen Addison will be NHL ready next year? And if so, who would need to be moved to make room for him?
Jason Mackey: I don't think he's going to be NHL ready for next season, so the second part is moot. I think they would like him to spend at least a season in the AHL refining his game.
Noah: Who is the most likely player to go this summer?
Jason Mackey: If I had to pick one, I'd say Phil.
Rick : The little Pens missed playoffs for first time in 17 years and still have no contact to renew in Wilkes-Barre. Did the organization neglect it’s farm team and are the little pens on the move?
Jason Mackey: I don't know they neglected their farm team, one. The NHL club takes priority, and the edict there is to win now; that often hurts the AHL team. As for a contract, I'm not in Wilkes-Barre, obviously, but I've heard nothing in Pittsburgh to indicate that the organization is looking to go in a different direction.
Jeff from south side: Jason great season chats. Thank you! Do you believe GMJR can actually turn the roster into what it needs to go deep into playoffs? Speed, youth & hungry gamers. With the cap as tight as it is?
Jason Mackey: Hi Jeff. I don't think cap space is a huge issue, honestly. Jim knows he needs to part with a few key pieces -- Phil, a defenseman, maybe more. If he can do that, he can actually open up a decent amount of cap space to do what he wants to. Does he make the right moves? You'd hope so, right? That's up in the air, but I think he will have the opportunity to do it.
Cole Wight: Hey Jason! Do you think the Pens will take a look at signing Skinner in Free Agency this year, also maybe bringing back Hagelin at a lower cap hit? Pens need to get back to that speed and skill game.
Jason Mackey: Hi Cole, given what Hagelin has accomplished and what he has done in Washington, I have a tough time seeing him as anything near affordable for the Penguins. Plus, he's not exactly young. My understand for the Penguins is they'd like to build around some young and hungry players. They're OK spending the money, but I don't think they want to do it for someone in their 30s.
Jason Mackey: And no, I can't imagine Skinner would be an option for them.
Carmen: When GMJR states that some players are satisfied with their cups and no longer have the hunger for another, who do you think he is speaking about?
Jason Mackey: My interpretation of that was Malkin, Kessel and Letang. Eleven two-time Cup winners. Can't imagine he's talking about guys in their 20s, plus you can't tell me that Olli Maatta is complacency and that cost the Penguins.
Jeff from south side: Since wilkes-Barre is so depleted of talent. Missing calder cup playoffs for first time in 17 years. Can you see Big Jim seeking picks for whoever he may deal or do you think the win now get all the help you can to win now is still in play??
Jason Mackey: With what Jim is peddling -- meaning Phil -- I think the victory is going to be opening the cap space, not necessarily the return. Have been told already by a couple people that it's gonna be tough to move Phil. I think Jim can do it, but I would temper your expectations relative to a return. I think Jim would like to restock some, but he also has to be realistic when it comes to what people are willing to give up.
Frank Black: All the talk about Malkin being a turnover machine, why didn’t anyone mention Sid had the worst +/-, of the postseason. Since many in the local media used the +/- metric against Geno during the regular season (and they were correct), why not bring this up for Mr Selke?
Jason Mackey: Because I think plus/minus is garbage when applied to such a small sample size. Over the course of a full season, it says a lot more about a player.
Josh: Why do reporters not ask Jack Johnson about his mistakes? Does it have to do with Rutherford being so defensive about him?
Jason Mackey: If you're talking about yesterday for locker cleanout, he was not available.
Jeff from south side: Since penguins have their own 1st round pick for the 1st time in what seems a decade who could you See GMJR targeting? Forward, Defense or Netminder??
Jason Mackey: They need talent, period. I see Rutherford going best player available.
Jeff from south side: Could you actually see them parting with Letang?? He wont fetch much id assume. With his age, salary & injury history what could he realistically expect in return??
Jason Mackey: It depends on whether he's willing to adapt and play less "high-risk." The coach and GM used that term a lot yesterday, and I think they did it for a reason. Letang doesn't need to be safe as death or anything like that, but he needs to pick his spots better. If he's unwilling to do that, then I think they would consider it. But to answer your question, no, I don't think it's likely that Letang gets traded this summer.
Casey: Is there any credence to Sully getting too comfortable with his players? I remember him coming in hot, barking at every player that looked at a ref the wrong way, getting in every player's face (star or not) if they weren't sticking to the system. I do suppose it's natural to want to trust them - I mean, they won two Cups together - but do you think we'll see him double-down on accountability this upcoming year? Too often this team just didn't look like a team.
Jason Mackey: You can criticize plenty with Sullivan -- the Simon thing, constant shuffling, a message that didn't seem to get through in the postseason -- but I would really have to disagree with him getting too comfortable. Sullivan is not comfortable with anything, trust me. He's not a player's coach. If anything, he might be on the harsh side of things. ... As for the bench thing, I do think he could tighten some of that up, but it's also incumbent on players to sooner or later just zip it.
Kenny Bania: Do you know if the Pens plan to re-sign Ethan Prow? He's a Group 6 UFA this summer, but finally had a breakthrough season. He's also their only in-house option on defense and a coveted righty.
Jason Mackey: I have a tough time seeing them allow Prow to get away after the season he just had.
Mark Downsyn: What did you have for lunch?
Jason Mackey: Ramen noodles. Fancy, I know.
Guest: Are you surprised the season ended the way it did?
Jason Mackey: I am. I thought they would at least make it to the second round and play the Capitals. Did not see this coming at all.
BigAl: Are you going anywhere on vacation? Will you bring extra underwear?
Jason Mackey: We're going to take several small trips, plus one big one that's still TBD. Thinking either Aspen, Colo. or Virginia Beach, Va. Small ones will likely be to Buffalo, Columbus, D.C. and Detroit -- my favorite drivable road cities.
Gus: After the Pens abysmal playoff performance and Rutherford saying "changes" will be made, who do you see the Pens dealing and who will the Pens get in return? I would be interested in seeing 71 traded if the market is right - get a nice package for him. Tired of the lazy play over the years and the idiotic penalties. I know 99% of Pens fans will argue with me on this one, but I don't let infatuation with a player override reason. Just because he is "Geno" doesn't mean he shouldn't be moved. If he isn't producing on offense, he isn't doing anything. Doesn't kill penalties, doesn't back check much, etc.
Jason Mackey: I see them moving Phil and a defenseman. I'm not expecting them to do anything with Geno. It's always been my understand that they want him to retire as a Penguin, and I don't think this season -- bad as it was -- changes that. Does he need to play a little more responsible game? Yeah, I think that's fair. But I don't think trading him sends the right message. It's reactionary.
Dan Mucy: Hi Jason! I'm depressed enough as is...the way the season ended was brutal. I will, however, look forward to your work for what promises to be a VERY entertaining summer! OK...is there enough cap flexibility to fix this team through trades? Also, Letang's defiance shouts an awful lot about the core issue with this team: rigidity. Keep up the good work, my friend! Dan
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Dan. Will certainly be a busy one. And long. But fun. There's plenty of cap flexibility, in my opinion. If GMJR moves, say, Phil and Olli, that's basically $11 million they can play with.
Mountain Jack: The early exit hit me hard. Nothing will ever be the same
Jason Mackey: Don't wanna get all philosophical here, but nothing is ever really the same. It's always changing.
Jace: Men love him, women love him, kids love him. Why don't you love Mark Madden?
Jason Mackey: I do like Mark. He's a friend.
Truth: you need to get off the Fan, it's 2nd rate all the way
Jason Mackey: I love those guys, and I disagree. They do a great job. And did you really just log into this chat to say something insulting about a radio station?
Kenny Bania: What's going on with the Baby Pens? Could they move from WBS, or could the Penguins have a different farm team next season?
Jason Mackey: Man, why is this such a hot topic today? Did I miss something/
Don Crook: The Pens can't turn into the Blackhawks or Kings...can they?
Jason Mackey: No.
Dan: One of the things I’ve noticed throughout the year are the amount of coaches that aren’t hesitant to put young players in the lineup....and actually play them. Do you think MS will change his philosophy next year and trust them ? Also do you anticipate any staff changes ?
Jason Mackey: I could see a staff change or two. Wouldn't be surprised is someone wants Jacques Martin for a head coaching job, but I don't think they're going to look to fire guys. ... As for trusting young players, I think Sullivan will play Blueger, but other than that, the Penguins don't have a ton of young guys to trust for next season.
Lil Dippy Eggs: I feel like March lead to a tumble for the Pens. How and where did things go awry?
Jason Mackey: *Led ... If you're gonna troll my stories, at least do it right.
Christian: Hi Jason, GMJR said he wonders "if too many players on this roster have become too content" GMJR traded Hagelin last fall to give this team a so called "wake up call." It didn't look like the players received the message during the days & weeks that followed based on how they played. If your Sully & GMJR what do you do besides trading popular locker room players away to make sure your players don't become too content next year? You can't trade everyone.
Jason Mackey: They actually did respond to the Hagelin trade; they went 16-6-3 in the next 25. I think if you trade the right guy(s) it'll get players' attention. Someone like Phil will do the trick. They like him, but his game doesn't exactly scream effort. I would imagine -- as I've been saying -- that a defensemen is also likely to go for cap reasons.
Mike H: Do you think losing Rick Tocchet as a coach has hurt this team?
Jason Mackey: Yes. Because he was and remains a very good and well-liked coach. But I don't think they're 1-2 in playoff series because Tocchet left.
Christian: GMJR has made a move or two where you can say it backfired on him based upon emotion (Hagelin). Should we be concerned that GMJR makes moves this summer out of emotion and anger? And what if there's not much of a market for 81 & 72? You can't make a move to make a move.
Jason Mackey: I don't think the Hagelin move was "emotion." I think it was more trying to get his team's attention -- I do believe they're different -- and it actually worked some (see above). I don't see this summer being about emotion. They just got hammered by the Islanders. If they have that happen and do nothing, that's equally as dumb.
Guest: So funny thing here. Derick brassard is still in the playoffs and we’re out...
Jason Mackey: I noticed that. Kinda wild. Ian Cole, too. Can't say it's for anything Brassard has done especially well, though.
GSMP: Kris Letang's comments about not changing his game seems to contradict Mike Sullivan's comment about not being high risk and playing disciplined. How does the team reconcile these seemingly contradictory views?
Jason Mackey: I don't know, honestly. I don't think they know. My best guess is this: You need to sit Letang down and talk to him about what you want. It isn't changing his entire game but about picking his spots better. I think Letang would be OK. He would have to be, or else you move him.
Long John: Who are you rooting for in the playoffs now that the Pgh hockey club consisting of flightless birds are done?
Jason Mackey: I'm all in on Columbus. And Carolina to beat Washington.
Joe: Who do you believe is likely to go this off season.
Jason Mackey: I think Kessel and a defenseman, likely Maatta.
Christian: Jason, it was reported by another media outlet in town that there was a sense of entitlement and arrogance that has seeped into the locker room since going back to back. Even amongst the teams support staff. Have you picked up on this and if you have which players do you think have become entitled?
Jason Mackey: Please link the report, but honestly, that's pretty much what Rutherford said on the record yesterday. Some of these guys have gotten too comfortable.
Tim in the Barn: Hockey coaches have a short shelf life. How difficult is it for Sully to go to guys and have them change things that have worked so well in the past?
Jason Mackey: He could start by showing them tape of the Islanders series and how things are gonna go if they do their things their own way.
Bobby: Hi Jason, Some of our core players rely on training camp alone to prepare for the season. That is not nearly enough considering their age.Malkin spend all summer on Instagram then" I had a bad season" .Kessel plays poker every other night then cannot score on empty net anymore. They cannot rely on pure talent anymore .Can the organization do something about it after all they get paid millions of dollars?
Jason Mackey: Do you really think, in 2019, that these guys don't train? They train year round. Malkin started skating earlier this summer than he ever has in his career. They didn't get beat because they weren't in shape. They got beat because they refused to change. That has nothing to do with the offseason.
Jear Bear: Everyone wants to have change but no one wants to get rid of a big name player
Jason Mackey: Fair point. Gotta give to get.
GSMP: I think the Penguins should field offers for Malkin. He's 32 and his production was down both in the regular season and the playoffs. His value will likely continue to drop. Acquiring younger talent and freeing up cap space would be worth it.
Jason Mackey: I disagree. I think it sends the wrong message. He deserves to have a bad season and not get shipped out of town for it.
What gives?: I get that in this day and age that athletes are more entitled and call the shots due to salary....but what are we to make of Letang vowing not to alter his high-risk style of play? He was brutal in the NYI series and 2 of his gaffs directly led to defeat...and this was after a couple yr history of bad decisions. What recourse does a coach have? Bench him and stars don’t get the puck on breakout. Allow this to continue and it serves to demoralize. There must be Buy-in or trade,
Jason Mackey: I agree with you, one. But I think Letang took my question more to mean his overall game. I think what the Penguins are going to want him to do is change his game during select times, to pick his spots better. We don't know whether he's willing to do that or not.
MA: Seeing a lot of players in Sid and Geno’s “generation” seemingly not able to keep up with the game anymore (ie James Neal being a healthy scratch tonight, Marc Edward Valsic being a dead weight for SJ) I know Sid and Geno are generational talents but at what point do the Pens have to stop and reanalyze who they are building the team around ? Not saying they should get rid of them bc that’s insane but to avoid a Kings and Blackhawks situation it seems like the Pens need to stop holding on to what’s worked in the past.
Jason Mackey: I hear what you're saying, but I think you can also do it by providing the right complimentary pieces. Also, we're suddenly lumping Sid in with this line of thinking because he had four bad playoff games. Before it, he had 100 points and one of the best two-way seasons of his career. Don't let recency cloud your way. But the both of them could use some help, that's for sure.
Guest: Two part question: How much input does the team have if a player wants to go play at Worlds? From SM it looks like Geno might go?
Jason Mackey: Please link the report. Assuming you mean Slava Malamud? Have not seen anything to that effect. It's usually cooperative and not contentious. If the player wants to play, he's usually allowed.
penfan: Disappointing season, should the fans still have faith in the GM 's decisions on trades? Maybe it was a bad time to ask but Phil and Kris seemed not to really care about the losses. Did you get that feeling?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. I think they absolutely cared. I think Letang cares a lot, especially, getting pretty pissed off during his scrum yesterday. And yeah, I would have faith in Jim's trades. He brought in McCann, Bjugstad, Pettersson and Gudbranson. Those didn't suck.
Guest: 2: Did we get any feedback about how healthy Geno actually is?
Jason Mackey: We did not. He didn't talk yesterday.
scott: Are the players still listening to Sullivan? watching it on TV it seemed really easy to see what was going on strategy wise, why couldn't the manager communicate with the players?
Your Man: I just got done with the footage on the tape, must've thrown up everything i ever ate
Jason Mackey: Don't eat before you re-watch the playoff series.
scott: Also you wrote this is the last chat of the year? did you mean season and you will have them again once September gets here?
Jason Mackey: I'll have one around the draft or if any news breaks.
What gives?: What should we do in regards to Letang vow not to change style of play. His decision making and high risk plays directly led to 2 defeats in NYI series and this after a few yrs of rumbles concerning this. Do we trade at low value and risk D not getting pucks to stars early and quickly on breakouts, or continue to witness this and see how it demoralizes and empowers others into similar play? You would think respect for coach would necessitate adherence, but maybe not in entitled-Star-athlete era.
Jason Mackey: I think they need to have a talk with Letang -- not about changing his entire game but about picking his spots better. My hope would be that he responds to this because he wants to win.
RandomHockeyGuy: Maybe I missed it, but did anyone ever ask Sullivan why Jack Johnson, who dressed for all 82 games, was a scratch for Game 1? If yes, did we get an answer besides dressing the best roster we feel could win the game? Or did we phone Columbus and ask them why we sat him? Not saying the decision was right or wrong, but it sure looked odd that a guy plays all 82 games and suddenly becomes a healthy scratch.
Jason Mackey: He was asked about the game and didn't answer the question. He just said it was a tough decision, which I'm sure it was.
CarlRoss: Hey Jason, appreciated your coverage all year. Any more insight on why Hagelin got away like he did? How does a GM not know the roster rules? I think he would have been a significant factor vs. the Islanders. Are there any others that might be available next year who play like he does? Go Pens!!
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Carl. It is a little confounding that they did not know. Honestly, I didn't know, but I'm not a GM/assistant GM for a hockey team. I also think the Penguins never in a million years thought they'd have a chance to get Hagelin back. But saying he would've been the X-factor against the Islanders or something like that, I have to disagree there.
Mike: Hello Jason!!! Just a couple questions. Do you believe Rutherford will be on the hot seat with Guerin being highly coveted if he makes the wrong off season moves with trades and or free agents? Also, if a trade were to happen of kessel or LeTang could we see it at the draft? One more what players will be free agents that the pens can covet this year with speed?
Jason Mackey: Hi Mike. I don't see Jim being on the hot seat, and when he does step down, I'm not sure it would be Guerin replacing him. Yes, the draft would be likely for Phil. I don't think it would be for Letang, and I don't think they would want to move Letang. Next year? Micheal Ferland still interests me. Maybe Ryan Dzingel. Zucc from the Rangers would be appealing, too.
Bwent N Billy: We believe it is time to explore trading Malkin. He was a -25 this season and clearly looks to be on the decline. It may sting, but if the pens can get some younger speedier players in return and lose that 9 million plus in salary, then it makes sense. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I disagree. I think the message is too reactionary.
MA: From what GMJR said he doesn’t seem to get that there is a speed problem with this team, specifically the D, I know it’s possible he’s putting up a front in front of the press but at what point would Morehouse or Mario step in?
Jason Mackey: I don't think we're there yet. They still made the playoffs. I think Jim is a little emotional because this is still fresh. I don't think it's anything more than that, and I can't say I blame him.
Just Bwent: Do the pens still have confidence in Murray? He let in some soft goals in the playoffs while not being screened. Those 2 goals he got beat short side twice in a game is unbelievable! Hug the posts like they teach in youth hockey!!!!
Jason Mackey: Yes, they have confidence in him. He was their best player down the stretch, and he'll likely get an extension this summer.
Pope: Any chance the pens look TK being back Hagelin for a 2-year deal? They need the speed.
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. He'll make too much, and they want to get younger.
FMatter: Over/under on Phil coming back?
Jason Mackey: I don't know how to put an over/under on anything, but it's unlikely he's coming back.
Huggy: Is Maata all but gone?
Jason Mackey: Would imagine so. If someone wants Jack, maybe Olli stays. I don't see that happening.
Kaspara1t1s: Player A: 1 goal, 12 assists, -4 rating, 41 PIM, 19:17 average TOI, 14 TK/32 GV, -5.6 EV RelCorsi in 82 games. $3.25 AAV, 32 years old.
Player B: 3 goals, 9 assists, -1 rating, 30 PIM, 17:10 average TOI, 19 TK/39 GV, +2.9 EV RelCorsi in 62 games. $1.1 AAV, 25 years old.
Jason Mackey: What a strangely worded question.
Rene Corbet : Do you think there might be a shakeup in the coaching staff?
Jason Mackey: Only if Jacques Martin leaves for a head coaching gig.
Rick Haverland : Your thoughts on new blood within the GM position? Obviously some player movement is needed. I believe in Coach Sullivan still. Where are you at in all of this understanding that the wounds are still fresh???
Jason Mackey: Rutherford isn't going anywhere, if that's what you're asking.
BIG Deal RD: Is it time to cut bait w Murray? I understand the business decison due to his youth of keeping him over Fleury, but he hasn't been right since Fleury left. Hopefully the pens don't sign him to a long term deal this summer. Make him earn it and play well for an entire season and the subsequent playoffs.
Jason Mackey: He's their franchise guy and played extremely well down the stretch. You don't make the guy who helped win two Cups go into a contract year without a contract, when an injury could change so much. They'll extend him. He deserves it, too.
Kaspara1t1s: This was meant to follow what I just typed, but player A is of course Jack Johnson and B is Derrick Pouliot. There’s a dissonance that allows the organization, the fans, the media (not saying you necessarily) to find A better than B. Pouliot was certainly not without his problems, but he enabled offensive play and JJ chokes the life out of it whenever possible. Obviously taking too many gambles hurt the Pens this postseason, but one has to think that management realizes that JJ has been an anchor. Do you believe they feel that way?
Karp: Too bad the Pens didn't have Ian Moran for these playoffs. They could have used his enthusiasm, right?!?! The Pens looked like they were thinking about hitting the golf course instead of playing playoff hockey. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. And one of reasons I think that is because they like some of the unquantifiable (or not perfectly quantifiable) things that JJ brings: physical, net-front, PK, etc. You can disagree on whether these things are valuable and probably do. But the organization really likes Jack -- or at least everything we hear says they do anyway -- and I have a tough time seeing him traded.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, definitely. Ian Moran would've fixed everything.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason, I just heard Phil Bourque with S. Savran, Just say the only emphatic way to get a message across to a player is to take playing time away. He cited Boston sitting Pastrnak down in the 1st period against Toronto to send a message. Sullivan hardly ever/never sent such messages to Kessel, Malkin, Letang, etc whenever players didn’t play the “right way” or we’re going thru the motions. As a result, the same crap happened thru out the season/playoffs (SHGs, ill timed pinching, etc.). If Sullivan doesn’t instill greater discipline & accountability then this team is doomed to the same results. Other than trading all the offenders which won’t happen, then the coach & GM need to stop worrying about hurting Letang, Malkin, Kessel’s feelings. I’m interested in your thought because you regularly defended not sitting these guys down.
Jason Mackey: I believe it was brought to me as in benching them for games or healthy scratching them or something like that, but if you're going to ding a guy's ice time for doing stupid stuff, I'm absolutely all for that. I'm also not about to disagree with Bourque.
Dr. Jungy Brogan: It’s not spelled out directly in this article from Gretz (https://nhl.nbcsports.com/2019/04/17/penguins-playoff-exit-was-two-yea...), but one can draw the assumption that since winning the ‘17 Cup, GMJR has been one of the game’s worst GMs. Would you agree with that sentiment, solely looking at the past 700 days or so?
Jason Mackey: I know. I wrote basically the same piece as Adam. I think a lot of us did: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2019/04/18/For-Penguins-f...
C Man: So do the pens trade Malkin, Kessel and Letang to get a lot of younger speedier prospects? If not all 3, which 2 are most likely? It's time.
Jason Mackey: Why do we have to pick two? I would trade Phil and talk to the other two.
Guest: If you were the GM, who would you trade and what would you look to bring in?
Jason Mackey: I would trade Phil. I think Micheal Ferland would be an interesting add. I think they need to get a little tougher, a little younger and a little more structured. Ferland helps with those first two things, for sure.
Guest: Why do you think sully didn’t stick with McCann on Sid’s line? They seemed to play really well. There have been some reports that McCann has had an attitude problem in the past, that’s not something we’ve seen but could it have been a personality issue or is it just Sullys ever changing lines issue?
Jason Mackey: McCann is the complete opposite of an attitude problem here, trust me. I can't speak for how he was at other places, but he is about the nicest person you'll ever meet. I think Sully got away from it because he likes the idea of Rust's speed there and also Simon.
Guest: So sad the season is over . I saw your comment you made to ponie which he tweeted that after game 3 you thought that some players were ready for the golf course. As a fan that is really really upsetting . Who do you think was checked out after game 3?
Jason Mackey: It just seemed like as a whole there wasn't enough want-to. They seemed down. I'm not going to single guys out.
Mattis: Schultz or Letang? I think the pens should keep Schultz over Letang based on Tanger's "attitude" about not playing more responsible on the blue line.
Jason Mackey: You're assuming, one, they could trade Letang. Having them both also gives the Penguins a huge advantage and helps their forwards. But they need to get Letang to rein it in during important times.
Kevin: Why is Phil Kessel's name at the forefront when guys like Johnson, Hornqvist, Maatta, Gudbranson, etc. are all guys who, although they make less money, don't bring nearly as much bang for their buck?
Jason Mackey: Because other teams aren't stupid. Just because you say you're gonna trade a guy doesn't automatically give you a taker.
PM: I feel like everyone is taking the whole "changes are coming" thing way out of proportion by saying guys like Malkin and Letting will be dealt. Can you actually see either of these guys getting moved?
Jason Mackey: Very unlikely. I think it'll be Phil and a defenseman.
Kevin: Isn't it alarming that GMJR thinks this is the best defence he has had since coming here? I just don't see what he sees
Jason Mackey: Yes, it is. I don't see it either. The defense on other teams won Cups. This team couldn't win a playoff game. It's not better.
Anaheim’s #11: Since 2006, the Pens have just two of their top-round (1st and 2nd rd) picks left on the NHL roster, Blueger and Määttä, and the latter may be on the way out. Can you think of any other teams that built champions without adequately retaining or growing top talent?
Jason Mackey: Not off-hand, but a couple things ... they have had a ton of luck in the third round (Rust, Guentzel and Murray) and they've built around the same core, which is before the window you're creating.
Guest: Is it dangerous that a NHL GM seems to have become disconnected to the reality of his team? Best defense since GMJR has been here?? The team this year was: The Penguins this season by the way were:
26th in the NHL in total shots allowed (33.3 per game)
29th in total 5v5 Corsi events allowed
25th in total 5v5 Fenwick events allowed
16th in total 5v5 scoring chances allowed
17th in 5v5 high danger scoring chances allowed
Jason Mackey: I don't think this year's group is awful, but I can't put it ahead of the Cup-winning teams.
Kevin: Is there any possibility of GMJR being transitioned into a different role in the organization and having someone else assume the GM position?
Jason Mackey: No. You're overreacting, Kevin.
PM: By retooling, do you think the Pens are heading towards getting players for similar value (similar age, points, etc) or trading guys for younger pieces who can develop (kind of like MIN did with Donato and Fiala)?
Jason Mackey: I think you're gonna see a couple things here. One, trades to create cap space. Then some spending on players who will get the Penguins younger -- guys who may have produced some but will be getting a much better opportunity in Pittsburgh.
Steeler Joe: The most baffling thing for me was the seeming lack of life in this team throughout the season and into the postseason. There just seemed to be a gloom over them. Is it possible that all the roster moves and all the line juggling has just left the team befuddled? Without chemistry?
Jason Mackey: I think that's reasonable. It just wasn't the right mix. You can sense that early on.
Kim: Hi Jason! Who are the most likely candidates to be the Penguins' seventh defenseman next season?
Jason Mackey: I could see them retaining Zach Trotman ... although he's probably more of an eight for them. Maybe Riikola or Jack, too.
PM: What's your view on JJ's future? Still in Pens top 7 next season, traded in offseason, bought out or AHL roster?
Jason Mackey: Based on GMJR's public comments, I think he's still in Pittsburgh.
Guest: Jason, what’s your approach to when an athlete responds aggressively/defensively to a question you ask? Like your question to Letang (which I believe he took the wrong way). I know you want to de-escalate the situation, but I’m sure you want to stand firm with your journalistic integrity and stay with the question you asked. Hard balance
Jason Mackey: It's not hard at all. If I'm asking a question professionally and not in a showy way and articulating myself ... if someone gets mad, that's their problem. That's what we signed up for. My biggest worry is always being respectful and asking things in a way that makes sense, not that someone gets mad.
Mark: What is the Pens’ biggest need at the forward position for next season?
Jason Mackey: Someone at left wing who can skate and score some goals.
Steeler Joe: Serious question: With Malkin, could a new baby have an impact on his play this year? I have to think players' personal lives have more to do with their performance than we're wiling to acknowledge sometimes. I think AB's blowup is largely driven by chaos in his personal life ... but that's a little off topic.
Jason Mackey: Ha. Previously the narrative was that being a father has helped Malkin -- that was when he had a good year last year. Poor Nikita. Already being attached to his dad's up-and-down nature.
Guest: I put half the blame for this season on JR and MS. Rutherford made too many trades including the very stupid trade of Hagelin . He was your fastest player and your coach likes speed and I think it hurt the locker room . I also think malkin’s play declined after he left . Sullivan’s constant line shuffling is disruptive and his decision to bench Johnson the first playoff game was bad and sent a bad message to the team .
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree with you. I think the Hagelin trade was a miss, although I understand why Jim did it. Sullivan showed a lack of patience sometimes, then he was stubborn to change with others. But the players are the ones playing the games, and they got outplayed.
PM: Do you think Hornqvist has a movable contract? I think he's an extremely serviceable guy, but at $5.3M a year for 4 more years for a guy who's 32... If they do decide to move him, do you think Penguins would have to take somewhat of a less favourable contract for maybe 2 remaining seasons in order to move him, or you think he has value to move on his own?
Jason Mackey: I don't think that's a movable contract. For the reasons you mentioned and also because of the concussions.
JC: Hello Jason as always thank you for doing this chat. So who do you think GMJR is thinking of moving because they are not hungry anymore? Will they try to acquire more youth or slightly older?
Jason Mackey: I think he will consider moving Phil, and yes, I think they will try to get younger.
Mark: Also, if Phil is most likely to get moved, what would you consider to be a fair return?
Jason Mackey: Anything that opens up that cap space.
BVALEPS25: This is all on Rutherford.
Jason Mackey: And Jack Johnson.
BVALEPS25: It’s his fault Phil is playing is last game with the Pens because we decided to g bigger instead of faster
Jason Mackey: Ha. I think we're skipping a few steps in here.
ANDYFROMBVA: You think the Pens could resign Hagelin????
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. He's gonna want too much.
C.R. : Thanks for the great coverage and the asking of tough questions to temperamental French Canadiens, Jason! Any insight on how the heck we let Hagelin go? What was the deal here? Speed, experience, always flying around the creases—might have changed the Trotzian game plan. Any chance we get somebody like him—maybe get him back? I think he would have helped greatly against that team from Long Island.
Jason Mackey: Man, you guys love Hagelin. The thinking was that the Penguins were playing like crap. GMJR knew he had to do something. Hagelin was on an expiring contract, wasn't doing much, and the Penguins knew they couldn't re-sign him. I don't see how they could get him back, although I'm pretty sure if they did, they would immediately have to erect a bronze statue of him outside of PPG Paints Arena.
Syl Apps: Just a different way of looking at things, but the last 2 years helps me to realize how special the back to back cups were. The '16 team needs to be appreciated as one of the best Stanley Cup winners in the last 20 years. The '17 team was pure grit and will. We are really so fortunate. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I agree. I think people are quick to realize what this franchise has done. A lot of first-world grievances being aired today.
Guest: To you agree with Rutherford’s assessment that the team is not close ? If so what do you attribute that to? Old players verses young players ?
Jason Mackey: I don't think it's the right mix of players. You need glue guys -- goofy, great personalities, keep things loose, etc. They don't have one of those, and you probably need a couple. That's on Jim. Also, the head coach runs kind of a tight ship. If I was playing for him, I would like to see him loosen the heck up every once in a while. It's a game. It should be fun.
Guest: If you could guess, which players won’t be penguins come October?
Jason Mackey: Phil and Maatta ... two points.
Karp & Mattis: The cupboard is bare in Wilkes-Barre. Time to trade Malkin and Letang and stock up on picks and prospects. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Why stop there? If the AHL team is hurting, you gotta do whatever you can to fix that, right? Send Sid down right away.
Guest: Seems like teams that succeed deep into the post season have almost a tandem like netminder set up 1A - 1B. I know the pens seem satisfied with Desmiths play but he isn’t a 1B goalie. Do you think they look to get a better back up, maybe someone that can provide Murray with some veteran back up and can be trusted in do or die situations( the way sully played Murray at the end of the season he didn’t seem like he could trust Desmith to win a game for the Pens with a sloppy team in front of him)
Jason Mackey: No, I don't think that's anything they're considering whatsoever. They want Murray to be their guy, and I think he can be their guy.
John: Jim has spent a ton of time over the past year or two talking about every intangible imaginable. Yesterday he discussed players being content, the team not being tighknit, and even threw a "push back" mention in there. Does he see talent and depth of talent as an issue? at all? They ice several players, particularly defensemen that just don't have the ability. I'd argue they were a tighknit group because they won, not the other way around. I'm terrified they are going to ship out even more talent for lesser players.
Jason Mackey: I don't know what you're asking, John. Do you think the Penguins don't have enough talent? They have more than enough talent. That talent has underperformed a lot lately, but they're not lacking talent.
Steeler Joe: Did we seriously underestimate the impact of the loss of Rick Tocchet behind the bench?
Jason Mackey: Tocchet is tremendous, but I don't think he lost the playoff series. He's a good coach. You move on.
Sheri: What do you think about the inconsistency with Murray all season?
Jason Mackey: I thought Murray was among the best goalies in the NHL since Dec. 15, which he was.
John: How would they justify trading Phil for cap purposes, when they pay their bottom two unskilled defensemen 7.25? It seems completely backward and reductive.
Jason Mackey: Because they would send a message, one, a message that probably needs to be sent at this point. You're also assuming there's a market for Johnson and Gudbranson, and moving Kessel would free up cap space.
Josh: Why do you think it will be Phil that gets moved? Is there evidence that's what JR wants to do or is it because writers think he should be?
Jason Mackey: There's evidence that Jim has listened the past two summers. It would also be easier to trade Phil than Malkin or Letang.
Harold: Jason, thanks for doing this all season. While Matt Cullen is a true soldier, I am hoping, regardless of whether he retires, that the Pens move Teddy Blueger into the lineup next season on a full time basis. Blueger is defensively responsible and looks like he has some good offensive upside potential.
Jason Mackey: I think that's extremely likely to happen. Yes, regardless of what Cullen decides.
Rick : Did the team really miss tochet ?
Jason Mackey: This is a convenient truth. Tocc is a great coach, but we're talking about something that happened before the 2017-18 season. C'mon guys and girls.
PM: Earlier in this chat, you said people have told you moving Phil will be difficult.. why is that? A PPG player making $6.8M for 3 more years seems very reasonable, no?
Jason Mackey: I agree. I wouldn't think it would be hard. Just relaying what I was told. Perhaps because of his no-movement clause.
sjsquire: What about cutting Jack Johnson? Doesn't seem worth the money.
Jason Mackey: You can't cut players in the NHL. It's not the NFL. You can cut 'em, but you still have to pay 'em.
Guest: The pens haven’t been able to replace what Nick Bonino brought to the team. Do you given time Nick Bjugstad could finally fill that spot?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. If Bjugstad can use his size a little bit more, I think they definitely might have something there.
PM: Do you see any suitors for Jarry around the league? Pens planning on moving him or keeping him as #3 in case of injuries?
Jason Mackey: He's on a one-way. I think someone will want him.
Jack: Do you think Jim tries to do a quick rebuild and take a chance at missing the playoffs or does he keep the team fairly the same but adds a few players to say the bottom 6 and D? I’d like to see a quick rebuild even though that might put the playoff streak on the line with some of these teams behind them getting better..
Jason Mackey: I don't think the on-the-fly rebuild will be too deep. They don't want to miss the playoffs. And to be fair, I don't think it's necessary to raze the whole thing.
Guest: Jason what type of return would you expect by trading Phil? Thanks.
Jason Mackey: Nothing too terribly big. A late-round pick or prospect or both.
Harold: Has GMJR been given too much of a pass on how he has tied up so much cap space on certain players? The 5-year deal of 72 looks pretty bad already, 17 looks overpaid based upon performance, 73 looks expensive, etc.
Jason Mackey: Rust almost scored 20. I'm OK paying $3.5 million for that. Hornqvist wouldn't look bad if not for the concussion issues, but if you didn't say it was a problem when it happened, then it's hindsight being 20/20 to say it's a problem now.
CR: Hi Jason, thanks for the great coverage this year; asking the tough questions when they are needed. Old news, but how and why did we let Hagelin go? Was this a GM blunder? I think he would have made a big difference overall. Who is available that might be able to replace him? ( Tough to find that chemistry I believe he had with the team.)
Jason Mackey: Thanks, CR. Got this earlier. They traded Hagelin because they needed to send a message, he was on an expiring contract, and they didn't think they could re-sign him. I don't think it was a blunder, even though I think they missed him. I think they could get Ferland from Carolina, and it might make sense for them.
Daniel: What do you think say a Phil or Maatta could fetch on the open market? Might be too early but wanted to hear what you thought
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it's too early Daniel. Sorry. And also, it's tough to say anything definitely because it depends on what teams are willing to pay. I think they would be OK just opening up the cap space for Phil.
Guest: I know hindsight is easy but I wish we would have played caps . Even if we lost it would have been good hockey . The Games against ny was like watching paint dry . If others teams copy their style the league is in trouble it will be too boring
Jason Mackey: Hindsight being 20/20 should be the slogan for this chat.
Rick : Because little pens have no contract current one is up in June and if you follow both teams it seems like they didn’t put much into growing talent
Jason Mackey: They're trying to win now at the NHL level. That usually deprives the AHL club.
Hornqvist Fan: Jason just a note to say thanks for a terrific season of Penguin chats. Always looked forward to them. When would you likely re-start these chats?
Jason Mackey: Probably around the draft ... or if news breaks.
Guest: Is there enough players available out there in free agency to help this team ?
Jason Mackey: Yes. And the fans want the Penguins to trade for all of them.
Steeler Joe: Not necessarily for publication--big fan, and your chats are always egalitarian and thorough, and you're candid. I really appreciate that as a reader. Just wanted to tell you that.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Joe. Appreciate that.
Guest: Do you think coach and gm are in the same page ? There seems to be a lot of building evidence to say they are not
Jason Mackey: I think they are now, but I don't think they were in the past. How else to explain the Reaves thing, right?
Tim: Seems Columbus was right about Johnson being he was scratched the first game. GMJR was pretty defensive when Torts said something after the signing.
Jason Mackey: Torts didn't say anything about Johnson. He criticized Rutherford for speaking out of turn.
Guest: Did each player meet with mgmt before they left town ? Or does that happen later this summer ?
Jason Mackey: Yes, they did.
pens58: Is it possible for a Ryan Reeves reunion?
Jason Mackey: No way.
Tim: Why do hockey coaches not last long? They seems to just go to another team. Other sports aren’t that way as much.
Jason Mackey: Because hockey players will just stop listening. Or that's the perception. And the NHL notoriously has a very quick hook with its coaches. It's crazy.
Guest: I think making the playoffs is going to be tough next year . Metro is getting tougher and pens getting older
Jason Mackey: Agree with that. It's a very good division.
Normie: From reading a few recent articles on the Pens, it seems like Sullivan and Rutherford are not on the same page as far as team make up. Sullivan wants speed and puck movers across the board. Rutherford favors bigger more physical - albeit slower - defense man. Is is this true or am I misinterpreting what I read?
Jason Mackey: I think you're mis-interpreting. I think they both want puck-movers on defense. I think their may be a problem admitting that they don't have that. And in the past I think they had some differences in opinion. They sound pretty united, though, in being pissed about the Islanders series loss.
Josh: How is Sid's 100 point season impressive enough to build around but Phil's 82 point season says he needs to be traded? I don't understand.
Jason Mackey: It's not trading based on who played well and who didn't. There are a bunch more factors. Like being the captain for one, and also when that contract runs out, whether you would sign someone again, marketability to other teams, attitude, a bunch of stuff.
Guest: So who’s winning the cup now that Tampa (incredibly shocking) and the pens are out? I’m going with Colorado.
Jason Mackey: I had Tampa and the Penguins making it to the second round. Not sure you wanna listen to me right now.
Guest: I am shocked no Selke nom for Crosby . What does he have to do ? Strap on the goalie pads ??
Jason Mackey: Just a guess, but I think that might put him in another category.
Guest: JR sounded defensive and completely arrogant in his press conference. Sid, Geno etc didn’t turn into different people and stop caring about winning Cups. Players weren’t playing too content, they just didn’t have the help they needed on the ice to execute sufficiently within the current way Sullivan wants them to play in order to beat the Isles. They knew they were outmanned and I think Sid alluded to that. That Sullivan and JR got up there and minimized their role in making this team a non-contender was really outrageous. Do you see it the same way?
Jason Mackey: I don't. I see what GMJR was saying. He wants more from the players he named. Based on what they make, they should be giving more. I didn't have any issue with what Jim said, other than him saying this is the best blue line he's had since he's been here.
Guest: Regarding Geno joining team Russia at worlds. SM = social media. His wife posted a message that seemed to indicate he was joking team Russia
Jason Mackey: I saw that. I have seen nothing official, though.
Guest: Zucc plays for Dallas now.
Jason Mackey: Sorry. Thanks for that.
Guest: What does Recchi do and why don’t they get rid of him and hire someone who can help Sullivan with the offensive strategy and craft a better PP?
Jason Mackey: They might, although I think it would be reactionary to make Recchi the fall guy here. Recchi works with a lot of the young guys, handles pre-scouts and coach the forwards.
Guest : The Pens D can’t get the puck out of their own end consistently and transition through the NZ quickly. Why is JR doubling down on this D as being the best he’s had? It’s clear JJ-Schultz pairing was atrocious
Jason Mackey: It could have been better, for sure. As I've said here, I don't understand it, either.
Guest: Did Maatta being a healthy scratch decrease his value? What do you think the return could be for him?
Jason Mackey: Not too much, I wouldn't think. Hard to tell on return, but the guy helped win two Cups, has a great attitude and is still extremely young. Have to imagine an acquiring team would want that.
Archer: Anyone else think Phil kessel is overrated?
Jason Mackey: I think Phil is a tremendous player. And hilarious. But I don't think he's the right player for where the Penguins are at right now.
Guest : Did you read this Jason? It’s spot-on. https://www.hockeybuzz.com/blog/Ryan-Wilson/Translating-locker-room-cl...
Jason Mackey: A site that doesn't staff practices or games to get quotes themselves -- or pay to be on the road or talk to people on and off the record -- but instead just steals the work of others? Nah, didn't read it.
Guest: Why not trade Hornqvist instead of Phil if they're trying to get cap space. Hornqvisy
Jason Mackey: Because I think Phil is probably a lot more tradable, and I think they actually need Hornqvist's work ethic and fire.
Guest: From what you've said above re who's likely to be gone, is it correct to say you believe Johnson and Gudbranson both will be in the opening day lineup?
Jason Mackey: I think Gudbranson will be. I think Johnson will be on the team. Don't know if he'll be in the lineup or not.
Jumbo: Do you think the pens will go after any big named players?
Jason Mackey: They'll go after guys you've heard of before, I can say that. I don't think they're going to trade for McDavid or anything like that.
Dan: Maybe a number 2 pick from Coyotes is about al they could get for Phil...something along those lines
Jason Mackey: I think you might be shooting a little high there, Dan.
Todd: Why are you so defiant about trading Phil? He has a NTC and can only be traded to 1 of 8 teams, severely limiting the return. Meanwhile Hornqvist who somehow gets a pass from everybody has an 8 team no trade, so in theory he could be traded to 1 of 22 other teams and in theory fetch a greater return. Not to mention Hornqvist is toast and has all the #grit/60 that the "hockey men" love.
Jason Mackey: I love Hornqvist as a player, but he's 32 and had three goals in his final 39 games after his fifth concussion since December 2014. Who in their right mind is gonna take that?
Christian: Jason, to my earlier question about which players have become too comfortable reported by another outlet here is the link. Which players do you think DK is referring to towards the bottom?https://www.dkpittsburghsports.com/2019/04/18/penguins-islanders-game-...
Jason Mackey: I don't have a subscription to Dejan's site, so I can't read that. But I would imagine he's referring to Letang, Kessel and Malkin, in some form or fashion.
Josh: What do you think the Pens will get for Kessel that makes it worth losing a .9ppg player?
Jason Mackey: Salary-cap space and the opportunity to open-up a top-six right-wing spot for Hornqvist. You'd also hope someone who adds a little bit more of a two-way game.
Guest: What happened to Riikola? He was sent to WBS then kinda disappeared.
Jason Mackey: He did well down there. Saw him yesterday. I'm expecting him to compete for time with the NHL club next season.
Jim Rutherford: Is Maata is disappointment or is it just a numbers thing?
Jason Mackey: Just a numbers thing. And having a movable contract.
Josh: You seriously think we should trade Kessel for a loss if it means cap space to sign players that won't score as much as he did? C'mon Jason.
Jason Mackey: He scored 27 goals while playing basically no defense and going through an extended slump. With $6.8 million, I would think they could get that and more.
Josh: Phil is a goofy, great personality, that keeps things loose. His own teammates have said repeatedly that he is. So yes, they have one. And you want him traded off.
Jason Mackey: I don't "want" anything. I'm telling you what's most likely to happen from the front office. But you should also know I think they're going to try. It's not gonna be easy.
pozone: Jason do you see the Pens bringing in any size and grit?
Jason Mackey: I do. I think they'd like to become tougher to play against, and part of it will involve those two things. But they also need to get faster. Tricky combination.
Guest: With the way Rutherford is trashing his team publicly , do you think free agents will want to come here?
Jason Mackey: Yes. A team that spends every available dollar? Of course they would. He doesn't say anything he doesn't say to them first.
Matt: Coach Sullivan talked about being accountable and playing the right way all year. That happened for small stretches but was not nearly consistent enough and it cost them in the end. Even last year had some similar problems. How will Sullivan be able to fix this next year if he hasn’t been able to do it with any consistency in a year or more?
Jason Mackey: Maybe he could get a little tighter with guys' ice time and hit them that way. I would also think he'd have players' attention after the four-game flameout.
Guest: How bout some 20/20 foresight. Best guess where Phil is playing next year?
Jason Mackey: Arizona or Florida.
Chris : Hi Jason! I am one fan who is already looking forward to next season. The last few days the media and the Pens management have been talking about changes. Since you cover them for the post gazette what changes do you see?
Jason Mackey: I see them trading a couple guys to free up cap space. I think they'll re-sign Murray, and I think Phil and Maatta are the most likely to go.
Guest : If we’re not signing or getting back a 60+ point player for Phil, then JR trading him has just made the team worse. Why doesn’t he trade actual bad players on the team?
Jason Mackey: He would be getting back someone who score 60 points, but he wouldn't be trading for them. He would be using the cap space to sign them as a UFA.
Matt in Cleveland: Will Hagelin be one of the three Hart Trophy finalists? Given the # of questions about him, seems he should be?
Jason Mackey: No kidding. What's up with that?
Chris : What do you think of the young talent ‘’ Jordy B, Sam Miletic, Addison? And is there a chance we’ll get to see them in the near future?
Jason Mackey: Like all of them, especially Addison. Really skilled defenseman. I think they'll still a year or more away, though.
AMP: How fed up are the Pens with letang’s decision making?
Jason Mackey: They're pretty agitated. But it's just about taking unnecessary risks. They know he can be a tremendous player.
Guest: Jason, why do you think so many fans think draft choices are the answer or are so valuable? Outside of the top five picks, which happily the Pens never have, what superstars have emerged from there in the last few years? It’s not the NFL
Jason Mackey: I agree. I'm fine with handling draft picks the way the Penguins do; they're not overly attached. I would rather deal with known commodities. Unless, of course, you're picking really, really high.
Guest : I don’t understand why Phil, Geno and Letang are seen as “too comfortable” during the Isles series...those guys are competitive and want to win. Yes, some or all made some mistakes, but to suggest they aren’t trying is outrageous. Geno had the most points in the series, Phil looked good. In fact, Sid played the worst of those three against the Isles. Don’t you think it’s really lazy to indict those players for not trying hard? They may be not have been executing well, but give credit to the Isles. I didn’t see a lack of caring at all
Jason Mackey: I think you need to think about more than just the Islanders series. Think about the whole season. The past two seasons. How things have been trending for the Penguins. Who brings what. Who's part of an inclusive atmosphere, that sort of thing. I think it's a little harsh, too, but I'm cautioning that Jim isn't speaking just about the playoffs.
MA: Who do you think comes up next season? Prow, Rikkola?
Jason Mackey: Maybe. If they can find a taker for Jack Johnson.
Ron J: How did We get swept my a mediocre goaltender ?
Jason Mackey: It's more than just Lehner. They couldn't do anything to penetrate the Islanders structure. And every time the Penguins did score, the Islanders had a response.
Parkman : Do you think the pens would entertain the thought of trading Geno, if so he would be the one guy on team with the highest return, I don’t want to see Geno go anywhere it was just a thought if they wanted to get a huge return to help get younger and faster?
Jason Mackey: I don't think they would go there. Sends the wrong message.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Thanks so much. Long chat today but a fun one. Also thanks for joining these all season. It's a good time. We're gonna be off for a few weeks, I think. I'll tweet when we're having the next one, probably around the draft.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.