Mike Sullivan speaks about special teams play in the postseason

How the Islanders won games during the regular season was fairly straightforward. Great defensive structure. Split between two guys, the best goaltending numbers in the league. Enough offense to survive.

How the Penguins can beat them in the Eastern Conference quarterfinals is similarly simple. They have to win the special teams battle.

It’s not exactly a drastic departure from the typical message this time of year, but it’s a little more pronounced given the recent history when it comes to these two teams.

“The more important the games, the more important the special teams become,” Matt Cullen was saying Monday after practice at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. “There’s not as much offense five-on-five. Special teams really come to the forefront.”

Advertise with us

Cullen isn’t wrong, but it’s been especially pronounced when we’re talking about Mike Sullivan-coached teams in the playoffs.

In 61 postseason games since the start of their 2016 Stanley Cup run, the Penguins are 23-10 when they get a power-play goal in a playoff game and 15-13 when they do not.

They’re 10-11 when they allow at least one power-play goal in a postseason game since that time and 28-12 when they do not.

If that’s not convincing enough, let’s also look at how special teams play has affected the Islanders this season.

When they scored at least once on the power play during the regular season, the offensively-challenged Islanders were 24-3-2. They were 24-24-5 when they were shut out on the man-advantage.

Advertise with us

If the Islanders allowed a power-play goal, they were 18-15-5 but improved to 30-12-2 if they did not.

That’s a lot to unpack, but the point here is this: If Sullivan’s team can score on the power play and its penalty kill can stop the Islanders, it should give the Penguins a big advantage.

“Special teams potentially has the opportunity to be a difference in a game,” Sullivan said.

Special teams were slanted toward the Penguins during the season series. Their power play scored on three of 14 chances (21.4 percent) and killed off 11 of the 12 (91.7) man-advantage opportunities the Islanders received.

The biggest challenge for the Penguins, who went 2-1-1 in those games, will be figuring things out given a few recent trends.

Advertise with us

The clean sheet the Penguins’ penalty kill produced Saturday against the Rangers was its first in five games. Over the final 36 games of the regular season, the Penguins killed off just 72.6 (69 of 95) percent of power plays, a rate that would’ve been dead last had it persisted over an entire season.

“It’s something we have to get better at,” Cullen said.

In the Islanders, the Penguins will not encounter a bunch of prolific, power-play point producers. Center Mathew Barzal is exciting and all, but 67 players this season had more than his team-leading 18 power-play points. The Penguins’ Juuso Riikola had only one fewer goal than Barzal’s three.

It’s really a two-horse race for the Islanders, and if the Penguins are able to shut down left wing Anders Lee (10 power-play goals) and right wing Jordan Eberle (seven), they should be fine. It also bears mentioning that the Islanders are just three for their last 50 with the extra man.

On the Penguins power play, things have definitely been more cohesive since Evgeni Malkin returned, as the entire unit often finds itself off-balance without the availability of his one-timer from the right circle.

Advertise with us

Even though it might not feel like this, the Penguins did finish fifth in power-play percentage this season at 24.6. They were also second-best on the road (32.4 percent), a number that may speak to simplifying more than they do on home ice.

Having success on the power play also involves layers. It’s about goals, sure, but also about momentum and helping those skilled players find their game five-on-five.

“You get some looks, I think that gives you momentum, gives you a little boost,” Sidney Crosby said. “We’re not going to score on every single power play, but if we can try to create momentum and do the right things, then I think it helps everyone.”

The last thing here involves power-play opportunities. Coaches love to say they dwindle in the postseason, but that’s not totally accurate — at least not for the Penguins.

In 1,114 regular-season games from 2005-19, the Penguins have had 4,333 power-play opportunities, which works out to an average of 3.9 per game. In 169 playoff games since that time, the Penguins have received 660 power-play opportunities — also an average of 3.9 per game.

Advertise with us

But given how stingy the Islanders are five-on-five, and where the Penguins can reasonably except to produce offense, they need to make sure their power play is clicking to give themselves the best chance to win the series.

“Those guys take ownership of the power play,” Sullivan said. “When they’re locked in, they’re as good of a power play as there is in the league. Our penalty kill, we try to do our best to prepare them as best we can and give them the strategies to have success. It boils down to commitment and attention to detail. When those guys do it, they’re very good, as well. We’re going to have to rely on them again moving forward if we’re going to have success.”

Jason Mackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.