The Penguins had the Anaheim Ducks right where they wanted them Monday.
Down one goal, their fans on their feet and Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Co. getting nearly four minutes of power-play time, including 17 seconds of a 5-on-3 advantage.
OK, fine. They still would have preferred to have the lead and probably about 15 more shots at that point. But after a 2-0 lead became a 3-2 deficit, they got a great opportunity early in the third period to tie up a game they had little business winning.
“The true testament to a real good power play is scoring at the right times,” coach Mike Sullivan later said. “Our guys know that, and they’ve been so good at it for so long.”
About four minutes into the third, Ducks winger Ondrej Kase headed to the penalty box to feel shame. The Penguins, as has been the case fairly often the past several games, struggled to get their power play set up and failed to generate consistent pressure.
But after the Penguins attempted just two shots during the first 1:43 of that penalty, defenseman Josh Manson hauled down Olli Maatta and went to keep Kase company.
Read More
The Penguins started to threaten. Malkin fired a slapshot as Kase was escaping the box. Jake Guentzel pushed a puck just wide of the post a moment later. After a Ducks clear, he had their best chance yet when he was left alone inside the right circle. But Ducks goalie and Whitehall native John Gibson gobbled up Guentzel’s rising shot from 18 feet.
Derick Brassard, leading the second unit, made a nifty play to get off a snapshot from the right faceoff dot. Gibson got that one, too, and the Ducks killed the second penalty.
That opportunity squandered, the Penguins went on to lose, 4-2, at PPG Paints Arena.
“There’s not much power play every game. A couple of power plays,” said Malkin, who got a power-play tally in the first period. “And to help the team win we need to score.”
Malkin’s goal, the lone one the Penguins scored on their four power plays Monday, was nothing spectacular. Malkin simply fired the puck past a Guentzel screen and it squeezed under Gibson’s glove. Where Malkin aligned on that play, however, was noteworthy.
The Penguins power play has grown stagnant of late. And with Patric Hornqvist out of the lineup and unable to give the unit some grit and sustained possession, it has mostly looked out of sorts. They have gone just 2-for-16 with him out the past six games.
Their power play has connected at 22.6 percent in the regular season with Hornqvist since they acquired him in 2014. That rate plummets to 16.2 percent without him.
“He just brings intensity and a work ethic that I think is important to any power play,” Crosby said recently. “Usually your power play has a lot of skill. But I think the work ethic and outworking the penalty kill that you’re playing against is always a really important thing.”

Zooming out a bit, the Penguins have not scored multiple power-play goals in a game in more than a month. Since Nov. 17, they have scored eight power-play goals, which, yeah, isn’t bad. Until you remember they coughed up five shorthanded goals over that span.
So Sullivan often went with an inverted look on their power plays against Anaheim.
Malkin typically hovers somewhere along the right wall, with Phil Kessel across from him in the left circle. Crosby roves around the net, usually somewhere off the right post. Sullivan had them line up on opposite sides Monday, perhaps trying to shake up that group.
That was not a new look. The Penguins have busted it out sporadically this season. While it made it difficult to tee up one-timers from the circles since it put Kessel and Crosby and/or Malkin on their strong sides, it seemed to encourage a more downhill approach.
The results were mixed, in part because the Ducks made it difficult for them to get anything set up in the first place. The Penguins got just nine shots on goal when up a man.
“We try change. Today we changed sides, me and Phil,” Malkin said. “We scored [the] first power play and not again. We tried to play casually. We [played] easy, you know? I don’t know.”
Malkin said they must shoot more and support each other when pressured. He also thinks they need to work on their zone entries, which were a big factor in the Penguins, with these same players, setting a franchise record for power-play percentage last season.
He compared their recent struggles entering the zone to a “ping pong game.”
Sullivan, however, is choosing to focus on the positives, at least publicly. He pointed to their winning goal against the Los Angeles Kings on Saturday. Scored by Kessel on a 4-on-3 power play in overtime, that came on a busted play, though they earned it with a little hustle. Malkin beat a couple of Kings to a loose puck and poked it to an open Kessel.
“When you look at their overall body of work, I think they’ve improved as of late,” Sullivan said Monday. “They had some good looks in [Saturday’s 4-3 win]. They scored in the overtime. But even in regulation at 5-on-4, they had some really good looks. We had some good looks again [against the Ducks] and we scored on one of the power plays.”
All that said, though, Sullivan noted expectations are higher here, where the Penguins trot out four All-Stars and another 20-goal scorer in Guentzel or Hornqvist.
The Penguins rank 11th in the league for scoring on 22.8 percent of their power-play opportunities. That’s still pretty good. But last season, they converted on a team-record 26.2 percent — a significant factor in the Penguins finishing second in the Metropolitan Division.
Plus, when this group is clicking, they seem to more often than not bury goals — and their opponents — when they give them power plays in critical moments, like the Ducks did.
“We’ve got a chance to tie the game there and I think those critical moments are important for power plays,” Sullivan said. “It’s not always about the numbers. Sometimes it’s about rising to the occasion at the key times when your team needs a goal.”
He added: “I thought in the third period that was a missed opportunity for us.”
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel. Click here to subscribe to our weekly From The Point hockey newsletter.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.