PHILADELPHIA – Just four weeks ago, general manager Jim Rutherford gave away Jamie Oleksiak for a draft pick because he figured that once Justin Schultz returned, the Penguins would have too many defensemen.

It was sound logic. The Penguins at that point were putting two defenders in the press box every night, with Oleksiak often being one of them. Schultz was about to starting practicing again, giving them nine on the roster.

“We had to move somebody out,” Rutherford said after that trade.

Suddenly, it appears the Penguins might need to move somebody in.

Advertise with us

Brian Dumoulin, who leads the Penguins with a plus-27 rating, suffered a concussion during the first period of Saturday’s 4-3 overtime loss to the Philadelphia Flyers at Lincoln Financial Field. Kris Letang, an All-Star this season, got injured sticking up for his top-pair partner.

The Penguins were forced to play the final two periods and overtime with just four healthy defensemen. Jack Johnson and Justin Schultz, playing the most each has in five seasons, both topped 30 minutes of ice time. Chad Ruhwedel and Marcus Pettersson stayed busy, too.

“It’s tough when you lose your top pair of defense,” coach Mike Sullivan said after the Penguins blew a late two-goal lead. “That’s not easy.”

Replacing Letang, who has an upper-body injury, or Dumoulin will not be easy if either is sidelined for an extended period. And if both guys are out for a while? That could deliver a critical blow to their playoff hopes.

“It’s going to give other guys opportunities,” Sullivan said. “Hopefully, we won’t lose either one of them for any length of time. But in the meantime, we’re going to put guys in that we know are capable of helping us win.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins, at least for the moment, are now down three of their top four defensemen – all of them injured in Philadelphia in the last two weeks.

On Feb. 11, Olli Maatta was injured in a Penguins win at Wells Fargo Center. Early in that game, he separated his shoulder while slamming it into the boards during an awkward fall. Maatta is out indefinitely.

That, coupled with losing Letang and Dumoulin, meant that the Penguins made the flight back to Pittsburgh with only five healthy defensemen.

Finnish rookie Juuso Riikola would presumably re-enter the lineup Tuesday in Columbus if the Penguins were without Letang or Dumoulin.

But the Penguins will likely need to bring in at least one more blue-liner, if only to have enough to get through Monday’s practice in Cranberry.

Advertise with us

Ethan Prow is the most likely candidate for a call-up from the AHL club in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton. The late-blooming 26-year-old leads them with 39 points, 15 of them goals, and was their lone All-Star representative.

During his first two full seasons as a professional, Prow was often a healthy scratch and twice had brief stints with Wheeling of the ECHL. He took a big step forward this season and his confidence has grown.

Prow, who has a dangerous right-handed shot, has displayed good offensive instincts at the AHL level while making strides in the defensive end.

Last month, when the Penguins had a blue-line logjam before the Oleksiak trade, Prow said he wasn’t worrying about his blocked path to the NHL.

“You just have to stick to the process. You can’t change up what you’re doing,” he told the Post-Gazette. “You just have to stick to it and kind of let the cards fall. You can’t think about it too much or you’ll go crazy.”

Advertise with us

Other potential promotions could include Zach Trotman, Kevin Czuczman and Blake Siebenaler, whom the Penguins acquired earlier this month.

Rutherford could also look to make a trade to bolster his blue-line depth.

He might have already been considering that before Saturday’s costly loss, with Maatta’s availability for the start of the playoffs in doubt and division rivals Columbus and Washington bolstering their lineups last week.

Regardless of whom gets moved in, if the Penguins must play games without Letang and Dumoulin, by far their best two defensemen this season, it would have a trickle-down effect on the rest of their defensive lineup.

“Those are a tough two guys to replace,” Schultz said. “They’re two of the more important guys on this team.”

Advertise with us

Schultz, who just returned Feb. 16 from an ankle injury after a four-month absence and doesn’t feel completely like himself yet, could be forced to shoulder a heavy load. Ditto for Johnson, whom last week Rutherford felt the need to publicly defend in interviews with multiple news outlets.

Ruhwedel, who did not play for an NHL game in three months before getting dusted off following Maatta’s injury, might now be in their top four.

Riikola, who took his place in the press box, hasn’t played since Feb. 13.

That’s not ideal for Penguins team that is by no means a playoff lock with a healthy Letang and Dumoulin logging major minutes for them.

“I think the guys who have come in at different points this year have really done a great job of coming in and not maybe taking those minutes on their shoulders, but everybody just helping each other,” Sidney Crosby said. “That's possibly what we're going to be faced with.”

Advertise with us

The captain added: “There's not going to be any teams feeling sorry for us, so we're going to have to find a way to overcome that.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.