What a difference a holiday makes.
Just before Thanksgiving, the Penguins lost nine out of 10 games. Matt Murray, after getting chased from three games in three weeks, was placed on injured reserve while many Penguins fans were popping their turkey in the oven on that holiday. Bryan Rust didn’t score all month. Mike Sullivan couldn’t find three defensive pairs he liked.
Now, here they are at Christmas, having turned their season around after an atrocious November. Sidney Crosby and his linemates have lugged the Penguins all the way back to third place in the Metropolitan standings. Casey DeSmith stabilized the crease, and now Murray is back and playing well, too. Marcus Pettersson has been a nice addition.
As the Penguins get a needed breather during the NHL’s holiday break, there is still a long haul until the playoffs and many questions about this talented but inconsistent bunch that will be answered in the next few months. So, at this unofficial midway point for the 2018-19 season, let’s ponder seven of the most pressing questions facing the Penguins.
1. What should Sullivan and the Penguins do in goal?
Sullivan’s recent decisions when it comes to who started in goal were understandably scrutinized. DeSmith ranks highly among qualifying NHL goalies in both save percentage and goals-against average. Murray, meanwhile, is still viewed as the team’s No. 1 goalie and their best chance to win a third Stanley Cup in four years. The Penguins coach seems to be letting the situation sort itself out by giving them both playing time. Murray and DeSmith alternated the six games in nine days that preceded the holiday break, and they both played well. Murray has thrived in the past when he had another goalie pushing him. And DeSmith has given the Penguins a chance to win in most of his starts. So why not keep this going and let the best goalie – presumably Murray – seize the starting gig?
Read More

2. Can Kris Letang keep playing this well – and this much?
Letang, after admittedly struggling last season following neck surgery, has responded with one of the best starts of his excellent career. He has 28 points in 34 games and with eight goals already is on pace to set a career high. He has been very good defensively, too, using his speed to break up plays and his elite puck-moving skills to get the Penguins out of jams. Can he keep this going the rest of the way? The answer to that might be tied to his workload. Letang is playing more than 26 minutes per game, including 32 against the Washington Capitals last week. That would be the second-most minutes per game of his career. Letang does not appear to be slowing down, but if his performance dips in the second half, perhaps Sullivan will consider playing him fewer shifts each night.
3. What happens when Justin Schultz returns to the lineup?
Last we checked, the defenseman was still on track to return sometime in February or soon thereafter from the fractured ankle he suffered a few games into the season. The Penguins feel they currently have eight NHL-caliber defensemen on the roster. So what happens when Schultz returns? There’s no sense in worrying about that now. Injuries will happen, as we have seen with Letang, who has had a couple of scares already. The Penguins would be fortunate to be at full strength defensively when Schultz returns, which should conveniently be right around the NHL’s trade deadline. If they still have a surplus then, sure, general manager Jim Rutherford would listen to offers for some of his defensemen.
4. Speaking of Rutherford, what other moves might he make?
The one to keep an eye on is Derick Brassard. In an interview with the Post-Gazette this week, Rutherford essentially admitted that Brassard has been a disappointment since he was acquired in a trade last February. Brassard has been invisible offensively when not on a line with Sidney Crosby, and the Penguins need him to be a good third-line center, not a third wheel to Crosby and Jake Guentzel. And Brassard does not have much of a presence in the defensive end, either. At this point, it’s hard to envision him turning it around here, so he will be one to watch as the Penguins seek a better option in the middle of that third line. Beyond that, it’s hard to picture the Penguins doing anything major. They have all the cornerstones in place. They just need to find the right pieces to fit around them.
5. What about Phil Kessel, though? Could Rutherford trade him?
That does not seem like a bold move Rutherford and the Penguins would entertain in the middle of a season, especially now that the team has seemingly gotten back on track. They are rightfully in win-now mode, and it’s hard to imagine another team offering them a player or package of players that will give them more than Kessel is capable of giving. The mercurial right winger simply needs to play better, and he’s not alone.
6. When will Evgeni Malkin wake up from this midseason slumber?
Malkin’s play the past two months has been maddening. It’s actually pretty remarkable that the Penguins have climbed back to solid footing in the standings despite getting little at even strength from Malkin, Kessel and Brassard. Since Nov. 1, Malkin has only one even-strength goal while posting an alarming minus-18 rating. Malkin has gone through similar stretches in the past, eventually returning to a dominant level. Heck, he was one of the NHL’s “Three Stars” for October, so it’s doubtful he has hit an over-30 wall. Just as is the case with Kessel, the Penguins have to hope he gets out of this funk soon.
7. Have the Penguins finally found consistency? Or was last week a fluke?
While the Penguins picked up at least a point in 14 of their last 18 games, they would take two steps forward then a step or two back, such as when they followed up a big shootout win on Long Island with a total dud in Chicago. That might have changed last week. With their victories over Washington, Minnesota and Carolina, the Penguins won three straight games for the first time since their Western Canada trip in late October. They might now be building some momentum. Are they ready to emerge as legitimate Cup contenders? Or will they stumble again and fail to separate themselves from the metro mediocrity?
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel. Click here to subscribe to Matt’s weekly From The Point hockey newsletter.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.