COLUMBUS, Ohio — Matt Murray stood on his head. Phil Kessel couldn’t stand on his skates. Add the two together, and you get a decent picture of the Penguins’ 4-1 loss to the Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday at Nationwide Arena.

One that, despite the five goals that were scored, actually featured a solid goaltending battle between Murray and Sergei Bobrovsky, whose recent history against the Penguins was akin to the Washington Generals.

The Penguins lost a game their goaltender seemed intent on willing them to win, and how they did that should prove instructive over the final 14 games of the season. Provided, of course, they can fix some of these issues.

“We’re lucky we have Murray on our team,” Evgeni Malkin said. “He’s played unbelievable, but we need to help him a little bit.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes we lose players in the defensive zone. We give them great chances to score. If we play a little bit tighter in the D zone, we’ll be fine.”

That’s a start anyway, which was missing for the Penguins in this one. The Penguins have actually started well for much of this season, but the Blue Jackets clobbered them early.

In a literal sense, as Josh Anderson hit Jack Johnson and Dominik Simon a few seconds after the puck dropped. Then in a more figurative sense when Boone Jenner snatched the game’s momentum like a loaf of marble rye, his goal at 2:31 staking Columbus to a 1-0 lead.

“I thought after the first 10-15 minutes, we kinda got our legs going,” said Zach Aston-Reese, who scored the Penguins’ only goal. “We had more of a game for ourselves. That first 10 minutes we kind of shot ourselves in the foot.”

That’s not what happened to Kessel in the second period, although it might’ve made the short-handed goal the Penguins allowed a little more understandable.

Advertise with us

Evgeni Malkin reacts to the Penguins' 4-1 loss to Columbus

After taking a drop pass from … well, no. Kessel never actually took a drop pass from Justin Schultz because he tripped, on nothing, and Cam Atkinson buried one from the left circle to make it 2-0.

It was the NHL-worst 14th short-handed goal the Penguins have allowed this season.

And easily the ugliest.

“I’m not sure where I’m at yet,” coach Mike Sullivan said when asked where he’s at with all those shorties. “I don’t think we’ve given up those types of chances in a while. But I’m not sure where I’m at.”

The goal wasn’t the only eyesore for the power play on this night.

Advertise with us

On the Penguins’ first power play, they had more giveaways (3) than shots on goal (0). They also got a gift when David Savard was called for interference, producing a 4-on-3, but the Penguins couldn’t score given 45 seconds on a bunch of open ice.

But at least the Penguins had a few chances there. On their third power play, they again had more giveaways (2) than shots on goal (1).

“It’s a huge part of our game,” Malkin said. “If we play [the power play] better, we have a great chance to win.”

Five-on-five was no picnic, either. The Penguins attempted six such shots in the opening period and were slogging along through the first third of the middle period, totaling just seven. Fortunately for them, they did start to generate more, but it came in fits and starts.

As a result, the Penguins finished with just seven high-danger chances — half as many as they’ve had in each of the past two games.

Advertise with us

“I think we’re capable of more,” Sullivan said.

The game did have a playoff feel — Columbus’ crowd was amped early and stayed that way — and it featured Playoff Murray, too.

Even though he wound up allowing three goals on 32 shots, the Penguins goaltender was nothing short of electric.

“I thought he was really good,” Sullivan said.

Murray padded his career highlight-reel by robbing Jenner with the blade of his stick in the first period, then used the inside of his blocker to deny Markus Nutivaara in the second.

Advertise with us

Later in the period, after a chance from Pierre-Luc Dubois, Murray challenged a Grade A, follow-up opportunity from Artemi Panarin, who doesn’t exactly stink at scoring goals.

Murray mostly sandbagged his performance afterward, saying he “made some pretty bad reads” and “got a little lucky, too.” He’d have better luck selling oceanfront property in Brentwood than he would getting anyone to believe that.

It was a superb performance — “Murray played amazing yet again,” Jared McCann said. “It’s unfortunate we couldn’t get the win for him.” — especially when you look at how the team played in front of him at key times.

On Jenner’s goal, McCann helped Brian Dumoulin pressure the puck carrier and lost track of Jenner, while nobody came within a stick length of Oliver Bjorkstrand before he potted a Ryan Dzingel pass for the Blue Jackets’ third tally.

Both plays were perfect examples of what Malkin talked about: losing guys in the D zone.

Advertise with us

If the Penguins fix that, if they get the power play going again, if they generate more five-on-five, if they get off to a better start … if they even do two of those things, they should be fine.

Because goaltending — easily the biggest and most important factor now and in the playoffs — was not even close to a concern on this night.

“We’re trying to control what we can,” Sullivan said. “As I said to the guys after the game, we didn’t get the result. We’ve got to put it behind us and be ready for the next one. That’s the mindset we have to have. We’re in playoff mode already. That’s just the way it’s gonna be.”

What it means

The loss snapped the Penguins’ winning streak at three, their run of dominance over the Blue Jackets at eight.

Advertise with us

The Penguins (36-23-9) now have 81 points and sit in the first wild-card spot, two points ahead of Columbus and a regulation win back of Carolina in the tiebreaker for third place in the Metropolitan Division.

The Islanders are four points ahead in second place, the Capitals six in first.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.