Phil Bourque remembers peeling off his equipment in a celebratory postgame dressing room at Civic Arena, the Penguins together marveling at yet another virtuoso performance from Mario Lemieux, when they had a collective realization.
“We were like, ‘Wait a minute, he just scored five goals five different ways!’ “ Bourque recalled recently.
Monday marks 30 years since Lemieux scored five goals five ways — even strength, power play, short-handed, penalty shot and empty net — yet the feat remains every bit as jaw-dropping now as it did then. Maybe more so.
In fact, while reminiscing about the moment recently, that was one of the biggest takeaways from those who experienced it: Nobody knew what had actually occurred until after the Penguins’ 8-6 win over the New Jersey Devils in an afternoon game on New Year’s Eve.
“Nobody had done it before, so you never thought about somebody being able to do it,” said Tom McMillan, who covered the game for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and now works for the Penguins as their vice president of communications. “I had written my story without realizing it was five goals five ways.”
There are a few reasons why it probably snuck past everyone.
Read More
One, circumstance. How many NHL games even allow for those five opportunities?
If one player is scoring five times, chances are it’s a blowout, with zero opportunity for an empty-netter late. But the Penguins and Devils traded goals all night, the Penguins never trailing but also never ahead by more than two.
Also, the gaudy numbers Lemieux — who also had three assists against the Devils — produced that entire season.
That was the second of three eight-point efforts for Lemieux 1988-89, one of them coming in the playoffs. That season, Lemieux had 12 games with five or more points en route to a career-high 199. That was Lemieux’s only five-goal game that season — the slouch — but he did produce four of those throughout his career.
“What he was doing had almost become routine,” said Paul Steigerwald, who served as the color commentator alongside Hall of Fame play-by-play man Mike Lange.
“It was another one of those times where he was having himself a night,” Bourque remembered, “and you just try to remember it.”
The game itself produced several memories for those involved.
Having scored at even strength at 4:17 of the first period, Lemieux’s most spectacular effort of the night may have come on the penalty kill at 7:50 of the first, when he turned poor Aaron Broten inside out for one of an NHL-record 13 short-handed goals that season.
The penalty shot goal, which also came short-handed, was one of so many artistic masterpieces Lemieux scored throughout his career, one that drew ample reaction from those watching on the bench.
“You’d look at one of your teammates, he’d look at you, then you’d both kind of say it,” Bourque said. “Like, ‘Holy [crap]’ at the same time. You can’t believe what you just witnessed.”
For Steigerwald, one of the things he remembers most is the empty netter. In the age of replay, Steigerwald said, the goal probably would’ve been reviewed and disallowed.
“When you watch the video, the green light comes on, which in those days meant it wasn’t a goal,” Steigerwald said. “If you went back and looked at the video the way they analyze video now, would that puck have been across the line before time expired?”
Maybe not, but that doesn’t matter now. And it didn’t matter then, either. The officials smartly gave Lemieux the benefit of the doubt.
“There’s no way the referee knew it had to be an empty netter to complete the feat,” Steigerwald said. “He just gave it to him because he’s Mario Lemieux, and he deserved it.”

Given the fact that he scored just five goals in his 208-game NHL career, nobody could’ve blamed Jay Caufield, now an analyst for AT&T SportsNet, if he had kept the puck in the final seconds instead of passing it ahead to Lemieux for the empty netter.
“That turned out to be a pretty generous offer by Jay Caufield,” Steigerwald said.
“Thank God I passed the puck,” Caufield said, laughing. “My wife and I still laugh about that. I might be ice fishing in Nova Scotia if I didn’t give that puck up.”
Not that Caufield ever really thought about taking a shot there. He said he was thinking about passing to Lemieux from the moment he got the puck and would do the same thing over again 100 times out of 100.
“He was there. It’s Mario. I was definitely going to give him the puck,” Caufield said.
Back in 2017, the feat was voted the greatest moment in NHL history, and Lemieux was feted during the NHL 100 Classic in Ottawa.
Like McMillan, Lemieux said scoring five goals five different ways “wasn’t something you thought about,” but he did admit to being proud of the accomplishment, the rare individual accolade that seemed to catch Lemieux’s attention.
“I want to thank the fans for this tremendous honor,” Lemieux said back in 2017. “There have been so many great plays in 100 years of NHL hockey. So many great players. To be chosen as having the greatest moment is something I’ll always remember.”
Those closest to Lemieux know accomplishing this means a little more to him, and the reasons why are perfectly understandable.
“Because of his health issues, he couldn’t really establish a lot of records that he could have probably broken had he been healthy,” Steigerwald said. “That’s something that no one else will ever do. Ever.”
There’s also the fact that Lemieux accomplished pretty much everything a hockey player could accomplish — aside from the volume of numbers, obviously.
Having something so rare, so unique, so weird, Lemieux and those involved almost can’t help but reminisce a little this time of year.
“I think as any athlete, if you’re able to do something that nobody else has done, that’s special,” Caufield said. “He doesn’t talk much about it, but when we get to this time of year, I know he knows.”
The beauty of scoring five goals five ways was that it was basically Lemieux’s own personal highlight film, complete with every kind of damage he was capable of doing.
Steigerwald appropriately called it Lemieux’s “résumé.”
If you think about it that way, maybe it doesn’t seem so nuts. The crazy part, though, is that all of that stuff actually happened in a 60-minute hockey game.
“He was doing what Mario does,” Steigerwald added. “He just happened to do it all in one night.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.