Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday chat. One change for this week and moving forward: I'm not going to answer repeat questions. Try to move this along a bit. Hope you understand. Thanks and talk to you at 1.
Christian: Jason, if we take trading availability out of this, what would you say is Brassard’s timeline for making an impact?
Jason Mackey: Hey Christian, I would say maybe a couple weeks. Two generously? It depends on how it goes and what Rutherford sees, that's for sure.
MA: There have been a lot of commentators mentioning a players team meeting the Pens had. Has there been any word about who spoke and what was discussed ?
Jason Mackey: I have not heard of anything, MA. Not anything outside of what normally happens anyway. They honestly have a lot of team meetings. Picking one to trace this back to -- even if that happened -- might not be completely accurate. But again, I haven't seen anything that you're referencing.
Chris: You or one of your colleagues noted that this year's defense is worse than last year's. Can you comment on that, given the positive press the most recent defensive addition (name escapes me, tall thin one who saved the puck from going in) has received as well as Letang's clear improvement from last year? Thank you for avoiding repetitive questions by the way!!!!
Read More
Jason Mackey: Hey Chris ... I think that needs a little context. Beginning of the season, it was worse because of results. Lately, though, they've been better. Player-for-player, I wouldn't say they're worse. Letang has been much improved. I like Riikola. Pettersson has been a nice addition. ... Compared to, say, 2015-16, then I would say that group is better.
Isaac: Who has been the best among the penguins depth forwards? Could you rank them? (I mean like Cullen, sheahan, rust, grant, dea, Pearson, Simon, etc, etc)
Jason Mackey: I'd have to go Rust first, just because of what he's done lately. It's been ridiculous. ... Maybe next a tie between Simon -- who has taken some decent steps -- and Pearson, who started out well but has slumped. ... After that Sheahan, who has been better of late. Cullen been quite but the contract is minimal. He's 42; I don't know how much you can expect.
Monday Morning QB: Derick Brassard has 9 points in 27 games, with 1 in the last 9 games. He's a -3 and hasn't meshed with any specific linemates. Those numbers arent too far off for an average 3rd line C, but he wasnt supposed to be an average 3rd C. What kind of production does he need to reach to be considered a success story? Is his style just not complimentary to Sullivan's? When do you 'pull the plug" and look for a trade if he remains stagnant?
Jason Mackey: I think it's getting closed, as I wrote recently: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/12/23/Jim-Rutherford...
Jason Mackey: But I still think you have to give Brassard and Kessel a couple more games to see if they can figure this out. ... That said, I don't think he likes it here. I don't think he wants to be here. And I think it would probably be best to pull the plug.
Redbeard: If you were to handicap the roster players most likely to be traded wyour top 3?
Jason Mackey: Brassard ... Grant ... Maatta. ... The first two are much more likely than the third, mind you.
Stamatios: With Doumalin, Letang, Maata, Oleksiak, and the soon returning Shultz as the defense's foundation, and nice young D-men like Rikolla and Petterson, the Johnson signing looks bad and unnecessary. They're now stuck with a guy they honestly don't really need at a huge price. I know depth is nice but at a certain point its too much and resources can be used elsewhere. I know he's playing solidly, esp on PK, but is there anything (i.e. magic) GMJR can do to move him and would he? Even if he moves Maata, I would still move Johnson if possible. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I don't think there's much he can do, to be honest with you. I don't have a huge problem with the Johnson signing, at least not to the degree that many Penguins fans do. But five years for a guy that age ... I just don't see who would be lining up right now to get that.
Dan: I saw where Craig Patrick is back scouting for Pens..What exactly is his capacity with team and was this a surprising hire or a favor to Mario ?
Jason Mackey: I don't think it's surprising. I'm surprised it's taken so long, to be honest. Seems like a perfect move. He's most responsible for advancing scouting ... he's usually a couple games ahead of the NHL club, watching for tendencies and such from other teams.
Stamatios: What can be done to wake up Malkin? perhaps playing him with Hornqvist? It's not just the lack of goals, his all around game has been lackluster, lazy, uninspired. I can't remember another time that he's been in such a funk for so long.
Jason Mackey: They are playing him with Hornqvist tonight, and I think that will help -- tell Malkin to simplify and shoot the puck more; that usually helps. But I think also they just need to ride it out. Malkin is a streaky player. Always has been. Take the good with the bad. He's certainly due to break out.
Joe: Hi Chris, It seems that Jim Rutherford is using the media a little more this year than previous to convey concern/displeasure about personnel on the Penguins. Do you concur, and if so, what is the motivation behind this...thanks.
Jason Mackey: Chris? Ha. ... Jason. ... I think GMJR is about the same this year, and he does do this regularly. He's old school. He likes being available and saying what he does to get peoples' attention. I just think they've struggled more at the start of this season. As such, he's had more to talk about.
Bryan Rust speaks ahead of Penguins' return from Christmas break
JB: It seems clear that Brassard isn't exactly thriving (nor does he seem particularly thrilled with being) in a 14-15 minute a night 3C role. I know they say they want 3 lines that can score, but even given that, tried him on Crosby's wing here and there. That job's nowhere near available at the moment (nor should it be), but it seems to me that the more natural fit might be to put Malkin on Brassard's wing with either Kessel or Hornqvist, bring up Blueger and give him a shot at being the 3C with whichever of 81/72 isn't playing with Brassard plus whichever of Simon and Rust isn't playing with Sid. Worst case, shouldn't they at least try it to see where Blueger is before deciding on trading Brassard? You might even slightly mask Malkin's maddening addiction to turning the puck over within 6 feet of the offensive blue line through ill advised passes to wingers that he hopes might, possibly be kinda sorta open that way...and you definitely would get him out of faceoffs,
Jason Mackey: I think if they traded Brassard, it wouldn't have a ton to do with Blueger. I think if they decided to trade Brassard, it would be more about getting something from somebody they were going to lose. As I understand it, I think it would have to be a special case to see guys like Blueger up here this year. And they might, don't get me wrong, but I think their first plan would be something like using Sheahan and Cullen down the middle first ... or maybe Grant ... or maybe getting someone else who fits better before they went to Blueger.
Stuart: What's up with Malkin? Playing east to west, turnovers. Fatherhood?
Jason Mackey: It would have to be delayed fatherhood, no? It's not like his kid was born a couple weeks ago. He's played like crap, I agree. Sort of mystifying. But he's been a streaky player. I also would not discount the loss of Carl Hagelin all of this.
JB: Sorry...I forgot about Pearson. The 3 line would be Blueger, Pearson and either 81 or 72 in my scenario...which might actually be a pretty decent group if Blueger is as ready as advertised...
Jason Mackey: They're not going to bring Blueger up from the minors and immediately give him those responsibilities. At least not without injuries or exhausting other options first.
Normie: Hi Jason. Have the Penguins indicated a time table for when Shultz gets out of the cast and can begin skating?
Jason Mackey: He should begin skating in the next couple weeks. Cast is off now. I'd expect him to return the second week of February, if not beore.
Jason Mackey: before*
Samuel: If the goal is to have Kessel play on his own line, what type of player would be the perfect third line center that meets his needs while also not needing to play 1st or 2nd line minutes? ...seems like an unlikely find...thanks
Jason Mackey: Someone who plays defense ... someone who can find Kessel with a pass whenever he blows the zone early ... someone who understands how and where Kessel wants the puck ... someone who has a thick skin, in case Kessel screams at him ... someone who can get his hands dirty around the net and maybe finish a little. Those would be my important attributes.
Yoda: Who besides brassard is tradeable to other teams? What I mean by tradeable is who would other teams actually be willing to trade for.
Jason Mackey: I think Maatta could be tradable, and they could save money by using Riikola in that spot. I also don't know if they would want to get rid out of Maatta at this point. He's statistically been their best PK guy. ... I could maybe see Pearson being repurposed, too.
Super Genius: Jason - If you could change one thing Coach Sullivan does with the Pens what would it be? Mine is the line juggling...how can this team ever develop chemistry on a per line basis whenever their linemate changes at a drop of the hat. What do you think?
Jason Mackey: Mine is the same. ... I think he shuffles too much and doesn't let guys build chemistry. I think it's coming from a good place, but he doesn't seem to have much patience with that sort of stuff.
Guest: On a non-game day, how long are the players at the rink? What time do they get there in the morning for practice and what time are they headed home for the day?
Jason Mackey: If they practice at 11, say, they're probably there for meetings and treatment -- it does vary by guy -- by 8:30 or 9. ... They'll usually head home, again assuming an 11 am practice, around 1:30 or 2, if they don't need treatment or anything like that.
Joe: Do you think sully would sit Malkin for a game to motivate him if he continues to play with what looks like care or effort. .
Jason Mackey: No. Because he's liable to break out at any moment. He's earned the right to play through this.

Steven: You keep pushing Brassard trade, but you’re not going to get value, and you then need to replace him. With who and with what assets?
Jason Mackey: I don't know if I'm pushing the Brassard trade so much as relaying the sentiment that has been expressed to me by those who have the power to make it happen. If he's not a fit, he's not a fit. They need to find someone who is. They don't feel like they're getting enough from that spot right now. It's really not much more complicated than that.
Todd: Is brassard the 1st Pens player that didn't want to be here while you were on the beat?
Jason Mackey: It's the first where it has seemed this obvious. Or that there's been so little of a fit. Especially when you cross that with how skilled I think Brassard is. Someone that good, usually they all figure out a way to make it work.
ALB: Do you think what happened with Wilson will effect the way Oleksiak plays?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. He talked about it this morning. This stuff happens. It sucks, but you move on. I believe him. He can't change his game. Playing that way is a big part of why he's valuable to the Penguins.
Andy O: Why hasn't Derrick Brassard meshed here?
Jason Mackey: He's a top-six center being asked to play a bottom-six role. He wants to play with more skilled people, and he hasn't been able to make it work with the most skilled player he's been with (Phil Kessel). He gets less ice time, which also includes less on the power play.
Baron: Rankin All-Time 'Guins, 66 then 87 then 68 then 71 then...? And who would be an under-the-radar Top 10 All-Time 'Guin?...thanks
Jason Mackey: Gotta include Stevens, right? I also think Fleury deserves mention. ... Letang ... Francis ... Recchi, even though he played plenty of other places. ... Bourque, even, for beginning to end how much he's meant. Errey for that matter, too.
Alex: Hey Jason, hope your holiday was great. Another year, another wasted season for Jordan Staal in CAR. Can you think of an active player in the league who’s potential has been so squandered like Staal’s? It’s almost criminal how he’s being wasted there. On a scale of 1-10, how possible is it that GMJR has interest and WOULD make the move?
Jason Mackey: I can't, honestly. Every single year I wonder why he hasn't asked to play somewhere else now that his brother is gone. Raleigh is an awesome place, but if I'm a hockey player ... man, when's the last time he even made the playoffs?
Guest: do u think jim rutherfor has anything up his sleve to mak us much better on defence
Jason Mackey: At this point, I don't think he's working on anything specifically for defense, no.
Fred Herbert: Hi Chris, do you expect the cap to go up next year?
Jason Mackey: The second Chris ... this is weird. Yes, I do expect it to rise.
Malkin_TheBeast: Hello Jason, did you have a nice feast this 25th? I think your best present this year has been the welcome of another Mackay junior! ^_~
You know, I am a big fan of Malkin, I'm worried... what's his biggest issue lately, it's speed skating ( I say that because watching him on TV is not the same as someone watching him live in arena) or playmaking decision?
Jason Mackey: I did ... and thank you. Young man was born back in October, but we were thrilled for him to experience his first Christmas. Everything was great, and thanks for asking. I think the biggest issue with Malkin right now isn't skating. It's pressing. Trying to do too much. Getting frustrated. Also building chemistry with linemates -- anyone, not just Phil.
Ebert Morknorkman: Malkin wll be fine, especially back with #72, as far as 3rd center, if GMJR flips Brassard is it for another center or winger and try Sheahan at center gain?
Jason Mackey: Very likely, yes.
Reston Pen: Hi Jason, has Brassard’s trade value been diminished by his failure to perform with the Pens?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. He's a UFA to be, meaning it's low-risk. And I think people will realize there's skill there. It just hasn't translated to Pittsburgh. Mind you, I don't think they'll get a ton for him, but he hasn't torpedoed his value here, either, which is what I think you asked.
Eddie Shack: What kind of team would want Brassard straight up - or do you need to sweeten the pot with say Maata?
Jason Mackey: You might need to sweeten the pot, either with Maatta or I could see Pearson being part of that, too. ... You know one place I think might be interesting: Montreal. Habs are hanging around. Could bank on him being real happy in that city. They could use someone like him. Don't know what they could give, though, but the Habs are a team that intrigues me.
GC from Seal Beach: You making the SO CAL trip?
Jason Mackey: Absolutely. Can't wait. Especially for the San Jose (for me San Francisco) part.

John: Your last description of a center screams Dzingel out of Ottawa. Might not be too eager for a center out of Ottawa, though.
Jason Mackey: Ha. PTSD or something of the like, huh? Can't imagine Ottawa would wanna make that move, either. Makes no sense for the Sens.
GC from Seal Beach: Jason are you making the SO CAL trip? Are they going to leave Brassard out here with the Kings or Ducks?
Jason Mackey: Ha. I am making the trip. I can't speak to the second part. ... Don't think the Kings would have interest. Could see the Ducks possibly, though. That makes sense.
Ebert Morknorkman: Who would have thought this time last year that ANYONE in Pittsburgh would be missing Hagelin but as you mentioned I think there is something to that with Geno and it does seem we miss his speed, any chance of a reunion? Havent heard much about how he is doing in LA.
Jason Mackey: He's hurt. Has been for a while. But, yeah, I think they've missed him a lot.
JB: If the priority is a center for Phil and they're going to depart from giving meaningful responsibility to younger players - which they have in the past with success - isn't St. Louis looking more like a seller every day, and don't they have a guy named Bozak who seems to be able to play well with Kessel? Not that he's exactly ripping it up at the moment, either, though...
Darius Kasparaitis: Is this team too soft?
Jason Mackey: I would make a call, but the contract -- as we went through last week -- is onerous. St. Louis would have to eat some if I was going to entertain that. I don't think it's terribly likely, to be honest with you.
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. They've won 11 of 17, Darius. Doing just fine.
Eddie Shack: For everyone who keeps mentioning Brassard's value, he has none to the team he is currently on - honestly I'd ride it our with Sheahan at 3C Brassard has really done nothing but mope and get injured since he's been here. And Jason, to your comment, does he not like it here because of minutes he's getting or because he just thinks he's better than he is?
Jason Mackey: I think both of those are probably true, Eddie.
Dave: It was great to see the pens play a good game here in Raleigh so be sure to tell Sid thanks for the early Christmas gift. More of an observation than a question : when they choose to play the right way, they are extremely difficult to beat. When there are fewer chances, I think the pens skill becomes an even greater advantage.When they play loose, they give less talented teams the chance to score easy goals, which negates their scoring talent advantage.
Jason Mackey: I agree with you, Dave. Glad you enjoyed the game. And they've done a better job playing that way of late, too.
Officer Sorrows: You wrote that Garrett Wilson could counter Tom Wilson. Garrett can fight, but is more of a grinding 4th liner - not tough fighter. Did you miss Tom knocking out a 6’7” guy? The only counter is to play and beat his team, not try and fight him.
Jason Mackey: Thanks for your opinion, Officer. ... I did not miss it. Tom Wilson is a tough dude, that was impressive. And I never said they were going to retain Garrett Wilson for purely fighting. More physicality. I also wrote what I wrote because it was based on something ... not just me slapping my opinion on a page. ... Lastly, I think Garrett Wilson is a better fighter than you're giving him credit for. He could hold his own, trust me.
Ebert Morknorkman: Paul Coffey as an all time great?
Jason Mackey: Ahhh ... I knew I would forget someone. Good call. There are probably more I forgot.
Officer Sorrows: Trading Brassard won’t net you back a current roster player (he’s a UFA, value is lower). Wouldn’t it be wiser to keep him - he can make some sort of impact, whether at center or at wing? Trading for future pieces when our future is the bottom of the league when 87/71 retire seems like horrible asset management.
Jason Mackey: I disagree. If he's not a fit, you're wasting a spot. And the Penguins might be wasting a spot. That's what they're trying to figure out.
John: Well, Dzingel is a UFA. Can't imagine Melnyk shelling out at the end of the season for him, given Stone/Duchene need new contracts
Jason Mackey: Good point. Although I think non-cheap owners would pay the man.
Stop the Hate: You what team could really use Brassard? The Pittsburgh Penguins if they trade him just because the media doesn't like that he won't talk to them.
Jason Mackey: Brassard talks all the time. He's tremendously approachable and very helpful. I like him a lot. I think he's a very good player. I just wonder if he's the right one for this team. So does his general manager.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Thanks so much for participating. Let's do this again next week!





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.