With the Penguins heading down the home stretch here, we have decided to add a mailbag to our array of Penguins coverage. If you would like to submit a question for next week’s installment, you can email Matt Vensel at mvensel@post-gazette.com or send one to him on Twitter @mattvensel.
Is Jake Guentzal the best winger the penguins have drafted since Jagr?
— Diamond Pickems Harrison Baldwin (@RealHB17) March 25, 2019
This was a good question, one I couldn’t easily answer without the help of Hockey Reference.
I used the website’s handy Draft Finder tool to quickly pull up a list of every forward the Penguins have picked since 1990, when they drafted Jagr fifth overall, and sorted them by career points.
Guentzel, who was selected in the third round in 2013, already has 152 points in 199 games. That puts him eighth among wingers. Another couple of seasons like this and Guentzel will blow by Ryan Malone, the true homegrown winger who scored 370 career points, though not all of them with the Penguins. The only winger the Penguins picked who topped that? Get ready for a stomach punch.
Ah, yes, we all remember Markus Naslund, don’t we? The 1991 first-round pick had 67 points in 151 games with the Penguins before they shipped him to the Vancouver Canucks in one of the most lopsided trades in recent NHL history. An All-Star there, Naslund finished with 869 career points.
It’s too early to declare that Guentzel will surpass that total, but he’s obviously off to a great start and has a good chance of getting there if he stays healthy and next to Sidney Crosby. With him locked in long term, I will not-so-boldly predict that Guentzel will end up being the best winger the Penguins have drafted since Jagr when solely considering contributions made here.
Read More
Is there any chance we see Jack Johnson sit in the playoffs? How short is his rope or does he basically get a pass?
— Josh (@jhbaccountant) March 25, 2019
We’re still doing this Jack Johnson thing? Look, I can understand why some were skeptical of this signing when it happened this summer given his ugly career plus-minus rating and advanced stats that attempt to capture puck possession when a player is on the ice. And he didn’t get off to a great start here, either. But the blue-liner has hardly been an issue over the past three, four months.
Johnson is a plus-8 since Dec. 4. He is a useful penalty-killer. And he’s one player who doesn’t mind throwing his body around in an organic way – not chasing hits and pulling himself out of the play.
Is he perfect? No. There are still moments where his lack of speed contributes to the Penguins not being able to get out of their zone, and that extended possession time results in pucks in their net.
I just don’t see the Penguins taking him out of the lineup, and not just because that would signal it was a disappointing signing; the Penguins under Jim Rutherford and Mike Sullivan have shown they aren’t afraid to make a change if they feel it is what is best for the team. The reality is that Johnson is a solid defender, fourth or fifth in their pecking order, who doesn’t hurt them on most nights.
Zach trotman, what are your thoughts on him? Is he being sheltered by playing with Dumoulin, or is he the real deal?
— Ryan Leverett (@ryan_leverett) March 26, 2019
Zach Trotman has mostly been OK. And, sure, playing a lot next to Brian Dumoulin probably has at least a little to do with that. He’s the team’s best defending defenseman not named Kris Letang.
But ideally – and nothing against him – Trotman isn’t in the lineup. He’s a solid depth defenseman, one who has arguably been steadier this season than Chad Ruhwedel before Ruhwedel got injured last month, opening the door for Trotman to get an extended look here in Pittsburgh. If you’re so deep that someone like that has to watch from the press box, then you’ve got a decent crew.
Assuming Geno, ZAR, and Maata are back for the playoffs (and no other injuries) what should we expect/consider for 4th line and 2/3rd pairing configurations? Should we expect Bjug, Horny, Simon to stick? Thanks!
— dennis (@Gobbus21) March 26, 2019
We ask Sullivan a lot of hypothetical questions like this. You know, what are you guys going to do when you get healthy? I wouldn’t blame him if he refused to answer them going forward because it seems like literally every time we do it, someone else exits the lineup shortly thereafter.
That said, this is a totally fair question, one that Sullivan and his staff surely kick around daily.
Assuming Evgeni Malkin and Zach Aston-Reese return relatively soon, it would be interesting to see what Sullivan does there. He would presumably be picking three from Aston-Reese, Teddy Blueger, Garrett Wilson, Dominik Simon and Adam Johnson to fill spots in the lineup. The other two sit.
That third line that you mentioned has been pretty good the last few games, so he might not want to touch that. But I’m still intrigued by the idea of Kessel and Nick Bjugstad on the third line.
Anyway, assuming Simon, Bryan Rust, Jared McCann and Patric Hornqvist all slot into the top three lines somewhere, the fourth could be Aston-Reese, Matt Cullen and Blueger or Wilson. Not bad.
As for the defensive pairs, I think that would be more straightforward. Sullivan likes having three lefty-righty pairs, and he again praised the Marcus Pettersson-Erik Gudbranson pairing Tuesday. So that could mean that there isn’t a chair left for Olli Maatta should Letang return soon.
That appears to be far from certain, though. One can’t help but be concerned about Letang, who is out again with an upper-body injury that may or may not be the same one that sidelined him for close to a month. Letang did not practice with the team Tuesday after missing Monday’s win.
If u could be any hockey player for a day who would you be? And you cant say Crosby.
— Brian Hopkins (@Hoppy_21) March 25, 2019
As a beer-league blue-liner who doesn’t do anything exceptionally well besides falling – sometimes intentionally, sometimes not – I loved Brian’s question. This was a fun one to think about.
I’m pretty slow and my slapshot would clock in at about 45 mph if I could figure out how to get it off the ground. So it really comes down to Connor McDavid’s speed or Alex Ovechkin’s one-timer.
Give me Ovi’s rocket. I would love to know what it feels like to rip a one-timer from the top of the circle past a helpless goaltender just one time. No wonder that guy’s always looking to shoot.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.