Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday chat. Glad you could stop by. Let's get this thing started ...
JohnAl: Are you going to now write an article about how it's 'not working' with Malkin given that Brassard had more ice time than him last night?
Jason Mackey: I am not. We're also talking about a difference of 17 seconds. Sounds like you're a little put off I said Brassard at center (and with the Penguins). He has three goals and four points in his last 17 games. I don't think I'm the only one who's questioning the fit.
copall: Do you think the Pens will return Simon to the top line when he returns or will they leave well enough alone with the way Rust has been playing alongside Sid?
Jason Mackey: That's a good question. I think you probably leave well enough alone, honestly. Maybe try Simon with Brassard? I don't see how you can break up Sid and Rust right now, though. Remember, Simon can play both sides. ... But they're going to have 59, 87, 17, 46, 71, 81, 14, 19, 72 and 12 ... and someone's gonna wind up on the fourth line.
Terry: Hi Jason- really enjoy these chats!
Read More
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Terry. Appreciate that.
Guest: Are the penguins back in the game?
Jason Mackey: I think they've been back in it for a little now. All they need to do is getting the playoffs ... and be playing better/well. That has happened. Not saying they're a Stanley Cup contender at the moment. They're not. But they are back in it.
Terry: What is your honest take on Derick Brassard? What are the odds he doesn’t get traded? Do you think he can work with 14-19-72? Does he want to play here? Appreciate these chats!
Jason Mackey: I question whether he wants to, Terry, and thank you. I think he would rather be a top-six player somewhere else, but I don't think he has that choice. I think they really want to see this work, Sullivan especially. Which is one the reasons you're seeing him with Pearson and Hornqvist, two extremely hard-working players. Brassard is the most skilled player on the line, which may not be a bad thing.
Jimmie: Will Rust remain on the Crosby line when Hornquist returns?
Jason Mackey: Hey Jimmie, Hornqvist returned last night, and Rust stayed with Crosby. Hornqvist was with Pearson and Brassard on the third line.
Jeff Houston: I really like 19's game these past 3 games. I kno everyone hates on him, altho he has had same-better production of all 3rd C'c on every cup team since 06'. But alot of ppl dont realize that he has been a slow starter his whole career and usually breaks out about this time of season. I still think it would be a mistake to trade him. What are ur thoughts on 19?
Jason Mackey: I thought he was OK, Jeff, but that's about as far as I'll go. Sullivan obviously knows his team better than me or anyone here, so I don't fault him for wanting to see this thing through. But I do have my doubts. ... Bonino did stuff like this, too -- his March was also incredible -- but he also killed penalties, helped his linemates, was solid defensively, won battles. Brassard really isn't doing a ton of the other stuff, in addition to not scoring.
Ryan : Jason, what do you think is the biggest obstacle standing between the Pens and another deep run or Cup Championship?
Jason Mackey: There are a few. Toronto, Tampa and Washington, to start. Gotta get the same of goaltending they had two years ago. Gotta get Schultz back and tighter defensively as a whole. Bottom-six needs to be a bigger threat, somehow, someway, whether that's Teddy Blueger, Thomas Di Pauli or a trade. Lotta areas to patch up, but they have taken some steps in the right direction.
Ted: Is there any real truth behind the pens trading brassard to WIN? Heard they were linked to him? What does trading him honestly even serve they’d need to get another 3C
Jason Mackey: Hi Ted, please link the report or, at minimum, tell me where you heard it. Tough to comment on something blindly, but, no, I have not heard that that has been discussed.
Guest: Any trades in the mix to come as soon as the holiday freeze lifts? Or is GMJR content until the deadline?
Jason Mackey: It depends on how his team plays. If it stays like last night, likely not, although GMJR could do something to address his bottom-six scoring, particularly that third-line center spot if they deem Brassard to not be a fit. He'll be gone after the season, and they could at least try to get something for him. ... But GMJR is gonna wait and see what his team needs and which direction it's headed.
John: Jason.. Just a coincidence, dumb luck or coaches philosophy.. Last 3 years playoffs vs. Washington, someone from the Pens gets knocked out by a concussion. I think it is a deliberate coaches directive to try to injure Penguin players knowing that knocking them out will result in either no penalty (see T. Wilson vs. ZAR), of willing to accept the penalty vs. knowing chances to win are greatly enhanced by these obvious head shots.
Jason Mackey: Hi John, I don't think what happened last night was a "coaching directive." If it was, it had to be the world's dumbest directive: "If you get in a fight, punch the guy in the head." ... I do think there's a philosophy Washington has when it plays Pittsburgh and that's to play the Penguins hard, to disrupt their speed and skill with force. Columbus has done the same thing. The Penguins know this is coming. In years past, they moved the puck quicker than other teams can hit. Lately, not so much. But they can out-skill teams.
Ron: Who do you believe goes first? Brass ? Kessel? Maatta if any?
Jason Mackey: I would say Brass > Maatta > Phil ... although I'm not thinking any of the three are terribly likely right now.
Paul T: Hi Jason. Any chance there could be a Brassard trade by the deadline? Seems the most expendable player for the Pens, and may find a top 4 d-man for him?
Jason Mackey: If they traded Brassard, I'm not sure it would be four a top-four D. They're getting one of those in Schultz, and those prices tend to be crazy-high. Plus, they would have to fill awful confident they could backfill Brassard's spot.
Paul: Is Brassard’s poor play associated with low confidence? You are around these guys enough I’m sure to get to know their personalities
Jason Mackey: That's one way of putting it. I just don't think Brassard likes the role he's been cast in: bottom-six, not necessarily with skilled guys, having to play a more blue collar game. That's not how he wants to play, and I think it's showing. Confidence is part of it, because I see him as a shell of what he was with the Rangers and Ottawa, but the Penguins are also asking him to fit a square peg in a round hole.
Matt: Any idea where Simon will play tonight? I doubt they'd want to put him back with Sid given how well Rust has done
Jason Mackey: I don't think Sullivan will separate Rust and Sid. Rust is red-hot. ... Maybe with Malkin. I could see that making sense. Or even getting him with Brassard, to get Brassard with someone a little more skilled. It worked a lot in the preseason with Rust on the other wing.
Dave: If only one thing could be said to the team, my suggestion is no cross ice passes at either blue line. If they cut that out, that alone would make a big difference in games won. Your thoughts? Thanks for all the great work and hope it's a great Christmas for you and your family!
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Dave. Same to you. I think Sullivan would agree with you. It is maddening sometimes.
dave: I'm glad they won last night, but I thought Murray was shaky. There were lots of leaky pucks, and it seemed like he was having trouble finding the puck. What did you think?
Jason Mackey: I thought he was OK. Just OK. I didn't think he deserved the Vezina based on last night alone, but he did play in Washington, against the hottest team, didn't let Ovechkin score and gave up only one goal. I don't care how you get it done. That's pretty solid. Credit where it's due.
Isaac: Do you think the Penguins should trade Brassard? He simply has not worked here. What could they get for him? What kind of player would they look for next as a 3rd line Center? Maybe Tyler bozak if he’s available given St. Louis situation
Jason Mackey: Seems like you guys might wanna trade Brassard ... whew. ... Yeah, I would definitely explore it, although I'm not sure what they could get at this point. Maybe if they convince the other team that he's just not a fit and not broken, they could get something decent. But the results have been flat-out bad lately.
Jason Mackey: I would like Bozak a lot in that role, personally. Have no clue whether it's possible.
Mike C: Going off of what copall asked, where do you think Simon will go if it isn’t on the first line?
Jason Mackey: It'll either be with Malkin or Brassard. Depends on where they're at with ZAR and what they think might mesh with Brassard.
copall: Three or four times already this season the Pens followed a few less than inspiring games against average opponents with an inspiring win against a really good team. Do you sometimes think they need the pressure of quality competition to get up for games?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I think that's fair. I'll be interesting to see how they handle themselves tonight. Can they build on this one? That's the big story here for me.
Jer: How desperate is GMJR TO MAKE a trade? Is he ready to get rid of brass and what does that mean to Vegas being they helped get him
Jason Mackey: He's not desperate at all. HIs team just went on the road and beat the defending Stanley Cup champs. Jim is aggressive and entertains a lot of things, but I wouldn't call him desperate.
Mario: Who's in and who's out for the game tonight?
Jason Mackey: We'll find out when Sullivan talks at 5, but I would expect Riikola to be in for Oleksiak, Simon to play and DeSmith to get the start in net.
Chance: Have you heard about any defenseman the pens are looking at via trade?
Jason Mackey: I have not Chance, I'm sorry. I think they got their defensemen in Marcus Pettersson, to be honest.
Bill: Any word on Oleckziak in terms of injury status?
Jason Mackey: No. We'll find out when Sullivan talks at 5.
HB: Do you know why they played wilson over grant last night?
Jason Mackey: My guess would be in case anything got ugly with Tom Wilson. And just overall, Washington and its style ... a little bit of a tougher play Wilson > Grant.
Officer Sorrows : Is there any word on how the Penguins org feels about Zachary Lauzon’s future? Despite being a 2nd round pick, he had an abysmal 2017-18 season and now hasn’t played at all this season due to injury and he’s actively being pushed out by his team who acquired Noah Dobson and needs to move him to comply with QMJHL roster rules.
Jason Mackey: There has been no word, I'm sorry. That is something to look into, though. Thanks for the reminder. ... With everything else going on with the NHL club, haven't asked about Lauzon in a while.
Jo: 19 play isn’t that well so where can you see him play next reason and what’s his contract look like?
Jason Mackey: He's an unrestricted free agent after this season. Almost definitely he'll be gone then, if not before.
Guest: I may be alone in thinking this, but... Doesn't Jack Johnson seem to be playing pretty good lately? Or, is it just me? It's probably just me.
Jason Mackey: I think it's heresy if you say anything good about Jack Johnson in this space.
Reston Steeler Fan: Does the NHL have any plans to change the current playoff seeding format?
Jason Mackey: I think they're going to revisit it over the summer, but I do believe there's enough who like this current way -- I don't know why -- that it's hardly imminent.
Rob from Louisiana : Jason, why do you think the pens can will a hard fought, playoff calibe, win like last night but also the game before lose a 2 goal lead and seem like they don’t have an energy? And how do you think it’s fixed?
Jason Mackey: Honestly, Rob, I think some of it has to do with cockiness for lack of a better term. They thought they were OK up two the past two games. They survived a bit, but it's hardly sustained, and it bit them against the Ducks.
JohnAl: Brassard does help his linemates, is solid defensively and does win battles. But why let that get in the way of the Penguins media's latest scapegoat? Gotta trade a 3C away for reasons and stuff. Because he was somewhat aloof in interviews, he clearly hates it in Pittsburgh. It hasn't been the most natural fit, but dear god is the overreaction fierce on this one.
Jason Mackey: Boy, JohnAl, you REALLY like you some Brassard. I respect the opinion, but just because you don't agree with mine, all of a sudden Brassard is "the Penguins media's latest scapegoat?" He doesn't have a point in 13 of his last 17 games.
Normie: Hi Jason
Jason Mackey: Hi Normie.
Paul T: Any chance that there could be a Jack Johnson/Derek Brassard trade? Do you think Rikkola could slide into Johnson's spot and be as effective?
Jason Mackey: Only if the other team will give the Penguins all of its good players. ... Yes, I think Riikola could be close. But you're not going to get another team to take on Johnson's contract. You're just not.
FR: As much as the Penguins have had some success recently, there is still something missing with this team. Can Sullivan really justify having the likes of ZAR, Garrett Wilson, and Derek Grant in the lineup? The 4th line is streaky and to me is still lacking.
Jason Mackey: I think he can. Two of those three played against the Caps and won. If they continue to win, why not? Now, they probably need to produce more to make it sustainable, but there's a salary cap; your top guys make a lot of money; there's only so high they can go in those other spots. Yes, I think Blueger and Di Pauli deserve shots, too. But if they're winning games like last night, I think it's tough to justify wholesale changes.
JohnAl: Also, Di Pauli is injured. It takes about 10 minutes to do some research on the AHL.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, JohnAl. If I'm such an idiot, maybe it's time for you to find another chat.
Paul T: Jason,
Jason Mackey: Yes, Paul?
James: in this day and age with head injuries so scrutinized how can the NHL turn a blind eye to vicious hits and fighting?
Jason Mackey: It's a good question, James. But it is part of the sport. Sort of -- although not totally -- like boxing. It's always been there, and there will probably always been some strand of it.
Josh: Jason, with Brassard's struggles, is there really even a market out there currently for him? If so, would they contemplate calling up Teddy Blueger to fill the fourth line center role and bump Sheahen/Cullen to third line center? Also, at this point, what can be done to get more consistency from the forwards' defensive zone play? It seems like even with their wins over the last week+, the consistency is still not there as multiple goal leads are still being surrendered regularly.
Jason Mackey: Hi Josh. I think there would be a market. He has a solid track record and will be a UFA after the season -- I.e. low risk. Plus, I think the sell would be lack of fit. ... That would be a bit of a stretch on Sheahan or Cullen, and they would have to give Blueger a chance first. ... Would also be interested to see what they could get back in the way of a third-line center. ... As for what can be done ... I don't think a ton tactically. Sullivan is trying. Much of it is on the players.
JC: Hi Jasoni hope you and your family have a great Christmas. My question to you is, do you think the pens have any interest in Parayko ? I don’t know if you caught it or not but Darren Dreager was in NBC and listed some defenseman the pens might have interest in he was one of them. Who do you think would be a good right shot defenseman? One other question do they add a guy to there top 6? Do you think Brass or Phil are likely to be traded? Thank you
Jason Mackey: Thanks, JC. I think they would have interest, yes, but I think the acquiring cost and cap situation would make it impossible, to be honest with you. Would love him back there, but I don't see it happening for myriad reasons. ... I think there's a possibility on Brass, no on Phil. ... Top-six probably not. They have enough there. Thanks.
Normie: Good day Jason. The pens have to be pleased with Petterson's play. It was a nice hockey trade for both sides.
Jason Mackey: Agree and they agree. Kid's a very good player.
GPT: I used to think Brassard was great when he was with the NYR and OTT. He doesn't look like the same player now, poor fit or not. With a relatively minor cap hit, could the Pens expect a decent return if they wanted to move him?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think the return would be decent if they decided to go that route.
Guest: Love your work - would read your shopping list if you posted it! Happy Holidays to you and your growing family!
Jason Mackey: Ha. Is this my wife? Thank you for the kind words, though.
Jack: I mean this in the nicest way possible. But does 19 realize how unliked he is in PITT?
Jason Mackey: If he checks out this chat, he'll notice. ... Everyone except JohnAl, that is.
Paul T: Jason, how much of allowing Johnson to stay in the lineup is related to how much he makes? Seems to be stuck in the line up, when Rikkola could be of more of a success on D.
Jason Mackey: I think Johnson has been fine on the third pair with Pettersson. Everyone wants to blame Johnson, but he's been on the ice for four five-on-five goals in the past nine games. Letang, Dumoulin, Maatta and Oleksiak have all been on for more.
Jeff Houston: In a perfect world tho, I still put 19 with 87 & 59 and look for a more Defensive 3rd line C in a trade for 1 of our 6 LHD - (Faksa DAL- My dream, Danault MTL, Lowery WPG) and then at the deadline we could beg LA for Hags back for picks with the Cap space saved from Schultz ??
Jason Mackey: That's a fair point, Jeff. What about Brassard with Sid and Jake and Sheahan as your 3C? I could see it, although at the moment I wouldn't do a thing with Rust. And I think you need to not block Simon on the right side, either. ... I don't think the centers you mentioned would balance for a trade with, say, Oleksiak; they'd probably have to part with Maatta, although I think you'd be OK with that. ... The Schultz money is only good as long as he's out, meaning once he's back, they have to be cap compliant. So they could get Hagelin back, but there likely would have to be a corresponding move to free up money.
Guest: Does Oleksiak become the odd man out when Schultz comes back?
Jason Mackey: Could be. I think it also might depend on injuries. That's a long time off from now. A lot can happen.
Alex: Hey Jason. Which is/was the worse defensive unit? The 2017 Cup team or the defenseman now?
Jason Mackey: I think the group now.
guest: Hi Jason, happy holidays to you! Poor Oleksiak, he stands up for his team and teammates and Wilson seems to get just an extra second or so head start and he is put in an awkward position. I wish Wilson was man enough to just go toe to toe and not have to swoop in like that.
Jason Mackey: I had no problem with how Wilson handled that last night. He answered the bell and would decisively. He's done a lot of dirty stuff in his career. I'm not putting this in that category.
Reston Steeler Fan: The NBCSN guys (Dreger) were talking about Rutherford doing something to counter Tom Wilson. Mentioned several players who could be available and would stand up to Wilson. Have you heard any rumors or do you believe they would trade for someone who is geared to counter Wilson?
Jason Mackey: I have not, and I don't think that's a direction they would legitimately go. Sullivan is gonna want to be speed, speed, speed. Didn't work with Reaves. Won't happen now.
FlowerPower: How about Matt Murray Jason he looks good and also do you think the pens go for D-man depth or top 6 depth??
Jason Mackey: He did look good, although I wouldn't say great. But better than earlier this season, for sure. Looks healthy. Just needs to knock more of the rust off. I think GMJR is still trying to figure his target out, to be honest.
Lee: I’m not an expert in hockey so this question is perhaps amateurish. Why with 2 minutes left in the game and an extra attacker on the ice did the Penguins seem less aggressive and stay on defense? To my non expert eye, they seemed to throttle down and resign themselves to taking body shots. In previous power plays they seemed much more aggressive to extent they stole puck and played offense. Seems like sitting back letting Ovechkin fire bombs will ultimately fail them? The result was good this time but really hard to watch. #anxiety
Jason Mackey: Ha. Welcome to hockey, Lee. They're trying to not give up a softie.
Alex: Does the team still talk about Fleury or act like they still miss him?
Jason Mackey: They've moved on. Those who knew him obviously love him, but that ship sailed a while ago.
HB: I was sad to see Team Canada dropped Addison do you think he will make the team next year at the world juniors.
Jason Mackey: Certainly seems like he's on that path, HB.
Dave: Merry Christmas Jason...the 4th line has been quite good lately and I really liked 7/15 together....are those two together what was envisioned at the beginning of the season? Who are your best bottom 6 to get us on a deep cup run barring trades?
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't mind seeing either Simon or ZAR get a shot with those two. They're completely different approaches, but they could work. I want Hornqvist in the top-six ... or at least on a souped-up third line. I'm OK dropping the two guys I mentioned.
guest: Watching the Pens Caps games are some of the best but to be honest I am stressed out the entire time worried that one of our players is going to be hurt by a Wilson/Ovie/Oshie cheap shot.
Jason Mackey: They certainly take a physical approach with the Penguins. Can understand what you're saying, for sure.
Rich: Looks like Murray may be returning to form. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, he might not suck after all. (This is sarcasm based on all the vitriol directed his way earlier this season.) Murray has it in there. It's just a matter of finding it again, and I think that's going very well right now.
Mario: Is it me or is there a problem with the timing of the line changes? Last night, that awful line change led to a goal. At one point Crosby was on his own in Washington's end with the puck and two or three Washington players were on him. No Penguins were in sight to help Crosby.
Jason Mackey: I think they're a little careless with that stuff. Have been a lot this season. That's a detail thing Sullivan talks about often. And it's players needing to be more aware more than anything.
guest: I bet the dad
Jason Mackey: Take the over.
JB : 1-1/2 years of Brassard with salary retention only netted Ottawa Gustavsson (a goalie prospect who’s 3-4 years from being NHL ready if at all), a 1st (again not a sure thing and far from being NHL ready) and Ian Cole (bottom pair UFA D flipped for a 3rd) — how exactly would trading him net us any kind of win now value?
Jason Mackey: If they got a third-line center who fit here, helped the third line produce more -- a la HBK -- and the Penguins used that to go on a late-season run.
jack in NY: I kind of like Rust with crosby and guentzel. now that simon is back, who goes where?
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't touch that top line. I'd try Simon with Malkin or Brassard, depending on a few other factors.
Kenny: Was the toe tapped puck into the net by Sid skill or luck? Mah-gawd the reflex at that speed is crazy.
Jason Mackey: Skill. It's incredible. I don't know how he does that stuff. Nobody does.
Mario: During the first or second intermission last night, the NBC analysts were discussing the Pen's trade talk. I missed what they were saying. What rumors are floating out there that they were discussing?
Jason Mackey: They always get discussed here, Mario. ... I've been asked about potentially getting someone to combat Wilson in the playoffs. They tried that once with Reaves, and we all saw how that movie ended. I can't see it happening again.
jack in NY: With a struggling powerplay, was there ever a thought just to keep the lines together as powerplay units?
Jason Mackey: Not really. Those guys were historically dominant last season. They didn't suddenly forget how to function on the power play. Patience. They'll get there.
Bobby: Speaking hypothetically here (I know the team doesn't want to do it), but do you think another NHL team would take Jack Johnson and his contract? Or would you have to give them picks and prospects to do it. Basically, I'm asking how he is viewed around the league. And if that has changed since this summer.
Jason Mackey: Speaking realistically, no. Five years for a guy his age? No way.
Double M: Hey Jason – Keep up the great work at PG and with these weekly chats, very insightful. Of all the cities you travel which is your favorite and why? Also, do you regularly meet up with opposite NHL teams columnists and compare notes? Happy Holidays!
Jason Mackey: My top five would probably be: San Jose (close to San Fran), Vancouver, D.C., Manhattan and Montreal. ... Buffalo, Columbus, Long Island, Raleigh and Boston are close. ... Yes, there's a nice camaraderie among hockey writers. It's one of the things I like most about this job. We don't always get together -- it depends on the city -- but yes, we'll hang out with visiting writers and even amongst ourselves. Yohe, Bradford and I watched Steelers-Raiders together; Bombulie had a later flight, so he couldn't make it.
Guest: How frustrated do you think Ruhwedel is right now?
Jason Mackey: He shouldn't be. This is his role. Although I could understand him wanting to go somewhere else next season to play.
GPT: For all who bemoaned giving up Oskar Sundqvist and moving down 20 spots in the draft to get him, Reaves sure would have helped last night
Jason Mackey: I agree. I think Sullivan should've been more OK playing him 8-10 minutes a night. I think he would've been good for the Penguins. Never understood why he wasn't given more of a chance.
JohnAl: Bozak is your big solution for Brassard? A man being paid 5 million dollars a year, doesn't PK and is more suited to top 6 C role than a bottom 6 role? You're going to encounter the same issues you think are so devastating right now?
Jason Mackey: I'm willing to bet Bozak can fit with Kessel better than Brassard does now, and that would be worth it to me.
Jeff Houston: BOZAK ???? That is a screaming Hells to NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO33 yr old Slow C with $5m cap hit for next 5 yrs
Jason Mackey: The contract drops over the next three ... down to $4.25 million in the final year. It would also have to be amended. ... A second counter-arguement would be this: Wasn't Bonino not the greatest skater, too?
Mike: Any word on Oleksiak for tonight's game?
Jason Mackey: Not until 5.
Wilbury: Do GMJR and HCMS believe Shultz will be effective upon his return? Or might his injury impact his performance until next year? A lot of us seem to be banking on his returning to top form right away.
Jason Mackey: They're expecting him to return to top form this season, absolutely.
Guest: What do you think we get tonight? Inspired/building of last night performance, or non-interested, phone it in, upright skating Malkin type performance?
Jason Mackey: I think it's actually the first one: inspired, building some momentum.
Rachel: Hey Jason!!! Love your reports!! Any clue on an actual update on Jamie's status?
Jason Mackey: Not until 5.
GPT: Small sample size, but I like what I've seen from Pettersson. What do the Pens see his ceiling as?
Jason Mackey: I don't know if they know. Maybe a Dumoulin type. But he needs to get bigger, one. And maybe get a little more comfortable on the offensive end.
Paul T: Who would win if they fought.....Sid or Ovie?
Jason Mackey: Crosby. Ovechkin would come out hot early, maybe get in a few shots, but Sid would outlast Ovie.
Elijah: Hypothetically, if the pens were to trade someone , do you think they would go for a depth scorer or a d man?
Jason Mackey: Depth scorer.
Wilbury: Bleier comes out of the quiet to rip on the Steelers coaching a week ago and the next week Dupuis does the same. Who will appear next week and which coach and team will be criticized?
Jason Mackey: I didn't think what Dupuis said was that bad, honestly.
LA Matt: Is Murray back or is it too soon to make that determination?
Jason Mackey: Maybe a little soon, but he has been very good since returning. That's fair to say.
LA Matt: How is Tom Wilson still in the NHL?
Jason Mackey: He's a very good player, Matt. He's obviously not the most ... legal hockey player. But he can certainly play the game. It's a shame he does all the stupid stuff, honestly. Just play a hard, legal game, and he's good.
Albert: Observations from last night: 1) Man, when these teams play, what intensity, what great hockey. 2) Glad Letang is on our team, an absolute beast of a hockey player; 3) Is it me or does Murray have a problem with the area between his arms and body, where the puck always seems to leak through
Jason Mackey: What sort of problem would that be? That he doesn't have another limb there? There's only so many areas to shoot at. That's one of them with him. I don't think it's a "problem."
guest: I know Guentzel is not in Malkin's league, but what message does that send to bench Guentzel mid game for a bad mistake but Malkin has made many bad mistakes this season with no consequence?
Jason Mackey: Malkin played 14:30ish last night. Wouldn't say he was benched, but Malkin has had his ice time cut, too. But, yeah, we're talking professional sports here. Guentzel makes < $1 million. Malkin makes $9.5 million. Rules are going to be different.
LA Matt: Will we ever see the day where fighting is completely outlawed in the game? Although it is down dramatically from the 70s-90s, it still detracts from what should be considered a top three sport!
Jason Mackey: I agree, Matt, but I honestly don't think it will ever go away. It's always been a part of hockey, and I think there are too many in favor of it to ever take it out.
Jay: What teams need a player like 19 so we can give them him
Jason Mackey: Ha. I do think Brassard could fit a lot of places. I'm just not convinced it'll be here.
Bobby: Johnson and Pettersson have been playing extremely sheltered minutes since the trade? Meanwhile the Oleksiak-Maatta pairing has been getting tougher deployments. Has Pettersson shown enough for Sullivan to move him up the lineup?
Jason Mackey: We may find out tonight, to be honest. ... Although if I were Sullivan, I might just bring in Riikola and play him with Maatta. The Finns have been good together.
Mike: Why is it so hard for the Pens to find a 3rd center that fits?
Jason Mackey: Because they're trying to check a lot of boxes. A little offense. A little PK and defense. Preferably play with speed, although in Bonino's case, know how to function otherwise with smart outlets and using people like Hagelin and Kessel to your advantage. Be OK playing on the third line and fewer minutes because of 87 and 71 and also with less favorable wingers.
John: Why all the obsession with Brassard? Real question. So much else going on with this team and everyone asking the same question.
Jason Mackey: I can't tell people what to ask, John.
Isaac: Who do you think have been their best bottom sixers? Like rank ZAR, Cullen, Grant, Pearson, Sheehan, Rust, Simon, Wilson, etc
Jason Mackey: Rust, Simon, Pearson, ZAR, Sheahan, Cullen, Grant, Wilson.
Albert: Why is the NHL the only league that allows fighting? It's a joke! It disrupts the game, it is so contrived, its a horrible example for young fans... football is far more physical/violent, yet they don't need to police themselves with in-game fighting.
Jason Mackey: Man, people are hating on fighting today. Interesting.
Bevis: Do u think Jack Johnson has been trying to teach the other Dman when not to pinch?
Jason Mackey: I'm guessing no.
Rachel: I think ZAR has been doing great!! Maybe that's just me
Jason Mackey: I think ZAR has been good, too. He's at least a lineup regular, IMO.
George: What’s the secret sauce to get Malkin/Kessel up to their standard?
Jason Mackey: Thousand Island and ketchup.
Guest: Where can I find specific times of individual hockey players skating specific distances--something like NFL listing each player's time in the 40. Is there no absolute way to determine which team is faster?
Jason Mackey: There is not, to my knowledge.
Bobby: What does Jack Johnson need to do to get scratched? He's tried, repeated pushing his teammates into his goalie, prioritizing hitting over proper positioning, repeatedly shooting the puck into the defender in front of him, and disrupting any puck movement in the offensive zone. It really looks like he's doing everything he can to have a nice seat in the press box. Maybe he should try kicking Sullivan's dog next?
Jason Mackey: They're not going to scratch Jack Johnson. I'm also refusing to blame everything on him. Past nine games he's been on the ice for fewer five-on-five goals against than Letang, Dumoulin, Maatta and Oleksiak. Just four. That's not terrible.
Olli: Mack...I have not been standing out lately, pretty good deal eh?
Jason Mackey: Yes, Olli. Nice work.
Greg T: I'm very thankful the Pens have won 3 Cups in the Sid era. But with their barren farm, aging roster, and ton of money dedicated to a suspect defense, I have a hard time seeing them as a serious contender for a while. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I don't agree. They have some players in Wilkes, they're roster isn't aging, and I think they're closing to being a competitor.
Guest: What happens to the defence when Schultz is back? Do the Penguins keep all seven of Letang, Dumoulin, Schultz, Maatta, Pettersson, Johnson, and Oleksiak?
Jason Mackey: I think you'll probably see a trade if someone isn't injured.
FR: Rudolph, Frosty, or the Grinch? Who's your favorite?
Jason Mackey: Grinch.
Joe: Do you think rusty will stay on the first line. I don't think coach can resist Simon.
Jason Mackey: Yes, I do.
Aljohn: JohnAl is an imposter but I also like brassard. And so do a lot of pens fans with the capacity to see him for what he is and actually understand the game.
Jason Mackey: Thank you for that.
Shane: The Pens did a Mom’s trip in 2014, but since then have done 4 straight Dad’s trips. Is this to avoid Kessel’s mom screaming obscenities at Sid like she use to when he was a child playing high school hockey. (link to the famous story: http://letsgodu.blogspot.com/2007/01/dont-you-wish-you-witnessed-this-...)
Jason Mackey: I don't think so, but that's hilarious. Honestly, I did not know about that. They're due for a Mom's Trip. I'll bet it happens next season. They should just alternate them.
Sof: A lot of people always seem to be on board the "trade maatta" train, but is he actually that easily replaceable within the organization?
Jason Mackey: They have a lot of D right now and another in the minors, Ethan Prow, tearing it up. I like Olli and probably wouldn't trade him, but I would listen based on circumstance.
J: Do you see the penguins possibly getting a more physical type of top 6 forward at the deadline?
Jason Mackey: I could see them getting someone who's a little more physical because they could use that style. But not someone exclusively to handle Wilson as was floated on NBCSN last night.
Bobby: "I think Johnson has been fine on the third pair with Pettersson. Everyone wants to blame Johnson, but he's been on the ice for four five-on-five goals in the past nine games. Letang, Dumoulin, Maatta and Oleksiak have all been on for more." They also have been on the ice a lot more and against much harder competition. Pettersson-Johnson has been super sheltered. There was one game where they only had one D zone start.
Jason Mackey: That's completely fair.
Mike From The South Hills: Please start blocking Brassard comments...too many lazy people ask the same questions instead of looking what has already been answered.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, Mike has a good idea. Not gonna push through any more repeats.
Guest: Why did the media make such a big deal about Dupius’ comments when the media makes those same comments all time time and Dupuis is pretty much just media now?
Jason Mackey: It only became a big story, in my opinion, when Sullivan reacted the way he did. That's the only time I wrote anything, then I called Dupuis to give him a chance to clarify. I can't speak for anyone else.
Guest: Why are people expecting Schultz to be the saviour of the defense when he was very not good at defense last year?
Jason Mackey: He did lead the team in plus/minus last year. It's not a perfect stat, but it's not nothing, either.
guest: The dad's trip seems alot of fun. Do you get to interact with the dad's when covering the team?
Jason Mackey: Some but not a ton. Only a couple that I know -- Aston-Reese's, Guentzel, Crosby -- but yeah, it does seem like they have a blast on those.
dave: Do you think they have any interest in Bergland? He was waived by BUF, and he might be a better 3C than Brassard.
Jason Mackey: Not that I've heard, no. But Rutherford does explore a lot of options.
Wilbury: Might this be the best time for GMJR to offload the high priced Rust? I know, he's been on the scoresheet lately, all the more reason to move him while you can offload that cap hit.
Jason Mackey: Absolutely not. Not a chance.
chris: Given the penguins’ third line over the last several years plays more like most teams second lines, is there really a big difference for Brassard playing on the penguins’ third line instead of another team’s second line?
Jason Mackey: In the quality of wingers, yes. And the ice time he gets.
Guest: Outside of attending games, what does your day look like? How much time do you spend doing research, writing, etc.?
Jason Mackey: I usually spend an hour every morning researching, then 10:30-2 reporting/writing ... maybe an afternoon nap on gamedays, then like 5-midnight or so back at the rink. ... Practice days are different. Honestly, pretty much every day is different with travel and everything. One of the perks of the hockey beat for me.
Fred: When is the trade deadline? Is it possible that GMJR doesn’t trades at all
Jason Mackey: It's possible but I wouldn't say likely. I think he'll do something before. It's usually around the end of February. I don't know an exact date off-hand.
Wilbury: What are your thoughts on grudges and doghouses: do they have a place in sports (recall the accusations against Sully)? Do members of the media hold grudges against certain players?
Jason Mackey: I don't think media does, no. And if they did, what would it matter? I think coaches have thoughts on players. I wouldn't call it a doghouse, but it's their prerogative to determine when a guy can help and when he can't.
DTrain: Did you get the sense Sprong was disliked by the team at the time of the trade? I remember the Uber story from his rookie year, but was wondering if he matured/teammates warmed up to him?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. Teammates were fine with him. The trade had nothing to do with that.
GPT: Are you still amazed that the Pens gave Johnson a five year term? Who did they think they were bidding against?
Jason Mackey: Detroit and Anaheim was my understanding.
guest: Do you think the players are update with Dupois comments? especially since he was just in town and treated like rolyalty
Jason Mackey: No, they aren't. They knew about them, but I don't think they thought he was sharing secrets. He was just making an observation.
JohnAl: "The contract drops over the next three ... down to $4.25 million in the final year. It would also have to be amended"
That's not how cap hits work.
Jason Mackey: Yes it is. St. Louis would have to take back money to make it work for the Penguins.
Christian: Jason, GMJR has made some good trades since they last won the cup (Oleksiak, Pettersson, etc). However he’s also made MORE trades that have been misses. Do you think this could have something to do with missing Botterill? I’m not questioning GMJR as a GM but since Botterill has been gone there’s been more misses than hits.
Jason Mackey: I can't say it's not but it's hard to say specifically that it is.
Seriously?: Perhaps use one of the many resources available to you Jason. Bozak’s AAV does not drop. https://www.capfriendly.com/players/tyler-bozak
Jason Mackey: Thank you. My mistake. I was looking at the wrong column. Again, I apologize. I was wrong here, working too fast.
guest: do you think the comments Dupuis said will affect the Pens bringing him back to work for the team in some capacity in the future?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. But I think they will let the dust settle a bit first.
PA Girl: I have to take my blood pressure meds early on hockey nights. Last night was no exception. Do you think the holiday break will affect any momentum the team gets going?
Jason Mackey: It could, but if they truly have turned a corner, I think it's entirely possible they'll be able to sustain it. The next two games will tell us a lot about where they are.
Normie: Jason, you are now 2-0 when predicting a Friday win in your Thursday chat. Sounds like you like Pens Again tonight?
Joe: Jason thanks for the chats. What is the ceiling on Blueger? If he gets called up, will he be centering the third or fourth line?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think that's reasonable. Probably starting with the fourth line and seeing where it goes from there.
Mike: I missed what Dupris said. Is there a link to it?
Jason Mackey: Sure. Here you go: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/12/19/Pittsburgh-Pen...
A Yinzer: Wilson is scum of the Earth when will the NHL ban him? I expect a suspension from last night for what he did that was really dirty!
Jason Mackey: All he did was fight, as they agreed upon.
PA Girl: I think Pearson, Petterson, and Aston-Reese have all been contributors. I think Guentzel seems a little off - kinda like an adolescent who is trying to grow into his limbs. Or is it just me?
Jason Mackey: I don't have any problem with what Guentzel has done this season. Been way more good than bad. He's still a somewhat young player. That stuff is gonna happen.
GPT: Somehow I imagine so many folks wouldn't be up in arms if Oleksiak had pulverized Wilson
Jason Mackey: Very true.
Bobby: Is there any concern in the organization that the version of Matt Murray from this year (besides last night) and last season is what he actually is rather than what he did in the previous year?
Jason Mackey: No, there's not. They think he's going to be fine, and I happen to agree with them.
Hal 9000: I don't understand the Brassard hate. He's doing great at playing Center where he is. I don't generally expect my Centers to score goals that's what my wingers are for. Care to explain why the Media is out to get him just like they were with Kessel over the summer?
Jason Mackey: The media isn't out to get him, Hal. He simply hasn't done much when he's been in there. The numbers back that up.
Paul T: How much of the criticism of Kessel's play do you think is related to his relationship with Sully?
Jason Mackey: I don't think any of it, to be honest with you. When he's been criticized, it's been when he's turning the puck over and being a non-factor. That's not Sullivan's fault.
Kelli: I believe they have what it takes. Packaging it neatly & unleashing it is another story
Jason Mackey: Great point, Kelli.
Loyal Fan: I was shown a WAR chart and being told that it shows that Brassard is the 2nd worst skater on the team, but of course they ignore the fact that according to the exact same chart Olli is the 2nd best skater on the team. Do you think that makes the case that, that specific chart is wrong and Brassard isn't nearly as bad as people say he is?
Jason Mackey: I think that chart makes some sense. It's not perfect, but it does show that Brassard is not infallible.
Andrew: Sorry if this was already said, but I thought Riley Sheahan was noticeable (in the good way) last night. And do you still believe Johnson is a capable defender? I’m not sure Pens can get to the promised land deploying their current 2nd and 3rd d-pairs. Too many bottom pairing (at best) guys.
Jason Mackey: I think Sheahan was good last night, I agree. And I do think Johnson fits ... as long as he's on your third pair and nothing more.
Andrew: Jack Johnson has also been on the ice less than those guys. Imagine how much people would drool over Pettersson if he had a favorable partner.
Jason Mackey: I think that pair has been fine, honestly.
Guest: Do you know who in the scouting staff would be most involved with New England prep? Curious as to who might have found about Liam Gorman seeing he’s a very under the radar guy.
Jason Mackey: I don't, I'm sorry. They don't divulge those sorts of things, although Kevin Stevens does handle some of the Boston area, I know that.
Justin: With Sullivan seemingly set with the netminders (DeSmith and Murray). What do you see happening with Jarry?
Jason Mackey: Status quo for now. I think they see how this plays out and what happens with DeSmith over the summer, whether they're able to bring him back.
Joey: What are your thoughts on a Kessel-Sheahan combination for a 3rd line? They played pretty well for a couple weeks before last season's trade deadline. I believe Sheahan can be a very good 3rd line center for this team.
Jason Mackey: I think it's worth exploring again, but this season it hasn't been very good. Kessel has been awfully quiet when deployed with Sheahan, and they can't have that.
Brad: which cup run is your favorite from the Crosby/Malkin era so far?
Jason Mackey: My pick would be 2017, because I got to cover it. Selfish, I know.
Drop The Puck: Assuming that the Penguins are still on the fringe of making the playoffs at the trade deadline, who is most likely to move? Brassard since he's in the final year of his contract? Oleksiak or Maata? When Schultz returns, who is likely to be his partner on the second line?
Jason Mackey: I'm thinking Maatta, honestly. I'd say, at this point, Brassard is probably most likely to go.
Flower30: What do you think about our current goalie situation and do you think GMJR will make any moves to change/fix it?
Jason Mackey: I don't think he'll do a thing if Murray keeps playing this way. They're fine with this version of Murray, if it sticks.
The Not Grinch: If you could trade for any player (not counting a McDavid), who would it be? And why would he fit with the Pens?
Jason Mackey: Vince Trocheck from the Panthers to center their third line.
Guest: Did you hear the story of Riikola and the young kid?
Jason Mackey: I did not.
Andrew: How about simon with 87 and 17 and move Jake down with Brass since they seemed to have a little chemistry when playing on 87 line?
Jason Mackey: Eh, I like Jake with Sid, and I don't wanna bust that up.
4D Chess: Do you think that Sully and the Penguins will go out of their way to never get a 2 goal lead ever again so they don't blow it and instead just win 1 goal games?
Jason Mackey: Umm, I don't think they'd use that strategy, no.
Jon : let me try again (good afternoon), with all the lefties on D, do you think Maata will be moved?
Jason Mackey: I think it's unlikely. They like him a lot.
Christian: Jason, to utilizes Malkin’s one timer on the power play has Gonchar ever worked with Schultz/Letang for better passes over to Malkin? When Gonchar was playing he setup Malkin so well for one timers on the PP
Jason Mackey: He has ... although he's worked with them on a variety of things. Not just that.
Guest: https://www.pensburgh.com/2018/12/17/18144353/pittsburgh-penguins-sign... since you didn’t hear about it :)
Jason Mackey: That's neat! Thanks for sharing!
JohnAl: What is a more useless stat, WAR,GAR, K or GS?
Jason Mackey: I'll go with GS.
Brayden: I know Johnson has struggled when playing quicker teams, and I’m far from his biggest fan. But I think he did an incredible job of clearing the front of the net last night! If played properly, and contained within his comfort zone, do you think he can be the player they need him to be??
Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. I'm not as down on Johnson as a lot of people.
Katie: Have we learned why Pettersson is called the Dragon yet?
Jason Mackey: No. I have not heard that one.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Got some stuff to do this afternoon before the game. Thanks for participating!





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.